Something (to which I will not link) has appeared on the Internet, which purports to describe Sonia Sotomayor’s work at Princeton: Sotomayor is a graduate from Princeton University, where her legal theses included Race in the American Classroom, and Undying Injustice: American “Exceptionalism” and Permanent Bigotry, and Deadly Obsession: American Gun Culture. In this text, […]
Author Archive | David Kopel
Sonia Sotomayor versus the Second Amendment:
Maloney v. Cuomo is a 2009 per curiam opinion of the Second Circuit, upholding New York State’s complete ban on the possession of nunchaku. New York is the only state in the nation with such an extreme ban. In the opinion by Judges Pooler, Sotomayor, and Katzmann, the per curiam judges first cite Presser v. […]
Guns in National Parks:
The on-line New York Times has a daily feature called “Room for Debate.” The paper picks a topic for the day, and posts short essays from five experts. Today’s topic is Guns in Parks: Safe, Scary or a Sideshow?. My essay on the topic supports the new federal law, and praises President Obama for signing […]
Bloggers: Pelosi hurt herself. Total split on gov’t health insurance:
In this week’s National Journal poll of political bloggers, all of the Right bloggers and almost all of the Left one agreed that Nancy Pelosi had hurt herself “with her handling of the waterboarding controversy.” Most of the Left bloggres thought that she “Hurt herself a little,” while the Right overwhelmingly picked “a lot.” I […]
The No on Koh Letter:
In April, I signed a joint letter to the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, raising concerns about the nomination Yale Law School Dean Harold Koh to be Legal Advisor to the U.S. Department of State. The No Koh website contains a detailed report on Koh, written by Ed Whelan of the Ethics & Public Policy Center. […]
Journal on Firearms & Public Policy:
The Journal on Firearms & Public Policy, published by the Second Amendment Foundation, is an annual interdisciplinary journal. It publishes a mix of original articles, and reprints of important articles published elsewhere. Among the the authors of original articles who may be best-known to VC readers are Gary Kleck, James Jacobs, Roy Wortman, Gary Mauser, […]
Tenth Circuit Survey, Second Amendment, Habeas:
The Denver University Law Review’s annual Tenth Circuit Survey is now on-line, in full text. The Survey is issue 3 of volume 86–below the tables of contents for issues 1 and 2, and the special issue on Obama. The Tenth Circuit Survey issue includes my article, The Second Amendment in the Tenth Circuit: Three Decades […]
Question on family rights and international law:
A nation has ratified the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. Several provisions of the Covenant protect family rights: Article 17. “1. No one shall be subjected to arbitrary or unlawful interference with his privacy, family, home or correspondence, nor to unlawful attacks on his honour and reputation. 2. Everyone has the right to […]
The proper understanding of “Necessary and Proper”:
University of Montana Law Professor Rob Natelson, who is also a Senior Fellow at the Independence Institute, a prolific scholar regarding the original understanding of many provisions of the Constitution. In a 43-minute podcast, I interviewed him about the meaning of the Necessary and Proper clause. As he explains, misinterpretation of the clause is the […]
Left/Right bloggers split on whether Cheney helping Republicans. Bright futures for Jindal, Schweitzer, Granholm
This week’s National Journal poll of political bloggers asked “Has Dick Cheney helped or hurt the Republican Party since leaving office?” One hundred percent of the Left bloggers thought he was hurting the Republicans, while 3/4 of the Right bloggers thought he was helping. My comment: “Every time Cheney shows his face in public, the […]
Senate votes to allow licensed handgun carry in national parks:
Sixty-seven Senators voted for the Coburn amendment, which says that persons can carry firearms in national parks and wildlife refuges to the same extent that they are allowed to carry by state law. All Republicans except Alexander (Tenn.) voted for the amendment. So did Independent Bernie Sanders (Vermont), and 27 Democrats. Including, I am proud […]
Preemption laws and leases of public property:
Here’s a legal question that combines some of the favorite topics at the VC. David Nelson is the head of Stonewall Shooting Sports, the pro-gun gay rights group in Utah. At the upcoming Utah Pride Festival, Nelson wishes to carry a firearm lawfully, as Utah law authorizes him to do. However, the festival operators (a […]
Bloggers: Torture Commission would be good politically. Energy & Climate, or Health, will help Obama’s online appeal:
In this week’s National Journal poll of political bloggers, the first question was: “Does your party stand to gain or lose politically if a torture commission is established?” While the question generated a fair amount of pushback from both the Left and the Right (in that political concerns should not be the determining factor), the […]
Possible Obama Supreme Court Nominees and the Second Amendment:
In the October 2008 issue of America’s 1st Freedom, one of the NRA member magazines, I gave a brief overview of the Second Amendment record of some of the people who had been mentioned as possible Obama appointments to the Supreme Court: Sonia Sotomayor, Merrick Garland, Cass Sunstein, and Eric Holder. This is not, of […]
Reason Magazine goes too far:
Reason magazine sent me an e-mail asking for comments on their new essay by Nick Gillespie and Matt Welch about Obama’s first 100 days. OK, Reason, you want to know what I think? I’m personally offended by the essay. The essay begins: “So here we are, 100 days into the great eight-year triumph of Hope […]