For several years, I have been pondering the very difficult question of how the Fourth Amendment should apply to the Internet. In particular, I’ve been trying to come up with a set of general principles that should frame how to translate the Fourth Amendment to the Internet. I have just posted a draft article on […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Pleasant Grove City v. Summum:
The Supreme Court handed down Pleasant Grove City v. Summum today, a free speech case about the installation of a monument in a public park. I don’t follow First Amendment caselaw very closely, but I thought Justice Alito’s majority opinion was unusually good: Tight, well-reasoned, and persuasive. My only complaint was footnote 2, in which […]
Lori Drew, Take 2?: The Government’s Computer Fraud and Abuse Act Prosecution in United States v. Nosal:
I have blogged a great deal about the Lori Drew case, in which the government is arguing that mere breach of Terms of Service violates the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, 18 U.S.C. 1030, which prohibits accessing a computer “without authorization.” It turns out that there’s another case in which the government is testing a […]
Ban on Single Beer Sales in Parts of Washington DC:
The nanny state’s latest, in The Washington CityPaper.
District Court Overturns Magistrate Judge in Fifth Amendment Encryption Case:
Back in late 2007, I blogged a lot about a magistrate judge ruling in In re Boucher, a case involving a how the Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination applies to access to encryption keys. I argued back then that the magistrate’s decision was wrong on narrow grounds: Although the Fifth Amendment normally blocked the subpoena […]
Commentary on the NYU Protests:
The comment thread on yesterday’s post about the NYU protests raised some interesting points. I think my favorite was NaG‘s: Before anyone gets smug about the fact that these dolts are leftists, I found it quite common in college that students who were searching for a self-image were quick to go whole-hog nutso for whatever […]
“The Painfully Ridiculous End to the NYU Revolution”:
Gawker has the scoop. My favorite part about the video is that when someone does something the protesters don’t like, the protesters insist that the scene must pause for the “democratic process” and for “consensus.” It turns out that this just means that the protesters want to meet in private to debate amongst themselves how […]
Justice Scalia Takes on Honest Services Fraud:
Critics of the overcriminalization of federal law will cheer on Justice Scalia’s terrific dissent from denial of certiorari in Sorich v. United States today. Scalia explains why the “honest services fraud” caselaw is such a mess, and urges the Court to take the issue and construe the statute more narrowly. A taste: [T]his Court has […]
OLC in the Clinton Era and Today — A Response to Eric Posner:
Eric, I’m puzzled by your post below on OLC in the Clinton era. If I follow your argument correctly, you start with several cases in which the Clinton OLC concluded that the President had a particular power; you then note that alumni of the Clinton OLC were critical of the Bush OLC for concluding in […]
Obama Administration Adopts (At Least for Now) The View that Bagram Detainees Have No Habeas Rights:
The BLT has the scoop. From the statement of Acting Assistant Attorney General Michael Hertz: “This Court
New Filing in Lori Drew Case:
Readers following the Lori Drew case will recall that District Judge Wu held oral argument on the motion to dismiss back on January 8. Judge Wu has not yet handed down his ruling. However, this morning we filed the following Supplement to our Rule 29 Motion in light of recent caselaw developments.
Another Blogger for the Administration?:
From Al Kamen in the Washington Post: “There’s talk that Phillip Carter, who used to write the popular Intel Dump blog for The Washington Post’s Web site, is penciled in to be named deputy assistant secretary of defense for detainee affairs, overseeing such places as the Guantanamo Bay and Bagram detention facilities.” I hope the […]
Public Opinion on the Supreme Court and Its Relevance to Voters:
This Rasmussen Poll was conducted a few weeks ago, but I don’t think it has been widely blogged. From a survey of 1,000 likely voters: Should the Supreme Court make decisions based on what’s written in the Constitution and legal precedents or should it be guided mostly by a sense of fairness and justice? 64% […]
Working Hard and Good Grades:
I’m generally wary when the New York Times tries to tell its readers about what a “new generaton” thinks. What that important caveat, the NYT has an interesting article on how many college students feel that working hard should be taken into account in their grades, regardless of whether it leads to better performance. An […]
Gitmo Deja Vu:
Although it’s date-stamped with today’s date, I swear I have read this DC Circuit Gitmo decision before. It’s an opinion by Judge Randolph, ruling against Guantanamo detainees seeking release, that downplays the Supreme Court’s Gitmo cases and cites Johnson v. Eisentrager along the way. I can’t quite place it. Did I read this in 2003, […]