The Volokh Conspiracy

Seattle School District Eliminates "Office of Equity, Race and Learning Support":

Whether this will have any effect on policy, or even the District's pronouncements, is hard to tell. Still, it seemed worth noting, especially given my comments two years ago on one aspect of the Office's work:

Seattle Public Schools' Web Site Says Individualism is a Form of "Cultural Racism":

From "Definitions of Racism":

Cultural Racism:
Those aspects of society that overtly and covertly attribute value and normality to white people and Whiteness, and devalue, stereotype, and label people of color as “other”, different, less than, or render them invisible. Examples of these norms include defining white skin tones as nude or flesh colored, having a future time orientation, emphasizing individualism as opposed to a more collective ideology, defining one form of English as standard, and identifying only Whites as great writers or composers.

Also included: "Defining one form of English as standard," and "identifying only Whites as great writers or composers." I should say that assuming that only Whites can be great writers or composers is of course indeed racism; but providing a list of the greatest composers and writers that consists only of whites may be perfectly legitimate, depending on your criteria (which could be entirely fair, though not indisputable, criteria) of greatness.

(The definition was taken down following complaints that were seemingly spurred by media coverage of the Web page.) Thanks to Rick Thiel for the pointer.

The Ace:
Isn't the worst part of this the "having a future time orientation" definition. That seems like something we should be trying to instill in our students, deferred gratification. Actions have consequences. Orienting yourself to those consequences and planning your actions accordingly should not be considered racist.
5.13.2008 1:06pm
Cornellian (mail):
Office of Office of Equity

It's a component of the Department of Redundancy Department. [Thanks, fixed. -EV]
5.13.2008 1:20pm
The General:
policy won't change. This liberal racism is just going underground and away from public scrutiny.
5.13.2008 1:25pm
DanX:
Shouldn't non-whites be extremely offended by the suggestion that "having a future time orientation" is a "white" attribute? By implication non-whites *lack* a "future time orientation." Talk about racist...
5.13.2008 1:32pm
Richard Aubrey (mail):
Dan X.

As Revum Wright railed against "middleclassedness", future time orientation is a threat to the race hustlers and the poverty pimps.

To be controlled, the minorities must be convinced they're victims, helpless unless they give their money and power to....the poverty pimps and the race hustlers.

And nothing fixes victims like being middleclassedist and part of that is future time orientation.
5.13.2008 1:38pm
rarango (mail):
My son teaches 5th grade in the Seattle School District; The district is a microcosm of Seattle/King County, and if possible even more screwed up. Not that there's anything wrong with that, mind you....
5.13.2008 1:56pm
TTB (mail):
The Seattle School District: Collectively giving racism a good rep.
5.13.2008 2:00pm
Houston Lawyer:
I recently was routed a diversity magazine put out either by the Texas or Houston Bar. The article addressed to white men asked them to acknowledge their "white privilege, male privilege, hetero privilege" etc. in order to embrace diversity. I felt obligated to share it with my colleagues who could best appreciate it, being of the victimizer class.
5.13.2008 2:49pm
taney71:
Soon all white people will have to go through a "re-education" class like the criminal, Alex DeLarge, from the movie "Clockwork Orange." Its all for the good of society really.
5.13.2008 2:55pm
SenatorX (mail):
Amazing. But this "having a future time orientation" just boggles my mind.
5.13.2008 3:04pm
rarango (mail):
SenatorX--about 15 years ago, there was a piece floating around about "American culture." This was written in response to the first wave of multi-culti stuff. It described American culture (and didn't break it down by color) as: (1) valuing fairness (2) concerned with time as a scarce commodity (3) having a forward looking time orientation for problem solving (4) being materialistic (5) being pragmatic. There were a few other items but I remember thinking at the time it was a fair description of "American" culture.
5.13.2008 3:19pm
rarango (mail):
and now that the last synapse has fired: valuing the individual (versus family, clan, tribe or group)
5.13.2008 3:20pm
Thoughtful (mail):
Is this REALLY where Microsoft employees send their kids?
5.13.2008 3:43pm
EIDE_Interface (mail):

taney71:
Soon all white people will have to go through a "re-education" class like the criminal, Alex DeLarge, from the movie "Clockwork Orange." Its all for the good of society really.


With the forced-eyelid openers. Don't forget that little detail.
5.13.2008 3:53pm
rarango (mail):
Thoughtful: no; of course not--they send them to private schools.
5.13.2008 3:56pm
Bill Poser (mail) (www):
Thoughtful:

Microsoft is located in Redmond, a separate city from Seattle, which is part of the Lake Washington School District. I have no idea whether Lake Washington is any better, but it isn't the same as the Seattle School District.
5.13.2008 3:57pm
Extraneus (mail):
Ah, yes. "[E]mphasizing individualism as opposed to a more collective ideology" does seem pretty racist, when you really think about it.

Sheesh.
5.13.2008 3:58pm
ras (mail):
Can I presume this means they'd also want to do away with "racist" elections based on individual ballots?

Perhaps the central govt could instead appoint group representatives who would each vote on behalf of their entire "community...."
5.13.2008 4:10pm
music lover (mail):
Here's a partial list of great composers:
Palestrina, Monteverdi, Bach, Purcell, Handel, Gluck, Haydn, Mozart, Weber, Beethoven, Schubert, Mendellsohn, Rossini, Chopin, Liszt, Schumann, Brahms, Dvorak, Tchaikovsky, Mussorgsky, Borodin, Rimsky-Korsakoff, Grieg, Nielsen, Sibelius, Verdi, Puccini, Wagner, Debussy, Ravel, Stravinsky, Schoenberg, Messiaen, Bartok, Poulenc, Prokofiev, Shostakovich, Holst, Vaughn Williams, Britten, Ives, Copland.

