The difficulty some of the Justices had with pager technology in City of Ontario v. Quon yesterday reminds me of a passage in an article of mine on why judges should be cautious about applying the Fourth Amendment to new technologies. In the passage, I argue that judges are particularly likely to make errors in […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
“Our Tech-Savvy Supreme Court”
Ashby Jones has this funny post at the WSJ Law Blog about today’s Quon argument.
Was the Stored Communications Act Actually Violated in City of Ontario v. Quon?
At today’s oral argument in City of Ontario v. Quon, several Justices took the view that whether Fourth Amendment “reasonable expectation of privacy” existed in the case depended in part on whether the disclosure violated the Stored Communications Act (SCA), an electronic privacy statute. That raises a surprisingly tricky question: Was the Stored Communications Act […]
Quon Oral Argument Transcript
The transcript of the oral argument in City of Ontario v. Quon is now available here.
Thoughts on the Oral Argument in City of Ontario v. Quon
I was at the Supreme Court this morning for oral argument in City of Ontario v. Quon, the Fourth Amendment text messaging case. Here are a few thoughts from what I heard over the speakers from the Lawyer’s Lounge: 1) Based on the questions, the strongest proponent of Fourth Amendment protection in this case appeared […]
Final Version of “Applying the Fourth Amendment to the Internet: A General Approach”
I’m pleased to say that the final version of my latest law review article is now online: Applying the Fourth Amendment to the Internet: A General Approach, 62 Stan. L. Rev. 1005 (2010). The abstract: This Article offers a general framework for applying the Fourth Amendment to the Internet. It assumes that courts will seek […]
DOJ Moots Constitutional Challenge to Getting an E-mail With Less Process Than a Warrant
I wrote about the dispute on Wednesday. I commented at the time: This is big news, and not just because it was mentioned on the Drudge Report. DOJ and some of the ISPs have been disagreeing about this issue quietly for years. What makes this case unusual is that the two sides have decided to […]
A Quick Response to Randy on the Use of “Unprecedented”
My co-blogger Randy asks for my explanation of part of a blog comment I left over at Prawfs on his use of “unprecedented.” To fill in readers, I was responding to a post that began: Randy Barnett is not just a great scholar; he’s also a great lawyer. Maybe someone else beat him to it, […]
Jotwell
I wanted to remind readers about Jotwell — the Journal of Things We Like Lots — a website that has been up for a few months in which law professors blog about their favorite recent articles. Somewhat to my surprise, I find Jotwell interesting more for what it says about the bloggers who are making […]
Does Federal Law Allow the Government to Obtain Opened E-mail With Less than a Warrant?
There’s an important e-mail privacy dispute brewing in Colorado: DOJ and Yahoo are clashing in court on the ground that the Ninth Circuit covered in its very weird opinion in Theofel v. Farey-Jones (2004), on whether the federal privacy law known as the Stored Communications Act allows the government to compel opened e-mail from an […]
A Common Law School Exam Mistake
With law school spring exams around the corner, I wanted to blog on a common law school mistake on “issue spotter” exams: Writing too soon, and then writing too much on the facts at the top of the fact pattern. This probably won’t make much sense to non-lawyers, and it will only trigger bad memories […]
“Where Is the Fourth Amendment Docket?”
I recently put up a post by that title over at SCOTUSblog. From the introduction: Next Monday, the Court will hear oral argument in City of Ontario v. Quon, a Fourth Amendment case on employee rights in text messages. Notably, Quon is one of only two Fourth Amendment cases to be decided this Term. And […]
Some Thoughts on the Reply Brief in City of Ontario v. Quon
The Reply Brief in the Court’s only major Fourth Amendment case this term, the text-messaging case City of Ontario v. Quon, has now been filed and is available here. Here are a few thoughts on it. (1) The parties focus significant attention on the Stored Communications Act, somewhat to my surprise. The Stored Communications Act […]
Preliminary List of Entry-Level Law Prof Hires
Larry Solum has the initial list of newly-hired law professors here. Congrats on the folks who landed a position, especially in this very tough market. (And if you’ll pardon a little special cheering for the home team, special congrats to 2007 GW Law grad Josh Douglas for obtaining a faculty position at the University of […]
Does Attaching a Thumb Drive to a Shared Computer Waive Fourth Amendment Rights in its Contents?
“Yes,” says Judge Maurice Paul in United States v. Durdley, 2010 WL 916107 (N.D. Fla. 2010), handed down on March 11. I haven’t seen any cases quite like this, but I tend to think the decision is wrong. In this post, I wanted to explain the decision and then say why I find its reasoning […]