Author Archive | Orin Kerr

Good Advice for Commenters:

I usually try to enforce our comment policy in part through warnings. If a commenter is crossing the line and being uncivil but I think there is hope that he’ll change his tune, I try to respond by pointing out the uncivil comment and reminding the commenter that comments must be civil. A while back, […]

Continue Reading 115

Constitutional Obligations and Signing Statements:

In the wake of the controversy over Eric Holder’s apparent decision to support the DC voting rights bill despite its likely constitutional problems, a lot of conservatives are advocating a position of strict constitutional duty: If the executive branch believes that part of a bill is unconstitutional, the executive must vote against the legislation. To […]

Continue Reading 54

Wow:

From the BLT, a remarkable development relating to the prosecution of Senator Stevens:   Judge Emmet Sullivan dismissed the case against former Alaskan Sen. Ted Stevens with prejudice — but the case is hardly over for the Justice Department.   Dissatisfied with the pace of DOJ’s internal investigation into the bungled prosecution, Sullivan said today that he […]

Continue Reading 76

Twelfth Night Mock Trial:

Tony Mauro has a very entertaining write-up of a “mock trial” at the Shakespeare Theatre featuring three Supreme Court justices (Ginsburg, Breyer, and Alito) and five other federal judges, sitting as the “Supreme Court of Illyria,” hearing argument in the hypothetical case of “Malvolio’s Revenge” from Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night. There’s lots of good stuff in […]

Continue Reading 6

GOP Threat to Link Memo Release to Johnsen/Koh Filibuster?:

Scott Horton reports, via Jack Balkin:   Senate Republicans are now privately threatening to derail the confirmation of key Obama administration nominees for top legal positions by linking the votes to suppressing critical torture memos from the Bush era. A reliable Justice Department source advises me that Senate Republicans are planning to “go nuclear” over the […]

Continue Reading

The Great Repression:

Interesting commentary on the cause of the current economic situation — and why it may continue for longer than it should — from my colleague Larry Cunningham.

Continue Reading 11

Holder’s Obligations and the DC Voting Rights Bill:

A lot of conservatives are criticizing AG Eric Holder for apparently taking the position that the DC voting rights law is constitutional when OLC thinks it is not. There’s an angle to the story that I haven’t seen addressed, though, at least on the right: Does Holder have an obligation to oppose the bill if […]

Continue Reading 43

That’s a New One:

From Paul Ohm, “the world’s first law review article that is also a working computer program.” I’m not sure I see the benefit of “computer programming and the law” that isn’t already captured by empirical legal studies, but then I have never seen an article with a picture of the top of my head before.

Continue Reading 30

Iowa Supreme Court Same-Sex Marriage Decision:

It’s available here, from Howard. The introduction: In this case, we must decide if our state statute limiting civil marriage to a union between a man and a woman violates the Iowa Constitution, as the district court ruled. On our review, we hold the Iowa marriage statute violates the equal protection clause of the Iowa […]

Continue Reading 195

Do Habeas Rights Extend to Bagram Detainees Under Boumediene?:

Judge Bates says yes, at least for detainees not from Afghanistan who have been detained at Bagram for several years: Under Boumediene, Bagram detainees who are not Afghan citizens, who were not captured in Afghanistan, and who have been held for an unreasonable amount of time — here, over six years — without adequate process […]

Continue Reading 87

Testimony on Constitutionality of DC Voting Rights Bill:

The Washington Post article cited below on the constitutionality of the DC Voting Rights bill references DOJ testimony in 2007 by John Elwood, then a Deputy at OLC. You can find the testimony here; it seems quite persuasive to me. For the contrary view, see Ken Starr’s 2004 testimony here.   UPDATE: My colleague Jonathan Turley […]

Continue Reading 63

Holder, OLC, and the DC Voting Rights Bill:

The Washington Post reports:   Justice Department lawyers concluded in an unpublished opinion earlier this year that the historic D.C. voting rights bill pending in Congress is unconstitutional, according to sources briefed on the issue. But Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr., who supports the measure, ordered up a second opinion from other lawyers in his […]

Continue Reading 144

Powered by WordPress. Designed by Woo Themes