The case is In re United States, — F.Supp.2d —-, 2009 WL 3416240 (D.Or. 2009), by District Judge Mosman. The issue in the case is whether the government must notify a person when the government obtains a search warrant to access the contents of the person’s e-mail account. Judge Mosman concludes that Rule 41 and […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
The Judge-as-Umpire Debate, 91 Years Ago
I suspect the debate over whether judges are like baseball umpires is as old as baseball itself, but here’s an early example I came across on Westlaw: A well-known English judge, watching village children drawing up rules for their cricket team for the year, said they were showing him how the common law of England […]
Fourth Amendment Rights in a Storage Unit Obtained Using a Stolen Identity
Today the Tenth Circuit handed down a very interesting Fourth Amendment decision, United States v. Johnson, on whether an individual can have a reasonable expectation of privacy in a storage unit rented with a stolen identity. As I understand the facts of the case, the defendant Johnson asked his girlfriend to rent a storage unit […]
Good News: You’re Making Less Money
The Legal Intelligencer reports on a survey of law firm partner compensation among men and women, and I was struck by this line: Some good news out of the survey was that the gap in compensation between male and female partners shrunk in 2009. But the report also pointed out that the smaller gap is […]
District Court Suppresses Contents of E-Mail Account in Bear Stearns Trial
The New York Times Deals blog reports on a fascinating new computer search and seizure decision, and one that I think was very likely wrongly decided: Federal prosecutors hit another setback on Monday in their criminal fraud case against two former Bear Stearns hedge fund managers, Ralph Cioffi and Matthew Tannin, after the trial judge […]
Happy Pro Bono Week
It’s National Pro Bono Week. I’m presently involved in two pro bono cases: United States v. Drew and McCane v. United States. It might be interesting for our readers who are lawyers to say what pro bono matters they are involved in right now; I hope they will consider telling us in the comment thread.
A Response to Delahunty’s “The Fourth Amendment Goes to War”
In a forthcoming essay, The Fourth Amendment Goes to War, Professor Robert J. Delahunty defends the October 2001 OLC opinion he and John Yoo wrote while at the Office of Legal Counsel on how the Fourth Amendment applies in the war on terror. The opinion concluded that the Fourth Amendment does not apply “to the […]
Officer Questioning in a Traffic Stop
Here’s an interesting (and to my mind troubling) recent example of how few limits the Fourth Amendment presently imposes on officer questioning during traffic stops, at least as presently construed by lower courts. In United States v. Chaney, decided by the First Circuit last week, an officer pulled over a car because it had a […]
Corcoran v. Levenhagen
I wonder if I’m the only one who sees today’s Supreme Court opinion in a death penalty case, Corcoran v. Levenhagen, as somewhat similar to the Court’s order two months ago in In re Troy Davis. As in Davis case, today’s opinion in Corcoran is essentially an order telling a district court to take a […]
Chief Justice Roberts Dissents from Denial of Fourth Amendment Case — Again
Chief Justice Roberts published a dissent from denial of certiorari today in a Fourth Amendment case, Virginia v. Harris, that is interesting in part because it resembles his dissent from denial of certiorari last year in Pennsylvania v. Dunlap (a.k.a. the “tough as a three dollar steak” opinion). In both Harris and Dunlap, a state […]
Funny Misquote
Last week, Justice Kennedy gave the keynote address at the George Washington Law Review symposium on judicial review. A story about the address in the Daily Colonial contains this nugget: Kennedy was a particularly notable choice for the event’s speaker because of his influential central position on the court. Kennedy’s opinion is often the swing […]
Why Justice Stevens Sees Himself as a “Judicial Conservative”
Justice Stevens has been known to classify himself as a “judicial conservative,” which has puzzled many court followers. Justice Stevens is often described as the leader of the Court’s liberal wing: He consistently tries to advance politically liberal outcomes, generally defending liberal precedents and often working to overturn conservative ones. Given that, why does he […]
Federal Deficit in 2009 Amounts to 10% of the Entire U.S. Economy
The federal deficit for 2009 is about $1.42 trillion, amounting to about 10% of the United States economy or a little under $5,000 for each person in the United States. Wow.
Choosing Lawful Versus Unlawful Music Downloads
Of people who download copyrighted music online, why do some people obtain their music lawfully from sites like iTunes while other people obtain it unlawfully from sources such as peer-to-peer networks? In a new paper, Marc Bellemare and Andrew Holmberg try to answer these questions using an empirical study of the views of college students. […]
“Cyberspace and the Law: Privacy, Property, and Crime in the Virtual Frontier”
Tomorrow I’ll spend the day at the Minnesota Law Review annual symposium, titled Cyberspace and the Law: Privacy, Property, and Crime in the Virtual Frontier. You can watch the symposium yourself here on the web. Participants include Pam Samuelson, Terry Fisher, and Dan Burk, among others. Our key note speaker is Judge Alex Kozinski.