The 1Ls have arrived for orientation here at GW Law, and a colleague of mine asked if I would repost my essay on how to read a legal opinion. Here it is: How to Read a Legal Opinion: A Guide for New Law Students.
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Bogus Claims About Health Care Proposals Persist:
CNN has some coverage here. The debate over health care legislation reminds me of the debate over the USA Patriot Act back in 2001 (albeit with the politics more or less flipped). In both cases, the legislation was very technical and difficult for a non-expert to understand. In both cases, you had a lot of […]
The Nightmare of Every Rookie Prosecutor:
Ouch. From Kozinski’s majority opinion: The government concedes the impropriety of many of these statements, but points out that the prosecutors were Special Assistant United States Attorneys on loan from the military. That’s no excuse at all; when the United States Attorney endows lawyers with the powers of federal prosecutors, he has a responsibility to […]
Justice Holmes Rocks:
As this seems to be WDYTOJOWH week at the Volokh Conspiracy — “What Do You Think of Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes?” — I thought I would risk annoying Ilya and David B by saying that I’m a big fan of Holmes. He was a marvelous legal thinker for his day, a true intellectual, and a […]
Lash on the Original Understanding of the Privileges or Immunities Clause:
A very interesting paper, via Legal Theory Blog.
Ted Olson, Law vs. Policy, and the Role of Courts vs. Counsel:
Like my co-blogger Dale, I was very interested in today’s New York Times article on Olson’s decision to argue in favor of a constitutional right to same-sex marriage. The Times mostly covers the story as “prominent conservative takes liberal view and thereby annoys conservatives.” That’s a significant part of the story. At the same time, […]
Sotomayor Joins Stevens, Breyer, and Ginsburg in Unsuccessful Effort to Stay Execution:
SCOTUSblog has the scoop. David Savage offers some context. UPDATE: I personally don’t see very much in this: Recall that one of Justice Alito’s very first votes was a vote against lifting a stay of an execution when the other conservative Justices voted to lift the stay. It makes sense that a new Justice with […]
Bob Novak, Dead at 78:
The news is here.
The Ninth Circuit’s Erroneous Analysis of Computer Searches in United States v. Payton:
The Ninth Circuit recently issued a remarkable decision on the search and seizure of computers in United States v. Payton. I suspect this case may go en banc, as the issue is pretty important, so it may not be the last we’ve heard about it. Still, I wanted to flag the many errors in this […]
A Supreme Court Without Stare Decisis:
I sometimes come across arguments by lawyers or bloggers that the Supreme Court should not rely on the doctrine of stare decisis. (For nonlawyers, a rough definition of stare decisis is the practice of following prior court decisions unless there are very unusual circumstances.) The argument against stare decisis is a simple one: It’s the […]
CrimProf Blog:
The CrimProf Blog is back, this time hosted by the excellent criminal law faculty at the University of San Diego. Thanks to Doug Berman for the link.
New Way to Resolve Actual Innocence Claims in Capital Cases?:
Today the Supreme Court took a step I don’t think I have ever seen before: When faced with an actual innocence claim in a capital case that was filed as a result or an original habeas corpus case, the court transferred the case to the relevant district court and ordered the trial court to figure […]
Fourth Amendment Rights in Online Financial Accounts:
A district court in New Jersey recently decided a case involving law enforcement access to an online financial account. I couldn’t find the case online, but the citation is Patel v. Hayman, Civ. No. 08-3586 (D.N.J. June 18, 2009), available at 2009 WL 1748964. The facts, as alleged in the pro se complaint: Plaintiff alleges […]
Is Cheney Writing a Tell-All Book Criticizing Bush?
Well, maybe not a tell “all,” but it sounds like he’s planning to say a lot. Via Barton Gellman, on Dick Cheney’s forthcoming book about the Bush Administration: Robert Barnett, who negotiated Cheney’s book contract, passed word to potential publishers that the memoir would be packed with news, and Cheney himself has said, without explanation, […]
San Juan, PR:
I’m going to be in San Juan, Puerto Rico, over the next few days giving CLE lectures on Fourth Amendment law hosted by the United States District Court for the District of Puerto Rico for members of the federal court bar. If any VC readers are planning to attend, please say hello. And if anyone […]