You’ve read about the conservative version, whether fact or fiction; now try the liberal one. UPDATE: Amusingly, back in 2005, I wrote about how you could imagine a version of the “constitution in exile” meme that treated the “Constitution in 2020” conference as important to the liberal version of the “movement.” The imaginary critique included […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Comment Quality:
Reading the VC comment threads post-Sotomayor, it’s interesting how many of them are quickly descending into name-calling and over-the-top accusations from both sides. Granted, there is always a part of that with open blog comments: Some folks post Internet comments to enilghten, others to vent. And there are some topics, such as the OLC torture […]
Obama’s Statements on Empathy and the Doctrinally Relevant vs. Doctrinally Irrelevant Distinction:
There has to be a natural limit on how many posts on empathy a single blog can host — or at least I hope so — but I wanted to elaborate on an interesting issue raised in the comment threads on the difference between what I have called “doctrinally relevant empathy” and “doctrinally irrelevant empathy.” […]
The Information Superhighway Metaphor:
Internet law decisions and commentary from a decade ago frequently speak of the Internet as the “Information Superhighway.” My sense is that the metaphor is no longer in much use, and I wonder if wireless Internet access killed it. If Internet access is everywhere, there’s no room for a highway: the sense of a bulky […]
Doctrinally Relevant Empathy and Doctrinally Irrelevant Empathy:
I wonder if the discussions about “empathy” that we’re likely to have in the next few months might be advanced a bit by distinguishing doctrinally relevant empathy from doctrinally irrelevant empathy. In some areas of law, the relevant legal test absolutely requires judicial empathy. The applicable legal standard may call on the judge to try […]
Perhaps the Most Riveting First Chapter I Have Ever Read:
I have just finished reading the first chapter of my GW colleague Paul Butler‘s new book, Let’s Get Free: A Hip-Hop Theory of Justice. Wow! In the first chapter, Paul details a remarkable story that he has never publicly told: That when he was a federal prosecutor at the Justice Department, in the Public Integrity […]
Great Case Name:
United States v. Vampire Nation, 451 F.3d 189 (3d Cir. 2006).
More on Ted Olson’s federal lawsuit for gay marriage:
To be honest, when I first heard that former Bush Solicitor General Ted Olson, a rock-solid member of the conservative legal movement, had filed a federal lawsuit to invalidate Prop 8 I thought it was an Internet hoax. So I held off posting about it for awhile last night. It was a surprise because I […]
Supreme Court Trivia Question:
George H.W. Bush nominated both Sonia Sotomayor and the Justice she has been nominated to replace. Specifically, she was nominated to the trial bench by George H.W. Bush, and she has now been nominated to replace David Souter, who was himself nominated by George H.W. Bush (to both the First Circuit and the Supreme Court). […]
Sotomayor and Roberts on the Bench Together:
Well, the moot court bench. Video here, from the 2006 GW Law Moot Court.
Now and Then:
Dahlia Lithwick, The Rational Hysterics, today: Confirmation hearings are inevitably an invitation to behave badly. Something about the bright lights of the Senate judiciary committee brings out the worst in people. Legal thinkers who are otherwise reasonable and intelligent somehow become great big puddles of snarling, hateful id. I think Democrats made a mistake when […]
The Sotomayor Pick:
Jan Crawford Greenburg has a very interesting report on the road to the President’s selection. Hat tip: How Appealing.
Law Professors Opposing Supreme Court Nominations:
In 2005, 160 law professors penned a letter to Senators Specter and Leahy stating their opposition to John Roberts’ confirmation. The letter concluded, “On the existing record, we do not believe that Judge Roberts warrants a lifetime seat on our nation
Not a First:
A reader asks: With all the talk of her being the first Hispanic Justice, I find this question more interesting: Would Judge Sotomayor be the first judge to climb the ladder from federal district judge to federal circuit judge to US Supreme Court Justice? Nope. Charles E. Whittaker did it first: He was on the […]
More on Sotomayor and the Second Amendment:
Although I would guess that Sonia Sotomayor is not a big fan of Second Amendment protections, I think my co-blogger Dave Kopel is reading too much into Maloney v. Cuomo. Kopel writes that the judges in that case seriously misconstrue the Second Amendment itself, when they write: “The Supreme Court recently held that this confers […]