The Eleventh Circuit handed down an interesting Fourth Amendment case last week, United States v. Mitchell. The facts: The police suspected Mitchell of downloading child pornography, and they went to talk to him at his home. Mitchell candidly admitted to downloading child pornography. Mitchell then brought an officer to his computer, and officer asked if […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Judge Bybee and the Torture Memos:
The Washington Post has an interesting front-page story today on Judge Jay Bybee, who was the head of DOJ’s Office of Legal Counsel from November 2001 to March 2003. I find it a bit hard to know what to make of the story, as it’s pretty vague and the sources are mostly anonymous; the story […]
Controversial Weinstein Ruling Overturned:
Last year, I had a series of very critical posts about Judge Jack Weinstein’s opinion United States v. Polizzi, in which Judge Weinstein gave the defendant a new trial in light of his own prior decision not to instruct the jury about the mandatory minimum sentences that would be applied. Today the Second Circuit reversed […]
Does Arizona v. Gant Extend Beyond Passenger Compartments?:
In Tuesday’s decision in Arizona v. Gant, the Supreme Court limited the search incident to arrest power as follows: [W]e hold that [New York v.] Belton does not authorize a vehicle search incident to a recent occupant
When Is It “Reasonable to Believe” That Evidence Relevant to An Offense is In A Car? Does that Require Probable Cause, Reasonable Suspicion, or Something Else?:
Imagine the police arrest the driver of a car, and they handcuff and put him in the back of the squad car. The police want to search the car for evidence, but they don’t have probable cause to believe there is evidence in the car. The police can’t search the car based on officer safety […]
Thoughts on “The Legal Workshop”:
In his post below, Sasha links to the new website, LegalWorkShop.Org, which will post very short versions of published law review articles from participating law reviews. Larry Solum and Brian Leiter liken it to a Reader’s Digest version; I would update that to the 21st Century and say it forces each scholar to reproduce his […]
How Many Bloggers Use Blogging As Their Primary Source of Income?:
My co-blogger Jonathan Adler notes the Wall Street Journal essay reporting the following about blogging: The best studies we can find say we are a nation of over 20 million bloggers, with 1.7 million profiting from the work, and 452,000 of those using blogging as their primary source of income. That’s almost 2 million Americans […]
One Lesson of Arizona v. Gant,
handed down today: New York v. Belton is not a “super precedent.” Interestingly, though, the one Justice who was on the Court at the time of Belton has stayed pretty consistent. Justice Stevens did not sign on to the majority in Belton, and concurred in Belton only because he thought the automobile exception applied given […]
The Holding of Gant, and Some Initial Questions as To Its Application::
I’m really interested in what the new Fourth Amendment rule of Arizona v. Gant really means, and how it will apply in practice. Here’s the version of the holding on page 10: We hold that the Chimel rationale authorizes police to search a vehicle incident to a recent occupant
Supreme Court Limits Search-Incident-to-Arrest Exception:
The Supreme Court handed down Arizona v. Gant this morning, imposing a new limitation on the search incident to arrest power when the police want to search an automobile. Under New York v. Belton, the rule has been that the police can search the passenger area of a car when they arrest an occupant or […]
Congratulations
to my friend and GW colleague Peter Smith, who was voted the best teaching law professor by the student readers of the Blackbook Legal Blog. I’ve seen Peter teach, and he is indeed a fantastic teacher: he combines rigor, clarity, and humor in a way few can match.
Safford United School District v. Redding:
Tomorrow the Supreme Court will hear oral argument in Safford United School District v. Redding, a Fourth Amendment case involving an 8th grader who was strip-searched for prescription drugs believed to have been wrongly brought to school. The lower court opinion is here; Petitioner’s brief is here; the Respondent’s brief is here; and the amicus […]
U.S. News Rankings, 2009 Version:
As many in the legal blogosphere have noted, the the new U.S. News law school rankings are out. Some of the bigger news this year is an unusual drop for my own school, George Washington, which in the last decade has bounced around between 19 and 25 and averages somewhere around 21. This year we […]
Holocaust Remembrance Day — My Own Family’s Story:
David posted below about his relatives who were killed in the Holocaust. I have thought many times about posting about my own family’s experience, but haven’t until now. My father is a concentration camp survivor, and in my case my nearest relatives who were killed are my grandparents and my uncles. Here is their story. […]
Koyaanisqatsi:
The whole film, on YouTube. Cool. For background about the film, see here.