It’s available here, just in time. From the Chief Justice’s report: I suspect many are tired of hearing it, and I know I am tired of saying it, but I must make this plea again
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Sixth Circuit Withdraws Opinion Striking Down Traffic Law on Vagueness Grounds:
I blogged yesterday and the day before on United States v. Davis, the Sixth Circuit case handed down on December 19th that had invalidated a Michigan traffic law on the ground that it was unconstitutionally vague. Today the Sixth Circuit withdrew the opinion: The brief order withdrawing the opinion is here. This means that the […]
Gonzales on Gonzales:
From the Wall Street Journal, Alberto Gonzales complains about his reputation following his service as White House Counsel and Attorney General: “I consider myself a casualty, one of the many casualties of the war on terror.” Yup, when I think of casualties of the war on terror, I think of 3,000 people killed on 9/11, […]
Did the Sixth Circuit “Fuzzy Dice” Decision Violate Federal Law?:
I blogged yesterday about the Sixth Circuit’s recent decision in United States v. Davis, the case striking down Michigan’s statute on driving when the driver’s vision is obstructed by dangling or suspended objects in the car. Here’s a potential new wrinkle: It appears likely that the decision was handed down in violation of a federal […]
Northwestern Law Introduces Deferred Conditional Acceptances:
Paul Caron has the scoop. Apparently, Northwestern is issuing about 15-25 of these letters every year: The letters tell 1L applicants that they have been turned down for 1L admission but that they will be admitted as transfers if they can achieve a particular GPA or class rank at another school. The goal being, presumably, […]
Sixth Circuit Panel, Acting Sua Sponte, Strikes Down Statute Prohibiting Driving When Driver’s Vision Is Obstructed by Dangling or Suspended Objects:
On December 19, the Sixth Circuit handed down a remarkable decision in United States v. Lonnie Ray Davis. In an opinion by Judge Boyce Martin, the court struck down as unconstitutionally vague Michigan’s law that prohibits driving with dangling objects from the rear-view mirror when the object obstructs the driver’s vision. Notably, the briefs filed […]
KopBusters Hoax Looks Like It Was a Hoax Itself:
A few weeks ago, I posted about what was supposed to be a new reality TV show, “KopBusters,” that showcased police misconduct. The first show was about a fake drug house in Odessa, Texas, that the police allegedly raided without probable cause based on a bogus warrant. I then added an update, to the effect […]
End-of-Year Open Thread:
What’s on your mind?
Do Subjective Expectations of Privacy Matter in Fourth Amendment Law?:
The Supreme Court has said that government conduct is a Fourth Amendment “search” when two conditions are met: 1) the person searched had a subjective expectation of privacy, and 2) that expectation of privacy was objectively reasonable. When I teach Fourth Amendment law, I explain to students that, in my view, the two tests are […]
A President’s Lawful Authority to Respond to a Nuclear Attack:
In a recent interview with Chris Wallace, Vice President Cheney made the following claim about a President’s ability to launch a counterstrike if the U.S. came under nuclear attack: The president of the United States now for 50 years is followed at all times, 24 hours a day, by a military aide carrying a football […]
Motion for New Trial After Sequestered Jurors Allegedly Had Sex:
From the St. Louis Post-Dispatch: Eight years ago, a juror in a capital murder trial notified the judge that two other jurors had sex while sequestered
Fourth Amendment Rights in Numbers Dialed Stored Inside a Cell Phone:
I recently came across an interesting Fourth Amendment case in which a district court judge ruled that a defendant has no privacy rights in the list of phone numbers stored inside his cell phone: United States v. Fierros-Alavarez, 547 F. Supp.2d 1206 (D. Kan. 2008). This conclusion is wrong, I think, and why it’s wrong […]
Mens Rea and the Psychology of Pain:
From The Economist: If someone accidentally steps on your toe, it hurts. But does it hurt more if you think he did it deliberately? That, in essence, is the question Kurt Gray and Daniel Wegner of Harvard University asked in a study they have just published in Psychological Science. And their answer is that it […]
Oral Argument in United States v. Comprehensive Drug Testing:
I blogged a week or so ago about the Ninth Circuit’s pending en banc decision in United States v. Comprehensive Drug Testing, a computer search-and-seizure case arising from the investigation into steroid use in baseball. The Court held its oral argument on Thursday, and the audio is available for downloading here. The judges on the […]
Fed Soc Conference Near AALS:
Lawprofs who are attending the AALS in San Diego in a few weeks might also be interested in dropping by the Federalist Society’s annual faculty conference just down the street on January 8 and 9. Although it’s technically by invitation only, my understanding is that this is a formality for lawprofs and that invitations are […]