Philadelphia 1787 was not a runaway convention

So explains my Independence Institute colleague Rob Natelson, on his Our American Constitution blog. Forty-eight of the 55 delegates had instructions which allowed them to go beyond amending the Articles of Confederation.

Rob’s research into early American history has found that constitutional conventions (for a new constitution, or to amending an existing document) had well-established procedures by the time of the Framing. Click here for post that will provide a summary, and to lead to Rob’s extensive analysis of original sources. As Rob explains, constitutional conventions for a balanced budget, or other salutary (in my view) purposes have been blocked in part by fears raised by the John Birch Society that a new convention would run away like the Philadelphia Convention did, or that the procedures of a new convention are completely unclear. To the contrary, the procedures are clear, and neither the Philadelphia Convention nor its early American analogues exceeded their mandate.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by Woo Themes