Jack Kemp, RIP:

Jack Kemp has passed away. Kemp was a longtime Republican Congressman, HUD Secretary under President George H.W. Bush, a two time presidential candidate, and the Republican nominee for vice president in 1996. In the 1960s, he was a star quarterback for the Buffalo Bills. Others can better assess Kemp's career and legacy than I can. However, I wish to say a few words because Kemp was one of my superiors when I was an intern at Empower America during the summer of 1993. a I was a college sophomore at the time. EA was a public policy organization that Kemp co-founded with William Bennett and Jeane Kirkpatrick. My work was principally focused on school choice, which was also a major interest of Kemp's.

There are three things I will always remember about Kemp. First, unlike most politicians I have met or heard of, Kemp had a genuine interest in ideas. His office was filled with books about politics, history, and economics, most of which had the look of actually having been read and carefully studied. He was always interested in having discussions about policy issues - sometimes even with lowly interns like me. Kemp was much more knowledgeable about policy than most public officials with far more elite educational credentials.

Second, Kemp was one of those rare individuals who is genuinely at ease with people from all walks of life. Most politicians can affect an air of friendliness when necessary. But Kemp seemed to genuinely enjoy talking about a wide range of matters with all sorts of people. He was equally at home with policy wonks, athletes, and just ordinary voters.

Third, he had a serious and longstanding commitment to school choice, enterprise zones (a longtime focus of his efforts), and other policies by which market mechanisms can be used to advance the interests of the poor and disadvantaged. This came through both in his well-known public actions and in the passion he showed for these issues behind closed doors. Many Republican political leaders have endorsed similar policies at various times, but few showed anything like the same degree of genuine commitment to them.

I did not always agree with Kemp. For example, I did not fully share his faith in supply-side economics, and I thought that he was insufficiently attentive to the dangers of excessive government spending. Kemp was also more socially conservative than I am. However, I did greatly respect him, and there are precious few other politicians about whom I can say the same thing.

In closing, I would like to extend my condolences to Secretary Kemp's family, friends, and colleagues.

Public_Defender (mail):
Politically, I agreed with Kemp less than Somin, but he said what he believed, expressed himself well, and seemed to get along with just about everybody. It's too bad he didn't stick around politics longer.
5.3.2009 5:47am
geokstr (mail):
Pretty darned good quarterback, too.
5.3.2009 9:19am
rosetta's stones:

I did not always agree with Kemp. For example, I did not fully share his faith in supply-side economics...


30 years ago, the Kemp-Roth tax cuts were the political genesis of the supply-side policy that seemingly all accept today. For better or worse, Clinton basically accepted it, and Obama seems to be doing so, or at least they were/are being forced to do so by the Congress.

Kemp was a thinker, and he definitely got around. The prosecutor who took down Kwame Kilpatrick here in Detroit, Kim Worthy, was one of Kemp's proteges from way back, flying against the political grain.

R.I.P, my brother.
5.3.2009 9:24am
Desiderius:
This man is what true Liberalism looks like - in all its glory and naivete. That it was largely unrecognized is an indictment of our time. Sorely missed.
5.3.2009 9:41am
MaliciousDisorder (mail):
Get real, He was a RINO in sheep's clothing. He was a good football qb and should have stayed in sports. Before I figured out the media I always shut him off when he appeared on one show speaking for conservatives then on the next show talking moderate left.
Just like most of today's politicians he talked out of both sides of his mouth. Talked down to the hardworking American. Why can't these sorry types of politicians die while in office before they plunder the taxpayer ?
5.3.2009 10:05am
Cornellian (mail):
Get real, He was a RINO in sheep's clothing.

And people wonder why the Republican party is in such desparate shape.
5.3.2009 10:33am
Cornellian (mail):
Kemp was a good guy. So was Dole. A Dole/Kemp administration wouldn't have been such a bad thing. We'd have had a president with a sharp sense of humor.
5.3.2009 10:36am
Oren:
Indeed. I always wished W had run in '96 and Dole in '00.
5.3.2009 10:55am
Dave N (mail):
MaliciousDisorder,

I am a Republican and proudly so. To say that Jack Kemp is a RINO is an insult to both the man and his memory. Frankly, I want no part of a political party that would not welcome either Jack Kemp or his ideas.

May he rest in peace. He went too young.
5.3.2009 11:00am
Joseph Slater (mail):
Whatever one thinks of Kemp's politics, I will again say that the occasion of someone dying should, except in the most extreme of circumstances (Hitler, Stalin, Pol Pot), NOT be the time to stress partisan or related sorts of disagreements. A death is a time to honor what was good about the person and to reflect on our common humanity.

