More on Grade Inflation:
The recent discussion reminded me of Justice Blackmun's law school transcript, which I saw in Linda Greenhouse's Becoming Justice Blackmun (p. 12). The grades of the future Supreme Court Justice, Harvard Law '32:
2 As.
4 Bs.
8 Cs.
3 Ds.
But before folks start up with the snide comments, note that this put him just shy of the top 25% of the class (120th out of 451).
Related Posts (on one page):
Oh well, just goes to show, inflation corrodes value.
I can say, from having interviewed dozens upon dozens of law school students when I was an associate for several years at a very large--more than 1000 lawyers---corporate law firm, the big firm perception was that grade inflation generally followed the prestige of the school (US News &WR rankings), with the higher ranking schools have more grade inflation.
The disparate grading systems at law schools meant, for the "summer associate" program, that we didn't hire someone primarily based on his or her grades, but we did use (1) poor grades, at top schools and second tier schools, to reject people out of hand (no interviews offered); (2) truly exceptional grades from less prestigious schools to offer interviews to students who otherwise might not get in the door; and (3) high class rankings or designations (magna cum laude, etc.) of students at top law schools to decide whom we really wanted to pursue as a candidate. However, if an applicant blew the interview, or showed poor judgment while he or she was a summer associate, the candidate was doomed, regardless of the candidate's grades and the prestige of the candidate's law school.
Further, outside the hallowed halls of 1000+ or even 100+ law firms, professorships and clerkships, grades are not always a good predictor of success. I had a classmate who was probably exaggerating when he claimed to be in the top half of the bottom quarter of the class--but he had a remarkable career as a public defender. His talent wasn't in exam taking, but in establishing rapport with juries. He got a lot of clients off.
Thanks for the post.
LLamasex--we may be not necessarily smarter, but probably more competitive and as a result, work harder than back in the 30s.
Says the "Dog"
Education in America is not about knowlege. It is about money. End of story.
Nowhere is this more evident than in the artificial, irrelevant, and overwrought standard ciriculum of American law schools.
Law School is not a "school." It's a Shriners Lodge where you learn a secret handshake, go through silly initiation rituals, and in doing so, become a part of a privileged club that watches out for its own, and passes on all the best local business deals to its members.
Grades in law school represent one thing, and one thing only - the ability to short-term memorize enough silly facts and organize them in a time-pressured 3 hour exam.
If I practiced law the way I'm expected to succeed in law school, I'd be committing malpractice.
This isn't education. It's hazing. And a high GPA today is nothing to be impressed with.
1st year courses:
Maximum Minimum
A- and above………………20%....................5%
B- and above………………60%....................45%
C- and below………………20%....................13%
D and below………………..5%.....................0%
Other required courses:
Maximum Minimum
A- and above……………….30%...................5%
B- and above……………….75%...................45%
C- and below……………….20%...................10%
Curve for Elective Courses with 20 Students or More
Maximum Minimum
A- and above………………..60%......………15%
B- and above………………100%…………...45%
C- and below…………….....10%.......……0%
Curve for Elective Courses with Fewer Than 20 Students:
In elective courses in which there are fewer than 20 students, there shall be no mandatory curve, except that no more than 20% of the students may receive a grade of C- or below.
As you can see, for 1st year grades a minimum of 40% gets C or below (not listed that way, but if a max of 60% can get B- or above, that leaves 40% with C or below). A lot higher % than what was posted for other schools (like 5% Cs).
We don't have + grades--no A+, B+, C+, etc.
Huh. My GPA is slightly above 3.7, and I am ranked in the top 5 (of about 300). Pretty good, I thought, but if I am competing against people not only from higher ranked schools, but with artificially inflated grades, well that just stinks.