The second day of the Sotomayor confirmation hearing — the first in which she answered question — revealed relatively little. Judge Sotomayor played defense all day long — delivering cautious, deliberate answers to even the most pointed questions — under the (probably correct) assumption that if she said little of substance, she wouldn’t give her […]
Archive | July, 2009
Sotomayor Rejects “Empathy” Standard for Judging:
One of the more interesting parts of today’s hearings was the following exchange between Judge Sotomayor and Senator Jon Kyl (R-AZ). KYL: Let me ask you about what the president said — and I talked about it in my opening statement — whether you agree with him. He used two different analogies. He talked once […]
Mike Seidman on Sotomayor:
On the Federalist Society Online Debate on the Sotomayor hearings (click here and scroll down), my Georgetown Law colleague Mike Seidman–a cofounder and intellectual leader of the Critical Legal Studies movement in the 1980s–is brutally candid in his opinion of Judge Sotomayor’s testimony today: Speaking only for myself (I guess that’s obvious), I was completely […]
Strong Words on Sotomayor:
From Part II of the Federalist Society’s “Originally Speaking” Debate on the Sotomayor nomination: Speaking only for myself (I guess that’s obvious), I was completely disgusted by Judge Sotomayor’s testimony today. If she was not perjuring herself, she is intellectually unqualified to be on the Supreme Court. If she was perjuring herself, she is morally […]
“All The World’s A Stage, And All the Men and Women Merely Players”:
From People v. Marinaro (Minn. Ct. App.) (some paragraph breaks added): The Minnesota Clean Indoor Air Act prohibits smoking in numerous indoor public places, including bars and restaurants. But the act makes an exception for actors and actresses while they are engaged in theatrical performances. Thomas Eugene Marinaro, the proprietor of Tank’s Bar in the […]
Sotomayor (and Hatch & Feingold) on Fundamental Rights and the 14th Amendment:
I have posted the following on the WashingtonPost.com’s “Topic A” commentary on today’s hearings: One of the things we hope to learn during confirmation hearings is a nominee’s approach to the constitutional protection of liberty. But in her exchange with Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-Utah) about the second amendment and its potential application to the states, […]
Sotomayor’s Testimony on the Didden Case:
In the same exchange with Senator Grassley where she misstated the holding of Kelo v. City of New London, Judge Sotomayor also defended her ruling in the controversial Didden case, where her Second Circuit Court of Appeals panel ruled that it was constitutionally permissible for a state to condemn property because the owners had refused […]
I Am Apparently “So Desperate for [Ann Bartow’s] Attention,”
according to Prof. Bartow herself. Her evidence: (1) I posted to respond to her criticism of the UCLA Law Review symposium (which I helped organize), and again to her “coincidence” post. (2) “[T]he flurry of private e-mails [I] instigated” — that refers to an e-mail I sent her to mention the post in item 1 […]
Another Sotomayor Misstatement of Kelo:
In response to questions posed by Republican Senator Charles Grassley, Judge Sotomayor made another misstatement about Kelo v. City of New London: [T]he issue in Kelo, as I understand it, is whether or not a state who had determined that there was a public purpose to the takings under the — the takings clause of […]
Pro Bono Free Speech Case:
I’m glad to say I have an interesting pro bono case — a petition for further review by the Nebraska Supreme Court in State v. Drahota (Neb. Ct. App. June 16). Here’s the petition, which was just filed yesterday, with some of the formatting details omitted; hope you find it interesting. Please note that the […]
Sotomayor’s Misstatement of Kelo:
During the confirmation hearings today, Judge Sotomayor considerably misstated of the holding of Kelo v. City of New London, making the decision seem more limited than it actually was. In response to questioning by Democratic Senator Herb Kohl, Sotomayor refused to reveal her view of Kelo, a standard tactic used by previous Supreme Court nominees, […]
Coincidence? You Be the Judge:
An interesting post from a law professor blog, written by a professor who teaches in South Carolina: South Carolina
That CIA Had Plans to Kill or Capture Bin Laden Was Public Knowledge.
Today at NRO, Andrew McCarthy comments on the revelation that the CIA was plotting to kill Osama Bin Laden. Yet the existence of a CIA program to capture or kill Bin Laden was public knowledge. Iraq-War critic Michael Scheuer, who ran the Bin Laden tracking desk at CIA, talked widely about it. Buzz Patterson in […]
The CIA Plan to Kill Al Qaeda Leaders:
I see that I’m quoted by Mark Mazetti and Scott Shane in their New York Times article today, CIA Had Plan to Assassinate Qaeda Leaders (July 13, 2009). I’m trying hard to maintain radio silence and not blog to let my shoulder heal up, but let me say something very brief about this. First, I’m […]
Reflections on Day 1:
Yesterday’s opening session of the Sotomayor hearings did not reveal much about the nominee, but may have previewed each side’s strategy: Democrats will stress her biography and experience; Republicans will raise concerns about specific cases and quotes, but reserve judgment. I contributed additional analysis to the Washington Post‘s “Opening Arguments” blog here. On thing that […]