Author Archive | David Kopel

Caplan on Judicial Independence:

Legal Affairs editor Lincoln Caplan had this article on judicial independence in Sunday’s Washington Post “Outlook” section. I like Caplan’s magazine, but I can’t say the same for his essay. The article is filled with contradictions. For instance, Caplan writes: the legal right is increasingly divided between those who practice what the politicians preach and […]

Continue Reading

Current gun laws may be working very well:

That’s the suggestion of Posse Incitatus, which notes the result of a state-federal-local dragnet which rounded up over 10,000 fugitives. Only two percent of these fugitives had guns. P.I. suggests that the data show that American gun control laws work so well that criminals are much less likely to own guns than is the general […]

Continue Reading

Wilentz Plays with Numbers:

In today’s NYT, Princeton’s Sean Wilentz has a letter (second item) responding to Bob Dole’s op-ed on the filibuster of President Bush’s judicial nominees. Republicans obstruction of Clinton’s nominees “was much more ‘extraordinary’ than anything since,” Wilentz claims. His evidence is the rate at which appellate nominees were confirmed. between 1995, when the Republicans regained […]

Continue Reading

Judicial Ideology and Judges of Faith:

As much as I hate to disagree with my host, I think I have to side with Professor Bainbridge on this one. As I explained some time ago in posts on the nomination of William Pryor, here and here, I think it is fair to say that at least some Democratic Senators — and some […]

Continue Reading

Justice Breyer Defends Gun Possession:

Well, kinda. In Small v. United States, Justice Breyer writes the majority opinion holding that the federal prohibition on gun possession by any person “convicted in any court” of a crime punsishable by more than one year in jail does not apply to foreign convictions. Joining Justice Breyer on the side of the gun owner […]

Continue Reading

The “Most Ideologically Extreme”?

Yesterday Election Law Blog‘s Rick Hasen had an op-ed in Roll Call arguing that the filibuster is no more inherently “undemocratic” than the Senate itself. Setting aside the merits of Hasen’s comparison, I was struck by the opening of his piece: Democrats in the Senate have used the power of the filibuster to block from […]

Continue Reading

Althouse on Brooks:

David Brooks suggested that American politics will be hopelessly bitter so long as Roe remains the law in the land. (See my post here.) Ann Althouse doesn’t think it’s that simple: it’s not possible to redo the last 30 years. We already are where we are, and those who think abortion should be legal have […]

Continue Reading

Nuclear Harry:

Justice Harry Blackmun is ultimately responsible for ending the Senate filibuster? That is what David Brooks suggests in today’s column. Justice Harry Blackmun did more inadvertent damage to our democracy than any other 20th-century American. When he and his Supreme Court colleagues issued the Roe v. Wade decision, they set off a cycle of political […]

Continue Reading

Reconsidering Rendition:

Georgetown University’s Daniel Byman suggests that rendition is poorly understood, particualrly by its most strident critics. There is no question that renditions are a flawed instrument, especially when used recklessly and without exploring other options first. But it is a mistake to focus on the tool without understanding the problem it is used to solve: […]

Continue Reading

“Constitution in Exile” in NYT:

Tomorrow’s New York Times magazine will feature a Jeff Rosen article on alleged conservative movement to restore the “Constitution in Exile.” Slate has a preview here. A prediction: The article will conflate efforts to restore textual limits on enumerated powers with “Lochnerism” and judicial enforcement of libertarian ideology. Rumor also has it at least one […]

Continue Reading

Kerr Contra Krugman:

I don’t beleive Orin was unfair to Krugman in his post below. Contrary to Kleiman’s claim, Krugman does attack “conservatives” generally. In the last three paragraphs he specifically accuses “conservatives” of Lysenkoism and of seeking to “chill” scholarly inquiry. Those seem like pretty stiff charges to me. Krugman draws a parallel between the lack of […]

Continue Reading

Title IX Protects Whistleblowers:

Today’s Supreme Court opinion in Jackson v. Birmingham Board of Education holds, 5-4, that Title IX protects whistleblowers who accuse their universities of gender discrimination from retaliation. Justice O’Connor wrote the majority opinion. Justice Thomas wrote a dissent. The Associated Press reports on the decision here.

Continue Reading

Powered by WordPress. Designed by Woo Themes