A lawyer says yes. [UPDATE: Here’s his letter.] The argument for infringement is actually moderately strong. Like most other documents, briefs are protected by copyright the moment they are written. The fact that they’re filed in court doesn’t waive any copyright. Lexis and Westlaw’s distribution of the briefs is thus presumptively copyright infrigngement. The question […]
Archive | July, 2009
Fair Use Victory as to Blogger’s Use of Photos of the Businesspeople He Crticizes:
The case is Sedgwick Claims Management Servs., Inc. v. Delsman (decided July 17, 2009): Defendant Robert A. Delsman, Jr. … runs a “blog” in which he has strongly criticized the business practices of Sedgwick [Claims Management Services, Inc.] and its management. In addition, Defendant has mailed postcards styled as “WANTED” posters bearing the photographs of […]
States, Elsewhere:
California, Pennsylvania. Montana, Bulgaria. Wyoming, New York. More? No, I don’t want “St. Petersburg, Florida” and the like, or even “Colorado City, Arizona.” I’m looking for cities that have exactly the same name as the common name of an American state (and are located outside that state).
Stem Cell Advance Raises New Questions:
Two respected scientific journals today reported that Chinese researchers have created baby mice out of induced pluripotent stem cells (“iPSCs”), an advance that raises difficult ethical questions and could reignite the culture-war battles over stem cell research that have subsided over the last two years. Many conservatives oppose human embryonic stem cell (hESC) research, and […]
Consumer Supremacy?
I’m writing up a pretty detailed discussion of tort law policy arguments for my forthcoming Torts class. In particular, I want to stress to students that they shouldn’t just look at the classic compensation and deterrence arguments, but also consider how a proposed legal rule might affect defendants’, prospective defendants’, and others’ liberty, privacy, and […]
The Arms Trade Treaty: Zimbabwe, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, and the Prospects for Arms Embargoes on Human Rights Violators.
That’s the paper I presented at the recent annual conference of the Research Committee on Sociology of Law, in Onati, Spain. It is now available on SSRN. Along with co-authors Paul Gallant & Joanne D. Eisen, I will be revising for law review submission soon. In the meantime, comments are welcome. For those of you […]
Judicial Attitudes Towards Amicus Briefs:
The posts about amicus briefs have gotten enough interest that I thought I’d add one more, before I close with two posts about oral argument. Again, this is from Mayer Brown’s Federal Appellate Practice treatise: [A] nonparty that is not a government entity or official covered by Rule 29 of the Federal Rules of Appellate […]
Economic Climate Change Denialism:
Ronald Bailey on what may be the most common (and politically influential) form of climate change denialism. The California Air Resources Board issued a fanciful study finding that mandates to cut greenhouse gas emissions will cost Californians essentially nothing. This is pure California dreaming. In his stinging critique of the study, Harvard economist Stavins said […]
Efficient Market Hypothesis, a Bleg:
The first topic in my corporate finance class – starting in, alas, not very many weeks – is valuation and market efficiency. This is a law school class, and the approach to valuation is not technical; it is mostly just a description of why it is important, in the context of a survey class that […]
Does Knowing What’s Under the Judicial Hood Threaten the Supreme Court’s Legitimacy? Part 2.
In Part 1 of this discussion I set out a conundrum grounded in earlier research on public attitudes toward courts: Either knowledge does not produce a realistic understanding of decision making, or legitimacy may not depend upon citizens being duped into believing in theories of mechanical jurisprudence and the myth of legality. Here, I provide […]
HRW’s Whitson Plays the Racism Card:
In her ongoing attempt to defend Human Rights Watch’s indefensible, Israel-bashing, fundraising dinner with Saudi elites, with government officials in attendance, Sarah Leah Whitson has now played the racism card. Oh, she hinted at it before, when she responded to my Wall Street Journal piece by snidely writing, “believe it or not, some Arabs believe […]
Public Service Announcement:
Your esteemed blogger is going in for a colonoscopy tomorrow. He is unenthused about the procedure, but even less enthused about possible alternative scenarios. He has conducted a careful cost-benefit analysis and the benefits win. This is not a case of a post containing Too Much Information – Professor Anderson has lost not one, but […]
PopeHat Confesses/Brags About North Korean Twitter Feed Hoax,
here. He fooled me, a Norwegian news site (which ran the headline, “North Korea Threatens Cyprus With War”), and others. The key to the hoax’s success, I think, was that it captured well the spirit of the actual North Korean news agency. In any case, PopeHat 1, me 0.
UMKC Law Review “One-L Revisited” Law Stories Contest,
for current law students and recent graduates (from 2006 or later) — for details, see here. Naturally, the law review issue will have an Introduction by Scott Turow, and it will also have stories from some law professors.
First Amendment Protects Disclosure of Name and Address of Juror, Together With Condemnation of Juror, on Racist Web Site:
That’s the holding of U.S. v. White (N.D. Ill.), decided yesterday, which dismissed White’s indictment for allegedly soliciting criminal actions against the juror (long after the trial was completed). An excerpt: In 2003, a jury in the Northern District of Illinois convicted Hale of soliciting the murder of District Judge Joan Lefkow, who had presided […]