The Volokh Conspiracy

Debating Wetland Protection after Rapanos:

The Supreme Court's decision in Rapanos v. United States reaffirming the existence of limits of federal regulatory jurisdiction over wetlands and other non-navigable waters generated significant uncertainty about the scope of federal authority -- uncertainty the Bush Administration's post-Rapanos regulatory guidance did little to resolve.

This morning I am debating Jim Tripp, general counsel of the Environmental Defense Fund, on what the federal government should do next at a wetlands regulatory workshop sponsored by the American Society of Civil Engineers' Coasts, Oceans, Ports, and Rivers Institute. In two weeks, I'll revisit this issue again when I testify before the House Transportation Committee on proposed revisions to the Clean Water Act that would expand federal jurisdiction.

I'll post more on these events, and recent court decisions in this area, in the days ahead. In the meantime, I my two articles on the Rapanos decision can be found here and here.

M. Python:
I would put a tax on all people who stand in water ... Oh!
4.3.2008 11:42am
A. Zarkov (mail):
At one time draining swamps was a good idea. It was accomplishment a politician could run on. New York's Central Park was once a swamp. Now you call a swamp a wetland* and its preservation becomes an accomplishment.


*Wetlands include swamps, marshes and bogs.
4.3.2008 12:22pm
Woodoo:
Why would Banana Republicans want to protect the environment? Everybody knows that tomorrow does not exist.
4.3.2008 12:30pm
Crunchy Frog:
A. Zarkov: So was D.C. I propose we let it revert to its original state.
4.3.2008 12:54pm
Cornellian (mail):
I thought D.C. was still a swamp.
4.3.2008 1:06pm
Mike Jaskie (mail):
The term morass certainly comes to mind for DC
4.3.2008 1:34pm
Randy R. (mail):
The slang for the US State Dept is 'foggy bottom', since he was a bog so thick, things would sink down into it without a trace.

Many commentators say that still exists.
4.3.2008 2:19pm
TruthInAdvertising:
"At one time draining swamps was a good idea. It was accomplishment a politician could run on. New York's Central Park was once a swamp. Now you call a swamp a wetland* and its preservation becomes an accomplishment."

You can say the same thing about killing Native Americans. Are you hearkening back to the "good old days"?
4.5.2008 12:14am
DrBrren (mail) (www):
I think D.C. was still vety swamp. Best online pharmacy
4.5.2008 8:40am