No doubt a few have slipped my mind. But last I checked, all of these composers were white. The bastards. I bet they thought slavery was a good thing.

And my gosh, not a woman among them! How can that be?
5.13.2008 5:23pm
sbron:
Jack O'Connell, California State Superintendent of Public Instruction, held a conference on the "achievement gap" that concluded too many teachers were white, and white privilege explained the poor academic performance of Blacks and Latinos. From the Nov. 12 2007 SF Chronicle:


"O’Connell now believes that widespread cultural ignorance within the California school system is responsible for the poor academic performance of many black and Latino students in school.

He offered the example of black children who learn at church that it’s good to clap, speak loudly and be a bit raucous. But doing the same thing at school, where 72 percent of teachers are white and may be unfamiliar with such customs, will get them in trouble, he said."


Now O'Connell is complaining that California is losing too many teachers to other states with better education budgets. But if CA is losing mostly white teachers, isn't that a good thing? And O'Connell actually plans to run for Governor!
5.13.2008 5:44pm
Zed:
Who ever identifies only one form of English? There's British English, Scottish English, American English, Canadian English, etc.

Or does the racist list actually mean "not identifying Ebonics as standard English."
5.13.2008 6:47pm
Bill Poser (mail) (www):

He offered the example of black children who learn at church that it’s good to clap, speak loudly and be a bit raucous. But doing the same thing at school, where 72 percent of teachers are white and may be unfamiliar with such customs, will get them in trouble, he said."


If Mr. O'Connell knew more about black churches he would know that in addition to the lively services that many of them have, they also have Sunday school classes in which the children are required to listen quietly and attentively to the teacher. Those children are perfectly aware that different behavior is appropriate in different settings.
5.13.2008 7:08pm
SenatorX (mail):
Thanks rarango. I still can't wrap my head around the "having a future time orientation" phrase being linked to white racism. I must have a blind spot or something. There is some concept of only living in the now that minorities enjoy and need protected? What Richard Aubrey said can't be the truth can it? Even if there is truth there they must have a fig leaf concept that sounds nicer. I just don't see where this one comes from.
5.13.2008 7:49pm
LarryA (mail) (www):
He offered the example of black children who learn at church that it’s good to clap, speak loudly and be a bit raucous.
He obviously has no experience with the youth groups at most mainline white churches, either. “Keep the riot manageable” was always our motto.
But doing the same thing at school, where 72 percent of teachers are white and may be unfamiliar with such customs, will get them in trouble, he said."
In my academic experience students are required to sit quietly because their teachers are trained by education professionals to prohibit any such disruption. Race is irrelevant.
5.13.2008 7:51pm
joey thomas (mail):
I find the first sentence poorly stated but reasonable. It is the rest of the statement I just think is plain stupid. In my job as a director of an African American cultural center at a top 25 university I find it hard enough to have meaningful conversations about race, class, and culture without focusing on the absurdities of time orientation and hosiery colors. What were they thinking?
5.13.2008 8:08pm
rarango (mail):
Senator X. I understand your difficulty. To me it simply a function that someone somewhere defined "american culture" (and you have to, I think, read white americans in that definition) as having a future time orientation. I can't find any other explanation except "NOT white americans." And I think Mr. Aubrey is on the mark.
5.13.2008 8:25pm
oledrunk (mail):
Music Lover

You omitted Couperin, Marais and Rameau.
5.13.2008 10:05pm
Richard Aubrey (mail):
Senator X &rarango.

Thanks for the agreement. Now, would you agree with the following:
The people who pitch this in order to keep minorities disadvantaged and thus controllable are the most despicable pieces of dysentery-ridden rodent turds you can imagine.
Having them in places where they have one kind or another of power over others is a very bad idea.
5.13.2008 11:49pm
rarango (mail):
Richard Aubrey: absolutely--I do so love your phraseology.
5.14.2008 10:45am
rarango (mail):
Mr. Aubrey: I once heard the late Dante scholar and poet John Ciardi use the word "turd" on the air in a radio interview. He made it sound very impressive!
5.14.2008 10:48am
Richard Aubrey (mail):
Ah, yes.

"A wuuuhhd in yoah eah."

I'm trying to improve my phraseology by reading Misha, The Idiotarian Rottweiler.

That's where I heard that Holger Danske is suspected of having one eye open. My wife knows an exchange student from Denmark. I'll see if she knows anything about it.

Anyway, the concept of working hard to maintain people in victim status for political or financial (Wright's retirement home is 10,000 square ft. + in a super upscale 'burb of Chicago which is 2% non-white) is despicable enough wrt the unfortunates themeselves. Vicious and inhuman. Doesn't do the rest of society much good, either.

Palmer and Colton, in A History of The Western World, made the point that the reformer is the deadly enemy of the revolutionary. Because if the reform works, the people won't bother to revolt. And, it was said, Franz Joseph was, in his strange way, a reformer in the Empire. Had to go.
Point is, revolutionaries and others like the race hustlers and poverty pimps not only need victims as cannon fodder, they work to create them.
5.14.2008 11:31am
TZiese:
music lover, your list is indeed a partial list of great composers, though I'd guess you'd have a different list if you grew up in China or India or Egypt. (Also, I'd add in some modern non-classical rock and jazz composers as well.)

If I made such a list, it would probably be nearly all white as well, but that's not because I'm racist, it's because I simply don't have much exposure to nonwestern classical music. Until then, I'll qualify my list as "great composers I've heard of" or "great western classical composers." To call my list "a small sampling of the best composers ever" would be quite silly indeed.
5.14.2008 1:27pm
SenatorX (mail):
Richard I am unable to find a way to disagree with you. Rodent turds they are! Tax exempt and using Christianity to peddle the non-sense is extra disgusting.
5.14.2008 2:15pm