The Volokh Conspiracy

Time for a Uniform Uniform Code?

My colleague Erik Jensen has a new paper calling for a "Uniform Uniform Code." The abstract reads, in full, "Law professors dress scruffily, and we need to do something about that." Professor Bainbridge is unconvinced.

Oh My Word:
Time for Erik to take some shore leave.
10.20.2007 12:09pm
Libertarian1 (mail):
What would be the general feeling if you went to a physician with a serious medical problem and he was unshaved, unwashed, and wearing jeans, a t-shirt, and his dad’s old Army field jacket? Would his brilliant medical mind overcome his appearance?
10.20.2007 12:28pm
Anonymouseducator (mail) (www):
An unwashed physician is something else entirely. There's an actual health risk.

Suppose your surgeon were wearing a business suit.
10.20.2007 12:30pm
taion:
Libertarian1: In real life, or on TV?
10.20.2007 12:57pm
3L:
Libertarian-- Excellent point. I would far prefer the mediocre medical mind who took the time to shave. That way, my estate is more likely to have a medical malpractice claim, and the doctor is already ready for depositions!
10.20.2007 1:13pm
Libertarian1 (mail):

That way, my estate is more likely to have a medical malpractice claim, and the doctor is already ready for depositions!



A dear attorney friend of mine recently called me in tears. Her father had just died at age 85. He had smoked cigarettes for over 60 years and died of lung cancer. Her first comment was she was going to sue the physician for not diagnosing the cancer earlier.

3L, you have obviously chosen the right profession for you. What possible excuse can I find to sue? Do you honestly believe having a mediocre mind is a justifiable cause for a law suit?

I prefer to show my patients respect by dressing appropriately. And if you ever go into the actual practice of law I predict that as you mature you too will choose not to greet a potential valuable client unwashed, unshaven and in sweats. You seem to be implying that dressing like a slob is proof of a great mind.
10.20.2007 1:41pm
dearieme:
I have spent much of my life as an academic. My dress code is ragamuffin. When I require a uniform, I wear an academic gown. It goes well with shorts and sandals. If my students were to dress formally, I might consent to wear a toga. Or I might lash out on a new kilt.
10.20.2007 2:10pm
PersonFromPorlock:
The party imposing any dress code should be required to pay for the costs it incurs, pour encourager les directeurs.
10.20.2007 3:31pm
ChrisIowa (mail):

"Uniform Uniform Code."


My thought on first reading: would this be the legal equivalent of the Grand Unification Theory?

My second thought: Is this quotation abuse?
10.20.2007 4:35pm
Dave N (mail):
Time for a Uniform Uniform Code?

When I saw the headline, I thought a Uniform Uniform Code might be the grand unification of the Uniform Electrical Code, the Uniform Plumbing Code, the Uniform Building Code, etc.
10.20.2007 4:45pm
Dave N (mail):
And yet I noted that in pictures posted on websites, Professor Bainbridge (who claims to be a grunge afficionado) is wearing a tie with his suit jacket and Professor Jensen is not.
10.20.2007 4:55pm
Jonathan H. Adler (mail) (www):
Dave N --

That's the wrong Erik Jensen. Here is the Erik Jensen who wrote the article. As for Professor Bainbridge, he recently assured me that he only wears ties East of the Mississippi, and even then under some amount of duress.

JHA
10.20.2007 5:03pm
jdh (mail) (www):
My two favorite professors in law school were opposite ends of the dressing spectrum. One was immaculately dressed and coifed all the time. I think he may have worn the most beautiful suits I've ever seen. The other tried to dress well but always looked dishevelled. The suit looked too old, or didn't seem to fit well, or was out of style. And the ties were either old or not well-tied. And his hair was a constant mess.

Nevertheless, I liked them both a great deal, although I'd much rather dress like the former than the latter.
10.20.2007 5:44pm
Dave N (mail):
Jonathan--

My bad. But what are the odds of two law professors named Eric Jensen?
10.20.2007 6:09pm
Dave N (mail):
By the way, having read the article by the real Professor Jensen, I loved the satire. Not quite Swift, and he shouldn't quit his day job, but much, much better than most.
10.20.2007 6:11pm
Tony Tutins (mail):
It all depends on what the prof was used to wearing:
"I say beware of all enterprises that require new clothes" -- Thoreau
10.20.2007 7:46pm
Truth Seeker:
what are the odds of two law professors named Eric Jensen?

I think in Denmark Jensen is the most common last name and Eric is one of the most common first names.

Regarding dress codes, unshaved is one thing, but meeting people unwashed borders on mental illness. If you care that little for other people find a job where you can work at home alone. Your smell will be more memorable than anything you had to say no matter how brilliant becasue people won't be able to concentrate on it.
10.20.2007 9:28pm
Syd Henderson (mail):
I think a black top hat, red riding jackot and lime colored pinstriped pants, and white gloves. Or is that ringmaster at a circus?
10.21.2007 12:45am
Syd Henderson (mail):
Darn, I forgot the riding whip.

I also think we should bring back wigs for judges, and probably for President as well. The latter especially if Hillary gets elected. The Senators should probably wear baseball uniforms. And the Surgeon General full scrubs, a stethoscope, and a belt full of medical instruments

As for what the Solicitor General should wear--this forum is viewable by a family audience.
10.21.2007 3:03am
Porkchop:

It all depends on what the prof was used to wearing:
"I say beware of all enterprises that require new clothes" -- Thoreau Porkchop


There, fixed. :-D

I think the quality of instruction would inevitably go up if the professors were required to instruct au naturel. Most (not all, as I remember a couple quite attractive professors at my law school) would have to improve their game to overcome the negative impression that their out-of-shape bodies would give.
10.21.2007 8:35am
Bottomfish (mail):
After reading both Professor Jensen's and Professor Bainbridge's statements, I suggest that law professors be required to wear the uniforms of the local police force. After all, they cannot be against law enforcement.
10.21.2007 9:36am
justwonderingby:
If a law school is paying you over $100,000 to teach 4 courses a year, the least you can do is dress appropriately.
10.21.2007 9:41am
dearieme:
The first thing we do is hang all the people who witter on about "appropriately".
10.21.2007 12:38pm
Nathan Hall (mail):
There's something ironic in the informality of the article. "Right on?"
10.21.2007 5:17pm
Randy R. (mail):
Terrific article, Prof. Jensen! I took his income tax class at CWRU back in the mid-80s and he actually made tax law somewhat interesting, which is quite an accomplishment. We students liked him so much that we took that memorable phrase "de minimus fringe" and made it the name of our law school rock band.

That same year, I recall, Prof. Mehlman, then new to the faculty after having studied in Britain, came to our torts class dressed in some jacket he could only have bought in Oxbridge. It was cream and dark blue stripes, with each stripe being at least two inches wide. He came to class, and immediately everyone stopped chattering. Murmers grew to giggles, which grew to outright laughter. Finally, the class broke out into spontaneous applause and cheers. Max turned bright red, said nothing, and started the class.

We never saw him wear that jacket again.
10.21.2007 8:00pm