In the case of Indiana v. Black, the defendant was charged with murder, and planned to raise a self-defense argument. During voir dire, the judge prevented defense counsel from asking prospective jurors “Do you believe in self-defense?” At trial, the defendant testified that he acted in self-defense, and counsel incorporated self-defense into the closing argument. […]
Author Archive | David Kopel
Rappaport on Originalism:
USD law professor Michael Rappaport defends the normative basis of originalism on the Right Coast. In a nutshell, he argues that the supermajoritarian nature of both constitutional ratification and constitutional amendment provide a normative basis for following the original meaning of constitutional text. His post is based, in part, on this article he co-authored with […]
Smithsonian Returns Discovery Institute Check:
A few weeks ago I noted that the Discovery Institute planned to premiere a film supporting “Intelligient Design” theory at the Smithsonian’s Museum of Natural History. (My description of the film is based upon press reports, as I have not seen it.) As I understood the arrangement, the Smithsonian wasn’t endorsing the film. Rather, the […]
National Review on Marijuana:
The lead editorial in the new issue of National Review, “A Case for Mercy,” is powerful and sensible response to the Raich decision. In addition to identifying the flaws of Justice Scalia’s concurring opinion, NR highlights the “folly” of current federal policy. Many patients suffering from terrible diseases find that smoking marijuana provides them relief […]
The Return of Syufy, Part Deux?
The NYT reports AMC Entertainment and Loews Cineplex plan to merge, creating the nation’s second largest movie theater chain. Should the federal government subject this deal to antitrust scrutiny, it might give an enterprising federal judge the opportunity to try and outdo Judge Kozinski’s infamous opinion in United States v. Syufy Enterprises.
Who Are the Fascists?
In a post last September suggesting the Bush Administration has fascist tendencies, Brian Leiter wrote the following: Much may turn on what is meant, of course, by “fascism,” which is why I started by alluding to the erosion of freedom and democratic values. . . . one might well think that “some provisions of Bush’s […]
Nazi Germany = McCarthy Era = America Today?
At the end of a long post on whether President Bush can be impeached (in which he labels UNC Prof. Michael Gerhardt a “shill” for the Bush Administration for his contribution to this Salon symposium) Brain Leiter offers this “somewhat tangential comment”: in every society of which I’m aware the vast majority of the preeminent […]
What Guantanamo is Really Like:
Senator Richard Durbin has been justly mocked for his statement about what an FBI agent reported seeing at Guantanamo: “If I read this to you and did not tell you that it was an FBI agent describing what Americans had done to prisoners in their control, you would most certainly believe this must have been […]
More Faked Memos?!?
Two years ago, few would question the veracity of news reports based upon leaked government documents. Not anymore. After the “60 Minutes” scandal over the “fake but accurate” Bush National Guard memos, charges that leaked documents are more difficult to dismiss. For example, I don’t know quite what to make of this. UPDATE: Powerline says […]
Media Ignores African Genocides:
That’s the thesis of my latest media column for the Rocky Mountain News. The column points out the media’s failure to cover the Ethiopian genocide against the Anuak people, the severe undercoverage of the genocide-by-starvation in Zimbabwe, and minimal attention to the disaster, including genocide, in the Democratic Republic of the Congo. That the Sudanese […]
Gitmo No “Gulag”:
Former Soviet dissident — and gulag prisoner — Pavel Litvinov rejects the comparison in today’s Washington Post. By any standard, Guantanamo and similar American-run prisons elsewhere do not resemble, in their conditions of detention or their scale, the concentration camp system that was at the core of a totalitarian communist system. Litvinov, an Amnesty supporter […]
The Importance of History:
David Gelernter has an op-ed on the importance of history in today’s LA Times. Here’s a brief excerpt: I was amazed to hear about teenagers who don’t know Fact 1 about the Vietnam War draft. But I have met college students who have never heard of Pol Pot and the Khmer Rouge — the genocidal […]
Environmental Law Blogging:
J. Bishop Grewell rounds up recent environmental cases in federal appellate courts on The Commons Blog here, here, and here. Some of these decisions, such as the 4th Circuit’s ruling against the EPA in United States vs. Duke Energy, are quite significant. Meanwhile, the Environmental Law Prof Blog is the newest member of the Law […]
Brookhiser on Marijuana:
National Review has long bucked conservative orthodoxy on drug prohibition. The magazine first came out for drug decriminalization many years ago — a controversial move for the magazine, and a position not supported by all of its writers. Longtime NR senior editor Rick Brookhiser does support NR’s position, especially on marijuana, and can speak from […]
MoveOn.Org Misleads on PBS:
MoveOn.Org is seeking to mobilize its members in defense of federal funding for public broadcasting, but is doing so in a misleading manner. The MoveOn website warns: “The House is threatening to eliminate all public funding for NPR and PBS, starting with ‘Sesame Street,’ ‘Reading Rainbow’ and other commercial-free children’s shows. Sign our petition to […]