Over at The American Conservative, Freddy Gray comments on how often Internet comments are nasty and over the top: [A] disturbingly high number of people who comment . . . under web articles are mad and nasty and best ignored. Look around the web: it is often astonishing to see the levels of hatred and […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Supplement to Motion to Dismiss in Lori Drew Case:
A few moments ago, this supplemental memorandum to the Rule 29 Motion to Dismiss was filed in the Lori Drew case.
Liberal Justices Prevail in First 5-4 of the Term:
The Supreme Court has handed down Altria Group v. Good, a preemption case on cigarette labeling for “light” cigarettes. The Justices split 5-4. Justice Stevens wrote the majority opinion: It concludes that the smokers’ state law fraud claim against Philip Morris for misleading claims about light cigarettes was not preempted by federal legislation known as […]
Nondisclosure Orders and the First Amendment:
The Second Circuit has handed down an opinion on when nondisclosure orders served on an ISP comply with the First Amendment. The opinion both interprets and in some ways rewrites Congress’s work with National Security Letters. Here’s the key: [We] rule that subsections 2709(c) and 3511(b) are unconstitutional to the extent that they impose a […]
Did the NSA Call Records Program Cause the Major Controversy Within DOJ, and If so, What Does It Tell Us About the Legal Issues?:
Back in 2005 to 2006, the press reported on two major warrantless surveillance programs. The first became known as the Terrorist Surveillance Program, and involved real-time wiretapping of the contents of telephone and Internet communications that happened to be routed through the U.S. even though at least one of the participants (and most often, both) […]
Thomas Tamm Was the TSP Leaker:
Earlier news reports had tagged Justice Department lawyer Thomas Tamm as a suspect in the investigation into who leaked the Terrorist Surveillance Program to the New York Times back in 2005. In the latest Newsweek, Tamm admits that he was the leaker and makes his case for why he did it. (In the small world […]
Commenting About Commenting:
In his 2000th post at Simple Justice, Scott Greenfield expresses his frustration with moderating comment threads: [I]t’s the one aspect of this Blawg that makes me think I should hang it up. It gets unbearably tedious after a while, and sometimes painful to watch a topic veer off onto a tangent because the one commenter […]
Lessig to Harvard:
We don’t normally post individual law school hires, but this one seems worth noting: Larry Lessig is going back to Harvard.
No Soup for You, Article III Judges:
Over at The BLT, Tony Mauro has an interesting post on the proposed Cost of Living Adjustment (COLA) for federal judges that would let judicial salaries adjust for inflation. The COLA increase was originally inserted into the auto bailout bill, but it was pulled because it became controversial: [E]ven before the Senate killed the bailout, […]
Owens v. Guida and Cone v. Bell:
In his Owens v. Guida dissent, Judge Merritt suggested that prosecutorial misconduct was “typical” of the Memphis district attorney’s office and referenced Cone v. Bell, another death penalty case out of Tennessee in which Judge Merritt dissented. Perhaps not coincidentally, Owens was released on Tuesday, the very same day the Supreme Court heard oral argument […]
Better than a Kennedy:
Word is President-elect Obama will nominate former New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection Commissioner Lisa P. Jackson to be Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency. This is a much better choice than Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., who had been rumored to be in the running. I am sure I will have plenty of policy disagreements […]
“No Contact About His Replacement” Versus “No Contact” — A Response to My Co-Blogger Jim:
In his post below, my co-blogger Jim Lindgren wonders if Barack Obama was telling the truth when he said he had had no contact with Blagojevich at that time. In fact, Jim notes, there was a picture taken of the two of them shaking hands around then. So they must have had some kind of […]
The Role of the ACS and the Federalist Society:
In Thursday’s New York Times, Charlie Savage has an article on the influence of members of the American Constitution Society in the new Obama Administration, as well as the similarities and differences between the influence of the ACS and the Federalist Society. (The Post had a somewhat similar story a few days ago, as Jonathan […]
Legal Times Blog:
The BLT, The Blog of Legal Times, has had a lot of great stuff recently, including Tony Mauro’s coverage of Supreme Court arguments and excellent coverage of DC legal news. It averages 7 or 8 new posts a day, so there’s a lot of stuff there. Definitely worth checking out. UPDATE: To pick a recent […]
Oral Argument in Arizona v. Johnson:
Today the Supreme Court held oral argument in Arizona v. Johnson, a Fourth Amendment case on the stop-and-frisk power. You can read the briefs here, and the oral argument transcript is here. At its broadest level, the case raises the question of whether a police can “pat down” a suspect for weapons if the office […]