I’m wondering: Are symposium issues of law reviews generally more-often cited, less-often cited, or equally-often cited than non-symposium issues of law reviews? Does anyone know of general trends on this? I realize it presumably depends on the issue; that it depends in part on the journal; that citations aren’t everything; and that there are different […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
DOJ Report on the Torture Memos?:
According to Michael Isikoff of Newsweek, DOJ might end up releasing a report from its Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR) reprimanding the authors of the Bush Administration’s “torture memos” for failing to maintain the professional standards of the Justice Department. The report might then be referred to the state bars of the individuals who authored […]
Something to Keep in Mind:
According to 1 U.S.C. 1, In determining the meaning of any Act of Congress, unless the context indicates otherwise . . . the words “insane” and “insane person” and “lunatic” shall include every idiot, lunatic, insane person, and person non compos mentis[.] Hat tip: Mark Eckenwiler.
Ginsburg Surgery Update:
Via the BLT: “The pancreatic cancer for which Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg had surgery on February 5 has been determined as TNM Stage 1 by doctors at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center in New York City. All lymph nodes proved negative for cancer and no metastasis was found. . . “Extraordinarily, the approximately 1 cm lesion […]
Is the “Stimulus Bill” the Patriot Act of the Obama Administration?:
It’s October 2001, and a new President has declared a crisis that demands immediate action. The old policies of the past have failed, he announces, and it is time for far-reaching action that will expand the government’s power to combat the serious threats against the Nation. Time is of the essence, he declares: We must […]
The National Surveillance State: A Response to Balkin:
I have just posted a 5-page response to a recent essay by Jack Balkin on what Balkin calls “The National Surveillance State.” My response, forthcoming in the Minnesota Law Review, is titled The National Surveillance State: A Response to Balkin. The abstract: In his recent Lockhart lecture, published in this journal as “The Constitution in […]
Unintentional Seizures under the Fourth Amendment:
Last week, the Ninth Circuit handed down an amended opinion in United States v. Al Nasser that raises a fascinating and rather difficult Fourth Amendment question: Is a person “seized” for Fourth Amendment purposes if he reasonably thinks an officer is trying to stop him, and he stops in response, but the officer is actually […]
“You Try to Live on 500K in this Town”:
This is a few days old, but still pretty fascinating.
General Guide To Blogging, #128:
In a moderated comment thread, there is a 50% chance that a commenter who had an uncivil comment deleted will accuse the moderator of censorship and question the moderator’s commitment to free speech. (Because if the First Amendment means anything, it’s the right to do what you want with someone else’s private property without the […]
General Guide to Blogging, #127:
In a moderated comment thread, there is a 50% chance that any commenter who is given a warning for being uncivil will argue that they were not uncivil, demand an explanation of what exactly they did that was deemed uncivil, and seek an explanation of why others have not been warned when they did more […]
Reinhardt and Kozinski Duke It Out in United States v. Cruz:
If you’re interested in some engaging opinion-writing, check out the majority and dissenting opinions in United States v. Cruz, a criminal case on whether the jury had sufficient evidence to conclude that the defendant was an “Indian” for the purposes of a federal criminal statute. Judge Reinhardt (joined by Judge Thomas) concludes that it was […]
Living Without Lederman:
Apropos the developments mentioned below in the Ninth Circuit state secrets litigation, commenter Anderson asks a good question: How are we supposed to follow developments in detention and torture law without Marty Lederman? His decision to take a vacation from the rigors of academia to enjoy a cushy government job left a serious hole in […]
The Obama Administration, Middle Ground, and the State Secrets Doctrine:
Jonathan links below to the news coverage of the Ninth Circuit oral argument at which Doug Letter, an attorney for DOJ, announced that the Obama Administration had elected not to change its position on the state secrets doctrine in Mohamed et al v Jeppesen Dataplan, Inc., an “extraordinary rendition” case. It’s always hard to know […]
Judges Reinhardt, Henderson and Karlton Indicate Plan to Order California to Release About 25% of Its Inmates:
Howard has the links to this very interesting news development here. The tentative order of the three judge panel (all Carter appointees, as it happens) is here. This litigation is new to me, but it appears to have been going for a long time. The gist of the order is that California state prisons are […]
Chris Geidner’s Law Dork Blog
is back.