Loren Coleman's weblog "The Copycat Effect" (which is also the name of his book) examines the copycat effect of the Virginia Tech murders. He points out that a school attack last week in Oregon (no fatalities) appeared to have been inspired by a recent National Geographic tv special on Columbine. He offers a grim warning of the high risk of more copycat attacks in the next several weeks. Pointing to school attacks in Canada and Germany in recent years, he notes that the problem is not confined to the United States.
American Spectator has an article by John Tabin on "gun free zones" which includes an interview with me.
At my website, I have a variety of articles on policies which have worked to prevent or stop school shootings, including Israel's policy of arming teachers.
The rules on the purchase of firearms by non-immigrant aliens (such as the Virginia Tech killer, who held a green card) is here. Basically, they must have been in the U.S. for at least 90 days at the same residence. They under the same criminal records background check as a U.S. citizen, plus an additional check with Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
Although we do not know what ammunition magazines the killer used, ABC News was plainly wrong in claiming that the 2004 sunset of the 1994 Clinton "assault weapon" law brought magazines with a capacity of over 10 rounds back into the marketplace. The 1994 law banned the manufacture of new magazines, but magazines made before September 1994 were always readily-available on the marketplace.
Finally, I will be on the CTV (Canada) program "The Verdict" tonight, from about 9:19-9:30 p.m. Eastern Time. I will be debating Wendy Cukier, Canada's leading gun prohibition advocate. The program should be available on the CTV website not long afterwards.
All Related Posts (on one page) | Some Related Posts:
- Semi-Automatics Vs. Revolvers:
- A Strange Thing To Assert as Fact:
- A Well Regulated Militia:...
- Firearms and Non-Citizens:
- The Copycat Effect
- How Common Are Mass Shootings at US Schools?...
- Tragedies as Occasions for Discussing Ways To Prevent Repeat Tragedies:
- Tragedy at Virginia Tech:
- Shootings at Virginia Tech:
What's up with copycatters?
As for the particulars of regulating guns, honestly, this is something for which federalism is a good solution. Some states could have teachers carry weapons others won't. Some could have concealed carry even in classrooms, others will ban guns from campus.
Drawing any direct conclusions from big media stories or even loud political debates is not what I see having one approach win out over another. Over time states are going to work out in practice what works.
I wonder: Are they so detached they can think in such terms? Are they wanting immortality by being remembered, even if as a mass murderer?
I agree with the author that it's unwise (and incorrect) to label VTech as the greatest massacre in US history. But then, I believe MSM is more about alarmist dirty laundry than considering repercussions.
But if you want to see some truly disgusting display of rhetoric, here are a couple of places to start:
Derbyshire
Schlussel
One source of threat are students who are identified as emotionally handicapped, many of whom are potentially (or have histories of being) violent. Another source comes from having juveniles sentenced to attend school (some having committed violent felonies), with no parameters (aside from numbers of days attended) for judging successful compliance for said students, and insufficient communication with/monitoring from the judicial system that ordered them there. Another threat comes from increasingly irresponsible, immature, and unreasoning parents that cannot understand that MY conduct of the classroom does not have to mirror THEIR expectations for their children, or that their children's grades should have some correlation with the degree of completeness and correctness of assignments. The final threat I will categorize as the unsuccessful, frustrated marginal student himself, who knows that he has not really accomplished much in the last 10-12 years of his life, forced into classrooms with 20-30 other students, to whom teachers cannot devote the extra time needed to give that student a chance at succeeding in an academic setting.
And, Israeli teachers may indeed be more trained, but I am a US military veteran, and we currently have at least two combat-experienced Vietnam veterans in our faculty. We would be most grateful to be allowed to participate in training in something other than just another "new" instructional fad that very often results in just another way to gloss over a student's shortcomings and ignore or deny their many wondrous talents. I fear that many pressures would prevent this prudent use of available expertise.
As to the links you provided, I agree that the second link that you posted could be seen as quite crude, but it also points out that many segments of our society no longer trust the media to report the facts in a straightforward and transparent manner. I cannot see the first one in such a light, however, as it seems to point out that we have maybe succeeded too well in teaching some of our children not to resist physically.
I suggest that a TV special should be made on this, but focusing on Liviu Librescu and his heroism. Choose what you want imitated.
Why is it that a certain mind set always see more guns as the answer rather than more rational controls for allowing gun ownership?
A prof panics, shoots someone, who now gets hbuled into lawshit--why the Board, the School, the administration...and oh, yea, the prof.
Ps: I have served in the military a few times; my son, a former marine, owns some 4 guns, so this is not wimp talk
Order out of Chaos?
The "problem-solvers" have a conflict of interest...? Yes.
Who profits?
Gun-grabbers(though it hardly makes a difference nowadays, most of society has been so brainwashed and pacified that they don't even know or care they are being enslaved).
The Psychiatric/Psychology industry(mirroring the Soviet model).
And of course the Police-state apparatis is further justified for expansion and more invasive-intrusive measures are "normalised".