My preliminary reflections on day three of the Sotomayor hearings are now up on WashingtonPost.com here. UPDATE: The NYT reports that, since Sotomayor’s confirmation is all-but assured, “both sides are trying to use the Judiciary Committee hearings to define the parameters of an acceptable nomination in case another seat opens up during Mr. Obama
Archive | July, 2009
A Footnote You Wouldn’t Want To See in a Court Opinion:
From Lopez v. Candaele, which I blogged about below: This case is likewise not mooted by Defendants
Los Angeles City College “Sexual Harassment” Policy Preliminarily Enjoined on First Amendment Grounds:
The case stems from the incident in which a professor in a speech class refused to grade a student’s presentation, apparently because of the religious nature of the student’s presentation, the student’s expression of opposition for same-sex marriage in the presentation, or both. (The professor apparently also called the student a “fascist bastard” in front […]
The Case Against Senatorial Deference to the President in Choosing Supreme Court Nominees:
I fully agree with Michael Rappaport’s argument that senators should not give broad deference to the President’s choice of Supreme Court nominees. Michael makes an especially good point when he notes that deference to the president is likely to lead to a Supreme Court that is biased in favor of excessively broad claims of executive […]
Jeffrey Goldberg on Human Rights Watch:
Jeffrey Goldberg of the Atlantic follows up on the controversy surrounding my piece on HRW’s fundraiser in Saudi Arabia. Goldberg reprints some rather remarkable email correspondence with Kenneth Roth, director of HRW, which is worth reading in full. But here’s the conclusion: In other words, yes, the director of Human Rights Watch’s Middle East division […]
Senatorial Deference to the President’s Supreme Court Picks?
Over on The Right Coast, Mike Rappaport asks Is the President Entitled to Deference on His Supreme Court Nominees?: Yes, say many right wing legal commentators. But the question is why? It is sometimes said that the Constitution gives the President the decision of which person to nominate and therefore the Senate should defer to […]
We’re Number 2! (or 3):
Paul Caron presents his Law Prof Blog Rankings, which are the updated quarterly traffic rankings (visitors and page views) of the Top 35 blogs edited by law professors with publicly available SiteMeters for the most recent 12-month period (July 1, 2008 – June 30, 2009). The Volokh Conspiracy is #2 for page views (15,467,726) after […]
Sotomayor Again Misstates Fundamental Rights Doctrine:
As she did yesterday, Sotomayor asserted that a right is “fundamental” if it is “incorporated” against the states via the 14th Amendment rather than that a right is incorporated against the states if it is fundamental. She then claimed that Supreme Court precedent established that that the Second Amendment is not incorporated. This too is […]
More from Seidman on Sotomayor:
Elaborating on his strong words about Judge Sotomayor’s hearing performance, Georgetown law professor Louis Michael Seidman writes: I want to elaborate on some of the (perhaps intemperate) comments I made last night. There’s no denying that Republicans on the committee put Judge Sotomayor in a difficult moral position, and I need not elaborate on their […]
Question for Sotomayor:
In his dissent in Plessy v. Ferguson, Justice John Marshall Harlan wrote, “Our Constitution is color-blind, and neither knows nor tolerates classes among citizens.” Do you agree?
Ricci Testimony is Political Stunt: :
On The Best of the Web, James Taranto questions the wisdom of the Senate Republicans’ tactic of calling firefighter Frank Ricci as a witness in the Sotomayor hearing: [H]aving a litigant testify against a judge who ruled against him is a political stunt that is likely to come back to haunt Republicans. Stuart Taylor of […]
I’ve Inspired Poetry!
I have never inspired poetry before but now Gerson Hepner, has posted on the Huffington Post a poem inspired by my Wall Street Journal article, The Seinfeld Hearings. It is called Islands of Rights, Seas of Powers, so I suppose it is actually inspired by Princeton Professor Stephen Macedo who coined that memorable imagery. The […]
Senator Feinstein and the Commerce Clause:
Senator Dianne Feinstein asked Judge Sotomayor about the federal government’s Commerce Clause power today. One question on the commerce clause in the Constitution. That clause, as you well know, is used to pass laws in a variety of contexts, from protecting schools from guns to highway safety to laws on violent crime, child pornography, laws […]
The Still Missing Case of Connecticut v. AEP:
On June 7, 2006, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit heard oral argument in Connecticut v. American Electric Power, an action against major utilities seeking injunctive relief for their alleged contributions to the “public nuisance” of global climate change. Judge Sotomayor was on the three-judge panel that heard the case. In 2007, […]
Human Rights Watch Goes to Saudi Arabia, UPDATE:
I blogged in June about a trip a delegation from Human Rights Watch took to Saudi Arabia, where Sarah Leah Whitson, director of HRW’s Middle East and North Africa division, spoke at an event at which funds were raised for HRW. She highlighted HRW’s work in Gaza, and HRW’s battles with “pro-Israel pressure groups in […]