Author Archive | David Kopel

Opposition to Roberts:

I would add four additional points to the discussion of potential opposition to John Roberts: 1) Roberts is an outstanding lawyer, excellent judge, and impressive individual. He is the sort of person, irrespective of ideology, who President’s should nominate to the High Court (and those who have worked with him generally feel this way, even […]

Continue Reading

Alphecca’s Excellent News Round-up:

Alphecca, a self-described “gay gun nut in Vermont” compiles a weekly news collection of stories on firearms rights and media bias thereon. Today’s compilation is especially interesting. It includes: An Illinois bill, which may become law over the Governor’s veto, that would close the so-called “gun show loophole” and abolish state police record-keeping on firearms […]

Continue Reading

Kopel on the Media:

My latest media column for the Rocky Mountain News points out the flaws in Newsweek’s ranking of the top 100 American high schools. I also look at an error-filled retrospective on Colorado’s 1992 Amendment 2 anti-gay rights ballot initiative. And I bemoan the decision of newspapers to cover Israeli Independence Day with a biased story […]

Continue Reading

Professor Ratings:

Via Prawfsblog, I’ve discovered RateMyProfessors.com. This site is probably no more reliable than student evaluations, but it’s interesting nonetheless. UPDATE: A perceptive reader observed that the study cited in the link for “student evaluations” was itself based on data collected from RateMyProfessors.com. For those interested in independent assessments of student evaluations, I recommend this survey […]

Continue Reading

Hate Speech from Eleanor Holmes Norton:

Rick Santorum’s foolish analogy about the German conquest of Paris, which Master Conspirator Volokh recently denounced, was an early favorite for the Most Ridiculous Statement by a Congressperson for the Week for May 15-22. However, Senator Santorum must now take a distant second place to D.C. Representative Eleanor Holmes Norton. Opposing a NRA-backed bill to […]

Continue Reading

Florida’s New Self-Defense Law:

Florida Governor Jeb Bush recently signed Senate Bill 436, which expands and clarifies Floridians’ self-defense rights against violent attackers. The bill was the creation of former NRA President Marion Hammer, who is also head of Unified Sportsmen of Florida, the state’s major pro-gun group. The NRA has announced that it plans to take SB 436 […]

Continue Reading

NR on Filibusters:

The NYT is not the only inconsistent publication. NR flipped too — and more quickly — and is called on it in house. Can these positions be reconciled? Maybe. If I understand NR‘s editorial position, it is that the filibuster is worth preserving and eliminating the judicial filibuster could lead to the elimination of the […]

Continue Reading

NYT on Filibusters — Continued:

Stone Court thinks there is no inconsistency in the two NYT editorials I cite below. Certainly, one could oppose the filibuster on principle, but still object to changing the filibuster rule by a simple majority vote, but this is not the Times’ position. As the excerpts below should illustrate — and the full text of […]

Continue Reading

NYT on Filibusters — Then and Now:

Today the NYT editorializes against elimination of the judicial filibuster. According to the Times‘ editorialists, the filibuster and other modes of obstruction are “all part of the Senate’s time-honored deliberative role and of its protection of minority rights, which Republican leaders would now desecrate in overreaching from their majority perch.” In 1995, however, the NYT […]

Continue Reading

The “100 Hours” Proposal:

The NYT reports that last-minute talks to avert a “nuclear” showdown in the Senate over judicial nominees broke down. Commented Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid, “I have tried to compromise, and they want all or nothing, and I can’t do that.” This echoes Reid’s earlier sentiment that Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist never offered much […]

Continue Reading

When Students Replicate Errors on Their Exams:

I always find it interesting to see the same error repeated in multiple students’ exams. Sometimes this is a cause for dismay, as the fault is my own. Without fail, misstatements made in class are echoed back on students’ exams. Certain errors are also evidence that a given concept or idea was never communicated particularly […]

Continue Reading

In Defense of Academic Freedom (Properly Understood):

Professor Richard De George explains what academic freedom is — and is not — in today’s Washington Post “Outlook” section. He also notes academic freedom faces threats from both without and within the academy. On proposals to create an “Academic Bill of Rights,” De George has this to say: the controversy over the proposed “academic […]

Continue Reading

Do Firearms Harm Economic Development?

The international gun prohibition movement has been working hard the past several years to pick up allies from other international interest groups. The prohibitionist tactic is to argue that civilian possession of firearms harms “X”, where “X=the particular concern of the interest group.” Thus, feminists are targeted with the claim that firearms possession harms women […]

Continue Reading

“Large Capacity Clips” and Police Officer Safety:

The Brady Campaign, the largest of the gun prohibition lobbies, is holding a press conference today to “discuss how police officer’s jobs have become more dangerous since assault weapons with large capacity clips are more readily available.” There’s good reason to be skeptical about whatever claims the group will make. First of all, there are […]

Continue Reading

Powered by WordPress. Designed by Woo Themes