My co-blogger David Kopel links to the lawsuit filed by Michael Savage and others over the “Right-Wing Extremism Report” issued by DHS. Isn’t the lawsuit frivolous? As I read it, the lawsuit is claiming that the issuance of a government report criticizing certain groups violates the plaintiffs’ constitutional rights. But the Constitution doesn’t provide a […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
The Torture Memos:
The ACLU has links to the four torture memos released today here. I’m reading them now, and may post some thoughts later on. FIRST UPDATE: I’m initially struck my how little information is redacted, and by how much information the memos reveal about the details of the interrogation practices. Presumably this signals that the Administration […]
Symposium on “Cyber Civil Rights”:
For the last day or so, I’ve been participating in a symposium over at Concurring Opinions over treating cyberbulling and Internet harassment as a civil rights issue, and on what the legal response should be if it is so classified. Check it out if you’re interested in these issues.
The Feeders of Bush 43:
The list of OT09 Supreme Court clerks over at ATL is further confirmation that the two leading “feeders” of the Bush 43 judges are Brett Kavanaugh of the DC Circuit and Jeffrey Sutton of the Sixth Circuit, with Michael McConnell of the Tenth Circuit coming in third place. It will be interesting to see which […]
Schroeder Leading Candidate to Head OLP:
The BLT reports: Christopher Schroeder, a professor at Duke University School of Law, is the leading candidate to head the Justice Department
Judge Boyce Martin Makes Another Case Against the Death Penalty:
See his concurring opinion here. Notably, Judge Martin does not frame his opposition to capital punishment as a matter of constitutional law, as he has done before. Rather, in this case he expresses his view that “our scarce public resources can be put to better use” as a matter of policy, and that he believes […]
Fourth Amendment Seizures of Computer Data:
I have just posted a draft of a forthcoming essay, Fourth Amendment Seizures of Computer Data, forthcoming in the Yale Law Journal. Here’s the abstract: What does it mean to “seize” computer data for Fourth Amendment purposes? Does copying data amount to a seizure, and if so, when? This essay argues that copying data “seizes” […]
Discretion, the Rule of Law, and Political Ideology:
Last week, I posted the facts of the Third Circuit’s en banc decision in Pierre v. Attorney General and asked readers to chime in with what they would do if they were judges. Recall that this was the case with the inmate who was to be deported to Haiti where he would likely starve to […]
Citing Foreign Law, the Culture Wars, and the Law Review Article Hypo:
In his post below, David notes Justice Ginsburg’s puzzlement about opposition to citing foreign law when interpreting the U.S. Constitution: “Why shouldn’t we look to the wisdom of a judge from abroad with at least as much ease as we would read a law review article written by a professor?” This is a fair question. […]
2009 Survey of Books Related to the Law:
The Michigan Law Review‘s annual book review issue is now available online. You can read my own contribution here; it is a review of Christopher Slobogin’s book, Privacy at Risk: The New Government Surveillance and the Fourth Amendment.
Haven’t Had An Open Thread
in a while. What’s on your mind?
What Went Wrong in the Stevens Prosecution?:
In the Washington Post, Carrie Johnson takes a look.
The Role of Compassion in Judicial Decisionmaking:
Public debates on the proper role of the courts often focus on the tension between two competing visions: Some people think judges should adopt a narrow role heavily constrained by precedent and text, and some people think judges should feel more free to make rules and decisions in light of the equities of the situation. […]
“Internet records to be stored for a year”:
I don’t normally follow EU privacy law, as it’s often quite different from US privacy law, but this news from across the pond seemed worth noting: A European Union directive, which Britain was instrumental in devising, comes into force which will require all internet service providers to retain information on email traffic, visits to web […]
Sovereign Immunity and the Surveillance Statutes:
Yesterday the Justice Department filed a brief in Jewel v. NSA arguing that the statutory claims against the government for the NSA warrantless surveillance program cannot proceed because the causes of action under the Wiretap Act, the Stored Communications Act, and FISA are barred by the doctrine of sovereign immunity: [I]n the Wiretap Act and […]