To this Democrat, Kemp always seemed like an honorable, principled person. RIP.
5.3.2009 12:18pm
Response to MaliciousDisorder:
And in purging the Republicans of "RINOs" we get...Sarah Palin! R.I.P., Jack.
5.3.2009 12:24pm
CJColucci:
For various personal and professional reasons, I spend a lot of time with politically-savvy black people, so I'd like to pass on a perspective we might not otherwise get here. While most of those I spoke with disagreed with Kemp on whether his policy positions were sound, they all believed that he believed that those policies would be good for minorities, that he cared about whether they would be good for minorities, and that he thought that policies being good for minorities was a good thing. They also thought he was remarkably naive for thinking this point of view would be politically helpful to him in his own party. (And one made a joke I just have to repeat: "Kemp has showered with more black men than most Republican politicians know.")
Maybe the commenter who called Kemp a RINO is the sort of Republican they had in mind.
5.3.2009 12:39pm
A,. Zarkov (mail):
I'm very sorry hear that Kemp has passed away. He seemed like an extremely pleasant chap. But I have to regard him as an intellectual lightweight. He didn't do so well in his debate with Gore. Gore of all people-- a complete ignoramus. Then he was a fan of increased immigration-- if not open borders outright. His support of supply side economics also does him no credit. Still he brought an optimism and enthusiasm to the public arena, and I will miss him a lot.
5.3.2009 12:51pm
Dave N (mail):
Joseph Slater,

Well said.
5.3.2009 1:35pm
Strict:

Then he was a fan of increased immigration


Zarkov,

You still haven't told us when your parents immigrated to the US.
5.3.2009 1:42pm
Derrick (mail):
For various personal and professional reasons, I spend a lot of time with politically-savvy black people, so I'd like to pass on a perspective we might not otherwise get here.While most of those I spoke with disagreed with Kemp on whether his policy positions were sound, they all believed that he believed that those policies would be good for minorities, that he cared about whether they would be good for minorities, and that he thought that policies being good for minorities was a good thing.


I think that this doesn't get stressed enough. I didn't agree with a whole lot of Jack Kemp's policies, but I always thought that his motives were well placed when dealing with minorities. I actually caught a speech he gave at Howard U in the 90's, where he showed a great measure of wit, intelligence and compassion for those who didn't share his experiences. To those who believe bs like the "Democratic Plantation" crap, I promise that a Republican party filled with even a quarter of Jack Kemp's would be competitive in the Black community.
5.3.2009 2:14pm
A,. Zarkov (mail):
"You still haven't told us when your parents immigrated to the US."

Your question is both impertinent and irrelevant, but I will answer it anyway.

My parents did not immigrate to the US, they were born here.

Today we have about 1 million legal immigrants arriving per year, and another 1 million illegal immigrants. These levels greatly exceed the even the peak levels anytime in the past as you can see here. They are excessive and unnecessary and lower wages. The welfare given to the new waves also place a strain on state and local budgets. Just because the US once had immigration, does not imply the we should forever have high levels regardless of our needs.

Is it your opinion that there is no optimum population for the US?
5.3.2009 2:49pm
Splunge:
I've nothing to say about Jack Kemp, mensch, except the usual John Donne stuff. But this deserves comment:

unlike most politicians I have met or heard of, Kemp had a genuine interest in ideas.

Unfortunately, the history of the 20th century demonstrates that politicians with new ideas are largely to be feared. The problem of governing men hasn't changed in 40,000 years (at least), and the best approach hasn't changed, either. We know how it's done, and history teaches it plainly.

It isn't "ideas" that are the magic. Almost everyone who's had a new idea about how to run the world has brought tragedy, the bigger the tragedy the more plausible the idea.

What we need are the same old things: honesty, integrity, humility, moral character, courage. These are what our best leaders have demonstrated. Not an interest in ideas.
5.3.2009 3:07pm
Dan M.:
Whether or not someone is a RINO just depends on where you stand. I think anyone who supports or supported restrictions on semi-automatic rifles is a RINO. That doesn't mean they aren't decent human beings.
5.3.2009 5:17pm
jab:
As a fairly liberal Democrat, I always thought that Jack Kemp is one Republican I might be willing to support... Of course, I certainly didn't always agree with his policies, but I always felt that he had integrity, his heart was in the right place... i never questioned his motives... he was one of the few Republicans who would have a snowball's chance in hell of seriously reaching out to minorities in a CREDIBLE way.
If the GOP had a lot more Kemps, it would be good for the GOP and good for the country.
5.3.2009 5:53pm
David Drake:

[Kemp t]alked down to the hardworking American.


Malicious Disorder: it's obvious you never heard him speak. Jack Kemp was everything that was RIGHT about the GOP in the Reagan years. Bright, articulate and very much concerned about the effect of economic policy on the ordinary American.
5.3.2009 6:56pm
Maureen001 (mail):
Malicious Disorder: Perhaps you should not have turned off Jack Kemp when he was speaking. You might have learned something, not only about the man, but about the things he was passionate about.

