argues today that the FISA opinion made public yesterday proves that Bush was right all along that the program was legal: Ever since the Bush Administration’s warrantless wiretapping program was exposed in 2005, critics have denounced it as illegal and unconstitutional. Those allegations rested solely on the fact that the Administration did not first get […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Bush Says Goodbye:
Perhaps the most interesting thing about President Bush’s farewell address is how few people care about President Bush’s farewell address. But I thought I would open a thread on it anyway. Feel free to leave your thoughts on the Administration now coming to an end.
Some Comments on the FISA Court of Review Decision:
I was on a plane most of the day, delaying my promised blogging on the new FISA Court of Review case on foreign intelligence surveillance. Here are a few thoughts after reading the opinion. 1. First, keep in mind that the opinion has only a very slight connection to the legal issues that we debated […]
FISA Court of Review To Issue Opinion Upholding Protect America Act Surveillance:
The New York Times has the scoop. This is a very interesting development; stay tuned for lots of blogging on the opinion when it is released. Thanks to reader Ross Evans for the link.
Frontrunners for Obama DOJ Positions:
Sources speaking to the BLT are indicating that the following individuals are currently frontrunners for top posts in the Obama Justice Department: Lanny Breuer is likely to be picked as the head of DOJ’s Criminal Division; D. Anthony West is likely to be picked as the head of DOJ’s Civil Division; Mark Gitenstein is the […]
Volokh Conspiracy Caption Contest:
Submit your proposed caption in the comment thread.
Assuming Violations of the Fourth Amendment and Then Deciding the Scope of the Exclusionary Rule:
Today’s 5-4 decision in Herring v. United States reminds me of a broader point about Fourth Amendment cases: If you like the exclusionary rule, you really really don’t want the Supreme Court deciding the scope of the exclusionary rule in cases like Herring and Hudson v. Michigan in which the Court simply assumes without deciding […]
Responding to Tom Goldstein on Herring:
Over at SCOTUSblog, Tom Goldstein has a very different take than I do on today’s Fourth Amendment decision in Herring v. United States. Tom writes that his “preliminary reaction is that we will at some point soon regard today
Oregon v. Ice:
The Supreme Court hadned down a fascinating sentencing decision in Oregon v. Ice, dividing 5-4 on whether judges can impose consecutive sentences (sentences served one after the other if the defendant is convicted of multiple crimes) based on disputed facts not found by the jury. Justice Ginsburg concluded that the answer is “yes,” and she […]
Supreme Court Hands Down Herring v. United States:
Today the Supreme Court handed down what is probably the most interesting Fourth Amendment case of the Term, Herring v. United States, the case on whether the Fourth Amendment required suppression when a negligent error in a police database led an officer to incorrectly believe that there was an arrest warrant out for a suspect […]
When 35-Year-Olds Write Legal Memos:
Over at Slate, Yale Law professor Bruce Ackerman comments on the poor quality of John Yoo’s memos for OLC: While John Yoo did most of the staff work for [OLC Head Jay] Bybee, Yoo was barely 35 years old
How Not to Respond to Getting A Speeding Ticket:
More on the DOJ Civil Rights Division Hiring Report:
I blogged below about the DOJ Inspector General report on hiring in the Civil Rights Division, and I wanted to point out that the report is really pretty amusing (in a frightening sort of way) for the details it offers about the hiring process. In particular, Bradley Schlozman seems to have never thought about the […]
You can read that quote and a lot more in the DOJ Inspector General’s report, “An Investigation of Allegations of Politicized Hiring and Other Improper Personnel Actions in the Civil Rights Division.” Another taste: Schlozman made statements boasting to others about using political and ideological affiliations in hiring for career Civil Rights attorney positions. One […]
Serving Process on the Chief Justice at His Home:
The BLT has the scoop.