Three Yale Students Arrested For Burning U.S. Flag: No, it's not a First Amendment test case; as I understand the facts, the three students went on to someone else's private property and lit their American flag on fire. One of the three students is Said Hyder Akbar, 23, the author of Come Back to Afghanistan.

Related Posts (on one page):

  1. ABC News Site on the Yale Flag-Burning:
  2. Three Yale Students Arrested For Burning U.S. Flag:
Comments
ABC News Site on the Yale Flag-Burning:

From an online survey at the ABC News site:

Three Yale students have been arrested on charges of arson, reckless endangerment and other crimes for allegedly burning a flag on the porch of their apartment. One of the students translated for U.S. troops in Afghanistan. None have criminal records.

Should flag burning be a crime?
Yes. The flag is one of our most important symbols and desecrating it should be illegal.
No. What the students did is unfortunate, but they are protected by the First Amendment.
I'm not sure. I need more information.

The only trouble: They have apparently been arrested not for burning a flag on their own porch, but for burning a flag belonging to someone else, while it was still attached to his home; on top of that, the "flames [had] reached the building's awning." So, yes, that sort of flag burning should be a crime -- the crime of arson and reckless endangerment. And ABC News should be a little more careful in its reports.

Thanks to Greg Pollowitz (National Review Online's Media Blog) for catching this, and to InstaPundit for the pointer.

Related Posts (on one page):

  1. ABC News Site on the Yale Flag-Burning:
  2. Three Yale Students Arrested For Burning U.S. Flag:
Comments