I read Kemp's report on the blocks to affordable housing in this country. It was the first time government was identified as being the biggest stumbler, via extensive permit processes, excessive requirements for environmental studies, and high permit fees, in the development of affordable housing in this country. He was right on.

I'm sorry for his suffering and that of his family, and I hope he is at peace.
5.3.2009 8:01pm
Doc Rampage (mail) (www):
Some of Jack Kemp's proposals were too far to the left, but he was a fine man with a genuine respect for individual rights. I never heard anyone refer to Kemp as a RINO before this thread and frankly, I suspect that MaliciousDisorder is a leftist acting out his stereotype of a mean-spirited Republican. What could he hope to achieve with that remark if he really were a Republican? Kemp is gone; there is no longer any reason to oppose any of his policies. The only possible effect of such a comment is the reaction he got from Cornellian who seizes on this individual act as confirmation of his prejudice that Republicans are mean people.
5.3.2009 8:21pm
Jim Rhoads (mail):
Jack Kemp was one of the more honest politicians with which I was familiar. He thought things out and declaimed the results. He had more leadership skills than many of our Presidents. It is a pity to me that the electorate could not see what his teammates saw. A man you could rely on.
5.3.2009 11:54pm
Jim Rhoads (mail):
In the above post, "which" should be "whom". Sorry.
5.3.2009 11:57pm
ys:
Kemp also spent much time and energy helping Soviet Jewish refuseniks to get permissions to leave that country. Among people helped by him was one of the best chess players in the world at the time Grandmaster Boris Gulko. Thanks to Kemp's efforts Gulko eventually earned a unique distinction of having attained the chess championship of both the USSR and the USA.
5.4.2009 3:38am
A. Zarkov (mail):
ys:

Note that Gulko qualified to play in the 2004 World Chess Championship held in Libya. But the head of the organizing committee said, “We did not and will not invite the Zionist enemies to this championship.”

Poor Gulko. He went from being a "rootless cosmopolitan" to a "Zionist."
5.4.2009 4:11am
A. Zarkov (mail):
There was much to like about Jack Kemp. It's too bad he got seduced into the so-called supply side economics game by crackpot economist Arthur Laffer and journalist Wanniski. Listen to this debate between Peter Schiff and Arthur Laffer on 8/28/2006 about the recession coming in 2008. Schiff hit a bulls eye while Laffer crashed and burned. Listen to the ridiculous statements by Laffer. One would think Laffer wouldn't show his face in public nowadays.

My rejection of the Laffer-Kemp voodoo economics does not mean I agree with the Keynes or the Neoclassical Synthesis. That's wrong too. The guy who got it right was Hyman Minsky.
5.4.2009 4:33am
Houston Lawyer:
I made get out the vote calls in the Republican primary for Kemp back in 1988 when he ran for president. Not many Republicans are more conservative than I am, but this thread was the first time I had seen him referred to as a RINO. I was, however, disappointed with his performance as VP nominee in 1996. A VP's traditional task is to go after the opposing nominee hard, and Kemp clearly had no stomach for that.

As for Republicans like Kemp pulling in the Black vote: I Wish. I have seen no indication that Black voters are that open minded. Blacks, as a group are socially conservative, yet they consistently vote for the hardest-left liberals. In addition, no group would benefit more from free choice in education. Yet Blacks consistently vote for Democrats who have no intention of doing other than preserving the status quo in education.
5.4.2009 2:16pm
Desiderius:
Houston Lawyer,

You can thank LBJ for that. Until we get a black middle-class large enough to take the leap of faith required to get serious about limiting government, so will things continue. The Hispanics, with little cultural experience with limited government, of course don't help either presently. I suspect the two will have to (re)invent the concept on their own - just hope there will be enough believers in the old-time American civil religion of the Founders to join them when they do.
5.4.2009 10:42pm

Post as: [Register] [Log In]

Account:
Password:
Remember info?

If you have a comment about spelling, typos, or format errors, please e-mail the poster directly rather than posting a comment.

Comment Policy: We reserve the right to edit or delete comments, and in extreme cases to ban commenters, at our discretion. Comments must be relevant and civil (and, especially, free of name-calling). We think of comment threads like dinner parties at our homes. If you make the party unpleasant for us or for others, we'd rather you went elsewhere. We're happy to see a wide range of viewpoints, but we want all of them to be expressed as politely as possible.

We realize that such a comment policy can never be evenly enforced, because we can't possibly monitor every comment equally well. Hundreds of comments are posted every day here, and we don't read them all. Those we read, we read with different degrees of attention, and in different moods. We try to be fair, but we make no promises.

And remember, it's a big Internet. If you think we were mistaken in removing your post (or, in extreme cases, in removing you) -- or if you prefer a more free-for-all approach -- there are surely plenty of ways you can still get your views out.