As a follow up to David Post’s post below, I have some practical questions for those who think that legislators should “never vote on any bill unless they have read every word of it.” 1. Would you also require the legislator to understand the bill? Or is mere reading, with no comprehension, enough? And if […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
DOJ’s New Policy on Invoking the State Secrets Privilege:
Jonathan mentioned it below; the text of the policy is here. This gist of the policy is that DOJ will invoke the privilege only where it’s reasonably needed, not reflexively, and that a lot of high-ranking DOJ officials need to evaluate and review each internal DOJ request to invoke the privilege, with the final decision […]
Does the Wrongful Issuance of an Arrest Warrant Violate a Person’s Fourth Amendment Rights if the Warrant is Never Executed?:
The BLT has an interesting report on a case in the DC Circuit that raises a fascinating Fourth Amendment issue: Does it violate a person’s Fourth Amendment rights if the government wrongfully obtains an arrest warrant authorizing the person’s arrest if the warrant is quickly withdrawn and never actually executed? More specifically, if the person […]
Does It Violate the Fourth Amendment For Cops to Take Some Time Out and Play Wii During the Execution of a Warrant?:
The headline is not from the Onion. Tampa Bay Online reports: With guns drawn and flashlights cutting through darkened rooms, Polk County undercover drug investigators stormed the home of convicted drug dealer Michael Difalco near Lakeland in March. As investigators searched the home for drugs, some drug task force members found other ways to occupy their […]
Conceptions of Constitutionality — More Thoughts In Reply to Randy:
I appreciate Randy’s clarification below. Where we differ, I think, is that Randy believes that we need a correct conception of what it means to say something is “constitutional” that we should use even with people who disagree with it. Randy acknowledges that his personal views of the Constitution need not be used, but he […]
The Constitution and the Golden Calf – A Response to Randy:
Based on his comment below, I worry that Randy might misunderstand my view on his exchange with Professor Jost. In light of that, I wanted to explain my position a bit more clearly. I really don’t care whether we label what the Supreme Court says as what the Constitution “is,” or whether we use that […]
The Supreme Court “Cert Pool” Criticized:
Tony Mauro has coverage of a recent panel on the cert pool in which Mauro reports that several very prominent practitioners criticized the Supreme Court’s existing “cert pool” on the ground that the Justices defer too much to the law clerk’s recommendation. I didn’t see the panel, so I can only comment on Mauro’s summary. […]
Really:
In his post below, my co-blogger Randy channels Seth Myers and asks if those who follow the Supreme Court closely think that the Court would actually uphold hypothetical legislation requiring a person to have health care coverage: [I]n the absence of any clear super precedent, are my more realist colleagues absolutely confident that the four […]
Conference Where We Get to Sit Around And Talk About Facebook:
On October 23, Berkeley Law will be hosting a conference on the legal and ethical implications of social networking sites. I’ll be speaking on one of the panels, as will ATL’s David Lat and others. The schedule, with descriptions of the panels and the list of speakers, is here.
Constitutional “Is” Versus Constitutional “Ought” — A Brief Reply to Barnett and Jost:
Looking over the exchange between Randy Barnett and Timothy Jost on what it means to say something is “unconstitutional,” I wonder if their disagreement is primarily semantic. We all recognize that there is often a difference between how the Supreme Court has construed the Constitution and how a particular person thinks the Constitution should be […]
Irving Kristol, Dead at 89:
The New York Times obituary is here. UPDATE: I have deleted the comment thread, as unfortunately it brought out the worst in our readers; although a few of the comments were thoughtful, most were not.
Berkeley Dean Chris Edley on John Yoo and Academic Freedom:
Well put, I thought.
Americathon:
For some reason, watching the video of the Corvette that Jim links to below makes me think that America doesn’t need Cash for Clunkers to get out of this economic malaise. What America needs is a telethon. No, wait, an Americathon! (For more on this 1979 movie, see here).
Does the Automobile Exception Permit a Search of Computers Found in a Vehicle?:
Under the so-called “automobile exception” to the warrant requirement, the police can search a car for evidence without a warrant — including any containers in the car — if they have probable cause to believe that evidence is in the car and that evidence could be located in the place they search. But does this […]
The Voice of Oliver Wendell Homes:
A commenter points out that a short audio of Justice Holmes was recorded in 1931 for his 90th birthday, and it’s available online: Listen here.