Over at Balkinization, guest blogger Michael Greve offers an excellent post explaining the Competitive Enterprise Institute’s pending cert. petition in a case challenging the tobacco cartel. In short, the 1998 Master Settlement Agreement for the lawsuits initiated by some state Attorneys General against the largest tobacco companies is a violation of the Compacts Clause. Article […]
Author Archive | David Kopel
Fed. Dist. Ct. enjoins South Dakota ban on concealed carry permits for legal resident aliens
Decision here. Not decided on Second Amendment or other RKBA grounds. Very straightforward application of existing doctrine on equal protection and legal aliens. In short, state (but not federal) discrimination against legal aliens is subject to strict scrutiny. There is an exception for “governmental functions” which involve discretion in self-governance of the polity–such as voting, […]
“Health Laws of Every Description”: Obamacare and Original Meaning
Is the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act consistent with the original meaning of Constitution? David Gans (at Balkinization) and Charles Fried (testifying before the Senate Judiciary Committee) agree that the answer is “yes.” Both of them point to Gibbons v. Ogden and McCulloch v. Maryland. Gibbons is certainly a good foundation for advocates of strong […]
Judge Vinson rules federal health control unconstitutional
The decision from the Northern District of Florida is available here. In brief: 1. The 26 states lose on the argument that the mandate for drastically increased state spending under Medicaid is unconstitutional. State participation in Medicaid always has been voluntary, and remains so. The states did not argue that the revisions to the Medicaid […]
Why the media should not put the Tucson killer’s picture on the front page
Because, as Jack Shafer explains on Slate, the killer was seeking publicity. And such publicity encourages copycats, as I detailed in Rocky Mountain News columns in December and April 2007. Regarding copycats, Clayton Cramer’s award-winning “Ethical Problems of Mass Murder Coverage in the Mass Media,” Journal of Mass Media Ethics 9:1 [Winter, 1993-94] 26-42 is well worth reading. […]
More Guns, Less Crime? Answers from Kopel and others
The New York Times on-line “Room for Debate” feature poses this question today: “In Arizona, the shootings have led some citizens to call for more guns, not more gun control. Why is that?” Diverse answers are supplied by John Donohue (Stanford), John Lott (U. Maryland), James Alan Fox (Northeastern), Daniel Webster (Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School […]
Bleg on Eleanor and Theodore Roosevelt carry handguns
Here’s a picture of Eleanor in 1934 practicing with the revolver she had obtained the previous year. What type is it? Note: the Secret Service gave her the gun in 1933, when she insisted on traveling on her own without the agents. So the gun would be whatever the Secret Service was carrying in 1933. […]
Aaron Zelman, R.I.P.
Aaron Zelman, founder of Jews for the Preservation of Firearms Ownership, passed away on December 21. Zelman did excellent work in advancing the firearms policy discussion during the last two decades. His most notable contribution was research pointing out the frequency with which genocide has been preceded by prohibiting arms possession by the targeted victims. For example, his […]
Victory for firearms preemption in New York
Nassau County, on Long Island, New York, enacted an ordinance which bans handguns in non-traditional colors, such as pink. The ordinance declares such firearms to be “deceptively colored.” On December 28, the Appellate Division, Second Department (the intermediate court of appeals) ruled 4-0 that the Nassau ban is preempted by New York State’s handgun licensing […]
HSBC provides propaganda and banking services for the Iranian tyrants
Jennifer Rubin’s Washington Post article, “A bank that proudly does business in Iran,” explains it all. As a result, I just called HSBC to cancel my credit card.
Podcast on Virginia v. Sebelius
And on the other Obamacare cases in federal district courts. Rob Natelson and I discuss the various issues. 25 minutes, MP3 from iVoices.org.
Barack Obama and Gun Control: Effective and Shrewd
The Encyclopedia Britannica Blog is running a series this week assessing the Obama presidency. My entry, with the title above, argues that President Obama has been successful at promoting gun control, taking into account the fact that Obama has faced a Congress with strong pro-gun majorities, and that the Obama administration determined to spend its finite political capital on […]
Key points in Virginia v. Seblius
1. The facial challenge is allowed. See Lopez, Morrison. Salerno distinguished. pp. 7-9. 2. Rejection of the theory that the decision not to purchase federally-mandated is an “economic activity” since the individual will almost certainly purchase health services at some time in the future. “Of course the same reasoning could apply to housing, transportation, and nutritional […]
Final score on 2d Amendment in the November elections
Now that all congressional races have been decided, here the final tallies for how the election affected Second Amendment support in Congress, according to the NRA’s top federal lobbyist Chuck Cunningham: 19 of 25 U.S. Senate candidates endorsed by the NRA-Political Victory Fund won their races. The net gain is +7 votes (Ark., N.H., N.D., Oh., Penn., W.V., […]
The Chinese dictatorship’s reaction to the Nobel Peace Prize
I’ll be discussing the topic on NRA News tonight, at 11:40 Eastern Time. The program will remain available for replay at the website for a few days thereafter. In the meantime, please feel free to provide your own thoughts and analysis in the comments.