From the Justice Department press release, issued last Friday: The department’s complaint alleges that Essex County refused to permit Yvette Beshier to wear a khimar (religiously-mandated headscarf) while working as a corrections officer…. Title VII prohibits discrimination in employment on the basis of race, color, sex, national origin and religion. The act’s religious discrimination provisions […]
Archive | Religion and the Law
First Circuit Rejects Yet Another First Amendment Challenge to the Pledge of Allegiance
The opinion was just handed down today, in Freedom from Religion Foundation v. Hanover School District.
Death Sentence for Blasphemy in Pakistan
The Herald-Sun (Australia) reports: A Pakistani court has sentenced to death a Christian mother-of-five for blasphemy …. Pakistan has yet to execute anyone for blasphemy, but the case spotlights the Muslim country’s controversial laws on the subject … Asia’s case dates back to June 2009 when she was asked to fetch water while out working […]
Standing to Challenge Laws that Allegedly Endorse or Disapprove of Religion
I blogged yesterday about the Oklahoma anti-sharia amendment case, and suggested that the plaintiff may not have the legally sufficient standing to challenge the law. Among other things, I wrote: 1. The plaintiff argues that the amendment is unconstitutional because it impermissibly expresses governmental hostility to Islam, and provides for discrimination against Muslims. But the […]
District Court Temporarily Enjoins Oklahoma No-Use-of-Sharia-Law-in-Court Constitutional Amendment
[UPDATE, Wednesday 1:40 pm: I have a follow-up post that suggests there is a recent precedent supporting the district court’s decision that the plaintiff had standing, but that ultimately concludes — as did this initial post — that the weight of precedent cuts against finding standing.] The decision was announced yesterday, but the opinion was […]
Federal Government Acknowledges Constitutional Limits on Housing Discrimination Law
From the Department of Housing and Urban Development’s Determination of No Reasonable Cause in Fair Housing Center of West Michigan v. [Redacted] (paragraph break added): [A]n individual complained to Complainant about a rental advertisement posted on a bulletin board at the [Redacted] Church … stat[ing] (in relevant part): “I am looking for a female christian […]
Antidiscrimination Laws and Religious Organizations
Prof. Doug Laycock — one of the leading Religion Clauses scholars in the nation — and the Becket Fund have just filed an excellent petition for certiorari asking the Court to review EEOC v. Hosanna-Tabor (6th Cir. 2010). The issue is well described in the petition itself: This Court has long recognized the right of […]
Rosary ban likely illegal, say Volokh and Kopel
Mann Middle School in Colorado Springs has banned students from wearing rosaries as visible necklaces. School officials have offered two different rationales: some gang members wear rosaries as gang symbols; some Catholics are offended by the wearing of rosaries on the neck. A Colorado Springs Gazette editorial on the controversy quotes Eugene Volokh and David […]
The Individualistic American Law of Religious Exemptions
Say that someone demands a religious accommodation, under one of the state or federal religious exemption regimes (whether under an employment statute such as Title VII, a Religious Freedom Restoration Act, a state constitutional religious freedom provision, or what have you). And say that most of his coreligionists don’t share this belief, or that the […]
Does Trucking Company Have a Legal Duty to Accommodate Muslim Employee’s Religious Objections to Transporting Alcohol or Tobacco?
That’s the argument made in Reddy v. Schneider National, Inc. (E.D. Pa. filed Oct. 15, 2010). Vasant Reddy says that he has “a sincerely held religious belief that he cannot consume, possess, or transport alcohol or tobacco,” and that he informed Schneider National of this. He also says that “less than 5% of the loads […]
Orthodox Jewish Arbitrations, Islamic Arbitrations, and Discrimination Against Witnesses Based on Sex or Religion
I’ve at times blogged about the propriety of letting people agree to Islamic binding arbitration (by private Islamic arbitration panels) of their disputes, just as they can agree to Christian or Jewish arbitration, and just as they can agree to secular arbitration. (See, for instance, this post.) This agreement could take place either before a […]
May Courts Interpret Contracts Under Religious Law (Islamic Law, Jewish Law, Canon Law, etc.)?
In an earlier thread, reader frankcross asks: Suppose parties call for Islamic law and specified a judicial forum. If a court shied away from deciding that, it would leave the issue unresolved. Essentially you would be denying judicial review to parties who wanted a court to use religious law and to resolve the question. Which […]
Islamic Law in U.S. Courts
I just came across an interesting case, Rahman v. Hossain (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div.), which was apparently handed down June 17, but which just appeared on Westlaw. An ex-husband was demanding the return of a $12,500 “mahr” payment that was made at the time of the marriage. The parties had apparently agreed to be […]
Christian in South Asian Country Sentenced to Prison for “Attempting to Promote Civil Unrest” by Screening Pro-Christianity Movies
From Kuensel Online (“Bhutan’s daily news site”): Gelephu dungkhag court sentenced last week a 40-year old man to three years in prison for attempting to promote civil unrest. Prem Singh Gurung from Tarithang was arrested on May 21, after villagers in Gonggaon and Simkharkha of Jigmecholing gewog complained that he was screening movies on Christianity […]
French Constitutional Court Decision Upholds Ban on Wearing Veils in Public Places
France’s Constitutional Council recently upheld the constitutionality of a law banning the wearing of veils in public places. The text of the decision is available in French here. Despite the importance of the issue and the large potential infringement on religious freedom, the opinion is very short and conclusory. For those of our readers who […]