Author Archive | Orin Kerr

The Pie-Eating Contest:

I often hear lawyers recite an observation about making partner at a large law firm that goes something like this: Making partner is like winning a pie-eating contest in which the prize for winning is more pie. The point is that associates have to work long and difficult hours to make partner– and if they […]

Continue Reading

The Blakely Revolution, Justice Scalia, and the Living Constitution:

In his part of the majority opinion in United States v. Booker, Justice Stevens had what I think is the most honest explanation of the origins of the Blakely revolution. As sentencing guidelines schemes became increasingly popular in the 1980s and 1990s, the Court was faced with the issue of preserving [the] ancient guarantee [of […]

Continue Reading

Congress Drops Torture Provision:

The New York Times reports that, at the urging of the Bush Administration, Congress has dropped an effort to regulate “the Central Intelligence Agency’s secret detention and interrogation of top terror leaders like Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the mastermind of the Sept. 11 attacks, and about three dozen other senior members of Al Qaeda and its […]

Continue Reading

Implementing Blakely and Remedies for Structural Rules:

Today’s opinions in United States v. Booker provide an interesting example of the problem with judicial remedies for violations of structural rules — rules that require or forbid a particular relationship, but cannot compel a particular outcome. We see this most often in the context of the Equal Protection clause. The Equal Protection clause requires […]

Continue Reading

Initial Reaction to Booker/Fanfan Majority Opinions:

I have now worked my way through the majority opinions in Booker/Fanfan; while I’m sure I’ll have a better picture after I read the rest of the opinions, in the interests of timeliness I thought a quick and tentative post now might be of interest.   The basic picture is that the Apprendi Five held to […]

Continue Reading

Booker/Fanfan:

SCOTUSblog reports: The Supreme Court ruled today that the federal Sentencing Guidelines must satisfy the standards of the Sixth Amendment as applied in the Court’s ruling in Blakely v. Washington. Justice Stevens wrote an opinion on that point, and Justice Breyer wrote a separate opinion saying that the Guidelines can no longer be mandatory, but […]

Continue Reading

Important Article on Torture Practices:

Heather MacDonald has a fascinating article in City Journal about alleged torture practices and the war on terror. Her take is that there has been a big misunderstanding, and that the real story is how little interrogators can do, rather than how much. I’ve generally found MacDonald’s work to be quite reliable and accurate in […]

Continue Reading

Time to Bring in A Heavy Hitter:

The newswires are reporting that President Bush will nominate Third Circuit Judge (and former head of the DOJ Criminal Division) Michael Chertoff to be the new head of the Department of Homeland Security. Assuming Chertoff will be confirmed — and that seems a pretty safe bet, as he has been confirmed by the Senate twice […]

Continue Reading

“The Right Has the Wrong Legal Theory”:

Harvard lawprof Bill Stuntz makes the case that conservatives should embrace judicial minimalism instead of formalism and originalism : Most constitutional law deals with questions that other institutions could answer as well as or better than the courts. Where that is so — where there is room for reasonable doubts and disagreements, as is usually […]

Continue Reading

Wheelchairing Under the Influence?:

Although I can’t imagine what he was thinking, it seems that a Florida prosecutor actually brought criminal charges against a woman confined to a wheelchair for driving under the influence — for the crime of using her wheelchair after having a few drinks. The trial judge dismissed the charges. (Link: CrimLaw)   UDPATE: Several readers pointed […]

Continue Reading

The Nelson Report:

In his Friday column, Paul Krugman states that “[t]he Nelson Report, a respected newsletter, reports that Mr. Bush has made it clear to his subordinates that he doesn’t want to hear bad news about Iraq.” As best I can tell, the relevant excerpt from “the Nelson Report” has been reprinted here. I haven’t heard any […]

Continue Reading

Powered by WordPress. Designed by Woo Themes