Author Archive | David Kopel

Heller II suit is filed:

On Monday, Dick Heller and two other plaintiffs filed suits against the District of Columbia’s revised gun laws. The complaint challenges the following provisions of D.C. law: The ban on all self-loading handguns (about 3/4 of handguns sold in the U.S.) by defining them as “machine guns.” Allowing registration only upon the payment of an […]

Continue Reading 47

Two articles on Christian Pacifism:

Pacifist-Aggressives vs. the Second Amendment: An Analysis of Modern Philosophies of Compulsory Non-violence. 1 Charleston Law Review (no. 3, 2008, forthcoming). VC readers say an earlier version of this last fall, as a working paper. Then there’s a new working paper, Christian Pacifism Before Constantine. Here’s the abstract: Much recent scholarship on early Christianity has […]

Continue Reading 50

Weekend Fun:

Over at Cato Unbound, the post-Heller debate continues, with Erwin Chemerinsky joining Bob Levy, Dennis Henigan, and me. At the Rocky Mountain News, my media column discusses John McCain’s use of a dog-whistle in a TV ad, appealing to people who despise Tom Tancredo’s immigration reform policies. The column also discusses media treatment of a […]

Continue Reading 18

The Natural Right of Self-Defense: Heller’s Lesson to the World

The Syracuse Law Review is putting together a symposium issue on the Heller decision. My article for the symposium examines the implications of Heller’s constitutionalization of the natural law right of self-defense. The article has benefitted from the VC discussion of self-defense in Heller by Orin Kerr, Eugene Volokh, and Jim Lindgren. Due to the […]

Continue Reading 9

D.C. City Council’s False “Findings” of Facts on Firearms:

D.C. City Councilman Harry Thomas has introduced a resolution titled “Sense of the Council of Future Handgun Resolution of 2008.” The resolution makes the following findings: (1) Accidental deaths by firearms rank in the top 10 of accidental deaths in our country. (2) Approximately 1,500 deaths per year result from the accidental use of a […]

Continue Reading 36

The United Nations vs. the Second Amendment:

Over at Opinio Juris, Kenneth Anderson has an interesting post about last week’s gun control conference at the United Nations, and a New York Times puff piece thereon, written by C.J. Chivers. After noting U.S. concerns about the U.N. becoming a venue attacks on American gun ownership, the Times explains: The United Nations and advocates […]

Continue Reading 88

Debate on Heller and its Implications:

Over at Cato Unbound, Bob Levy (Cato), Dennis Henigan (Brady Center), and I are debating the Heller case. All three of us have new essays on the subject. My essay published today looks at the fatal flaw in the Stevens dissent: its treatment of “the” in “the right to keep and bear arms.” The essay […]

Continue Reading 5

Precedential-deference bleg:

A higher court writes a decision which says X. Misreading the case, many lower courts claim that the decision means Y. Years later, the higher court faces the same issue. To what extent, if any, should the higher court’s new decision take into account the reliance interests of the lower courts who said Y? Is […]

Continue Reading 22

Post-Heller Self-Defense bleg:

District of Columbia v. Heller clearly establishes self-defense (not just gun ownership for self-defense) as a constitutional right. In light of Heller, what are some cases from state courts or lower federal courts which might have to be reversed or modified? I am thinking particularly of cases which describe self-defense as a government-granted privilege, for […]

Continue Reading 9

McCain and Obama vs. Peaceful Protesters:

That’s the topic of my column in today’s Rocky Mountain News, starting with an incident Monday in Denver. As the article makes clear, both campaigns appear to be clearly within their legal rights, because they had protesters expelled from places which are not, under current First Amendment doctrine, traditional public fora. But that doesn’t mean […]

Continue Reading 35

Collective Rights bleg:

Thanks to District of Columbia v. Heller, we now have unanimous agreement that the “collective rights” theory of the Second Amendment is incorrect. All nine Justices agreed that the Second Amendment guarantees an individual right; the Justices simply disagreed about the scope of the individual right. Nothing in the dissent claims that there is now, […]

Continue Reading 18

Bleg on WWII English pacifism:

I believe I have read–but I can’t recall where– that during the Second World War, some English pacifists proposed that when the Nazi troops arrived in England, unopposed by military resistance (thanks to pacifist policy), they should be greeted with Christian love. Such a greeting would be disarming, and the Nazis, seeing that the invaded […]

Continue Reading 57

Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms party:

On Saturday, the Independence Institute held its 6th annual Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms party. We shot sporting clays in the morning, and then ate, smoked, and drank in the afternoon. Fred Barnes (of the Weekly Standard) and Jonathan Hoenig (financial journalist for Fox News, the Wall Street Journal, and others) were the guest speakers. If […]

Continue Reading 13

Michael O’Neill Nominated to DC District Court:

Congratulations to my colleague and friend Michael O’Neill for his nomination to the United Stated District Court for the District of Columbia. Michael is a man of impeccable honor and good judgment and would make a superb judge. It may be that there is too little time for him to get through before the elections […]

Continue Reading

Powered by WordPress. Designed by Woo Themes