Justice Ginsburg recently sat down with Joan Biskupic of the USA Today to discuss the importance of the Supreme Court having more women, and how the fact that she is the only women impacted the oral arguments and confidential discussions among the Justices about some still-undecided cases: Her status as the court’s lone woman was […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
How Do You Measure the Intelligence of a Judge or Judicial Nominee?:
The hubbub over Jeffrey Rosen’s TNR profile of Sonia Sotomayor raises some interesting questions about how you know might know how intelligent a judge or judicial nominee happens to be. This issue comes up a lot, so I wanted to blog a few thoughts about it. Broadly speaking, I think there are three common ways […]
Michael McConnell to Leave Tenth Circuit and Join Stanford Law Faculty:
The stunning news is here. Judge McConnell is one of my favorite judges; that’s a really big loss. I’ve noted before that there have been an unusual number of early retirements from the judiciary among the most academically accomplished of judges, including the likes of our own Paul Cassell (left to join the Utah faculty) […]
“Charges Seen as Unlikely for Lawyers Over Interrogations”:
The New York Times apparently has some sources who have summarized the OPR draft report on the interrogation memos.
More Good Stuff From Ross Douthat:
This time, a column on centrism within the GOP. And with the added bonus — at least to me, anyway — of a link to one my posts.
A Different Take on Justice Souter:
In his post below, my co-blogger Todd Zywicki writes: In the end, I don’t think that anyone would champion Souter as a anything other than a mediocre Justice. It is hard to measure how “good” a Justice is–one could imagine many different criteria: smarts, influence, coalition-building skills, etc. No matter what criteria one uses, however, […]
Lori Drew Update:
Readers following the Lori Drew case will be interested in this post by Kim Zetter on the upcoming sentencing scheduled for May 18th. As the post makes clear, Judge Wu has not yet ruled on the defense’s Rule 29 motion to dismiss, but is expected to do so soon.
Update on United States v. Davis:
Back in December, I blogged a series of posts about a 6th Circuit opinion, United States v. Davis, in which a panel sua sponte raised the question of a traffic statute’s constitutionality, struck down the statute as unconstitutionally vague, and then ruled that the unconstitutionality of the statute was not relevant to the outcome of […]
The Case for Karlan:
Bill Stuntz makes the case that Obama should nominate Pam Karlan for the upcoming Supreme Court vacancy over at Less than the Least. Stuntz’s emphasis on Karlan’s writing ability brings to mind her very funny graduation speech at Yale Law School in 2007. (Hat tip: Chad Oldfather.)
Supreme Court Trivia: How many United States Supreme Court Justices
married their secretaries? Which Justices did so?
Supreme Court Justice Retirement Rumors — in 1896:
Recently I came across this New York Times article from January 21, 1896, and I thought readers might find it interesting: JUSTICE FIELD NOT TO RETIRE — He Will Remain on the Bench So Long As He Works Easily. WASHINGTON, Jan. 21. — Associate Justice Stephen J. Field of the United States Supreme Court, in […]
The Myth of Justice Souter as a Yankee Republican:
Some people say that Justice Souter is a Yankee Republican, and that he seems like a liberal only because the GOP has shifted so far to the right. In an earlier day, the argument runs, he would have been considered a Justice on the conservative side. I confess I find this claim puzzling, and I […]
The Sotomayor Video:
I have a different reaction than my co-blogger Jonathan to the video of Judge Sotomayor. Here’s the transcript, as best I can tell: All of the Legal Defense Funds out there — they’re looking for people with Court of Appeals experience. Because it is — Court of Appeals is where policy is made. And I […]
Cameras at the Supreme Court:
Justice Souter famously said, “over my dead body.” But when he is no longer a Justice, will the idea get new life?
Why I’m Guessing Obama Will Nominate Elena Kagan:
I’ve been writing for a while that I would guess Barack Obama will nominate Elena Kagan to the Supreme Court to replace Justice Souter, especially over leading short-listers like Sonia Sotomayor. I thought I would blog a bit more about why I’m guessing that. As I see it, it seems likely to me that Obama […]