I came across a story about this (thanks to InstaPundit for the pointer), and I asked Prof. Robin Fretwell Wilson (Washington & Lee) for her thoughts, since she has written on this Greek practice. (Note that the old Greek regime didn’t just enforce religious arbitration agreements entered by the parties. Rather, it specifically routed Muslim […]
Archive | Religion and the Law
News About Scholarship on Law and Religion
I just subscribed to the RSS feed of the CLR [Center for Law and Religion] Forum, run by the St. John’s University School of Law. The site mostly focuses on summaries of new scholarship about law and religion, though it should also have some original commentary on law-and-religion news. It looks like an excellent supplement […]
Insult-to-Religion Arrest in Egypt
Agence France Press reports (thanks to Prof. Howard Friedman at Religion Clause for the pointer): Cairo police arrested a man who allegedly … posted [statements on Facebook] ‘that were insulting to the Koran and the Prophet Mohammed and Islam and Muslims.’ … The youth was referred to the prosecution, which may charge him under a […]
Insult-to-Religion Prosecution Rejected in Poland
I blogged about the case when it was filed, but I’m pleased to report that a judge has thrown it out. From The Guardian (London): [Judge Krzysztof Wieckowski] has found [death metal singer Adam Darski, of the band Behemoth,] not guilty of offending religious feeling … [by] ripping up a Bible during a show [in […]
Discrimination Against Student Religious Speech
Schools, including K-12 schools, generally can’t discriminate against religious speech by students, outside the school curriculum (such as class assignments) or school-organized programs (such as graduations). If they allow extracurricular nonreligious clubs to form, they must let religious clubs form. If they allow nonreligious flyers to be distributed, they must allow religious flyers to be […]
Charter School May Not Sue State; Charter School Teachers’ Free Speech Rights Not Violated by State Curriculum Restrictions
From Nampa Classical Academy v. Goesling (9th Cir. Aug. 15, 2011) (nonprecedential) (unsigned opinion by Judges Reinhardt and Willie Fletcher, with Judge Rawlinson concurring in the result only: Nampa Classical Academy (“NCA”), along with plaintiffs Moffett, Kosmann and M.K., sued the Idaho Public Charter School Commission, alleging that its policy prohibiting the use of sectarian […]
Court Tentatively Decides That State Law Preempts Proposed San Francisco Ban on Circumcision of Boys
California Business & Professions Code 460(b) reserves the regulation of medical procedures to the state, and preempts contrary local rules: No city, county, or city and county shall prohibit a healing arts professional licensed with the state under Division 2 (commencing with Section 500) from engaging in any act or performing any procedure that falls […]
Man Declared Mentally Incompetent Solely Based on His Religious Beliefs
That’s what the Ohio Court of Appeals (State v. Daley, decided yesterday) said happened in the court below; the appellate court reversed the trial court’s mental incompetence finding. Daley was charged in March 2010 with retaliation, intimidation, aggravated menacing, menacing, and telecommunications harassment. The charges stemmed from allegedly threatening voicemail messages left by Daley on […]
“Fear of a Muslim America”
An excellent and characteristically thoughtful and balanced Reason article by Cathy Young; I highly recommend it.
Geert Wilders Acquitted
From de Rechtspraak, the website of the Dutch Judiciary and the Supreme Court of the Netherlands: Verdict of the Amsterdam district court as regards the Wilders trial, 23 June 2011 Amsterdam, 23 June 2011 – Hereafter, the most important decisions of the district court are summarized. For the integral text, please go to www.rechtspraak.nl … […]
Requiring Church Attendance as a Bail Condition
Today’s Mississippi Supreme Court decision in Mississippi Commission on Judicial Performance v. Dearman orders that Mississippi Justice Court Judge Theresa Brown Dearman be reprimanded and suspended for 30 days for — among other things — requiring church attendance as a condition of bail: In April 2006, Judge Dearman presided over the initial appearance of Philipe […]
Fifth Circuit Invalidates City Zoning Ordinance that Treats Churches Less Favorably than Similar Secular Land Uses
In its recent decision in Elijah Group v. City of Leon Valley, the federal Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit invalidated a city zoning ordinance that forbade churches in an area where very similar secular land uses are permitted. The court ruled that the ordinance violates the federal Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons […]
City-Displayed Sculptures, Religious and Otherwise
The Spokesman-Review reports: [A] Ganesha sculpture, created by Spokane metal artist Rick Davis, is one of 14 being dedicated today throughout downtown Coeur d’Alene as part of the city’s new “ArtCurrents,” a public art program. In ArtCurrents, which will reoccur annually, artists own the sculptures, which remain in place for a year and are offered […]
Modesty and Women’s Sports Uniforms
Prof. Howard Friedman (Religion Clause) summarizes three recent disputes related to women athlete’s desire to wear clothing that departs from regulations: In the wake of the disqualification of Iraq’s women’s soccer team by international sports officials because of the team’s insistence on a uniform that meets religious requirements (see prior posting), two more challenges to […]
Are the Proposed Circumcision Bans Motivated by Hostility to Jews (or Muslims)?
I’ve heard some people argue that the proposed circumcision bans (one of which is now on the ballot in San Francisco) is motivated by hostility to Jews. I quite doubt it, for a reason I mentioned in an earlier post: As of 2005, about 56% of newborn American boys, and about 31% of American boys […]