A decade ago, I spent a lot of time debunking misunderstandings of the USA Patriot Act. Unfortunately, the press coverage of the Patriot Act began in the (mostly) pre-blog era, and the media coverage of it was laughably bad. The problem was that most reporters had no idea what was in the Act, but they […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Are State Court Immunities for Fourth Amendment Torts Unconstitutional?
In a response to my recent post, Originalism and Civil Damages for Fourth Amendment Violations, Michael Ramsey argues at The Originalism Blog that there is a way to square originalist opposition to the exclusionary rule with originalist embrace of doctrines cutting back on Fourth Amendment civil remedies. The basic idea is that the civil causes […]
Originalism and Civil Damages for Fourth Amendment Violations
Originalists are often opposed to the exclusionary rule, the rule that evidence obtained in violation of the Fourth Amendment cannot be used in court. The exclusionary rule was made up by 19th and 20th century judges, the argument runs. At common law, the remedies for violations of search and seizure law were civil damages against […]
Herbert Wechsler on the ALI and His Career
I’ve blogged here before about the legendary law professor Herbert Wechsler. Thanks to Adam White, I’ve recently learned that there’s a long interview with Wechsler recorded in 1989 that is now on YouTube . Part 1 is below (2 hours), and part 2 is here (36 minutes). The interview is mostly focused on Wechsler’s work […]
Fourth Circuit Overturns Conviction Because Officer Used A Knife to Remove the Crack Tied Around An Arrestee’s Private Parts
Kevin Walsh flags a very unusual Fourth Amendment case out of the Fourth Circuit that reaches a rather surprising holding: The police violate the Fourth Amendment, justifying suppression of the evidence, when the police use a knife to remove drugs tied around a suspect’s private parts during a search incident to arrest. The case is […]
Should Conservatives Favor Government-Run Health Care to the Individual Mandate?
Over at Ricochet, via Instapundit, Paul Rahe argues that conservatives should prefer a government-run health care system paid for by higher taxes over an individual-mandate approach: Government exists first and foremost for the sake of our protection. Without it, our lives and our property would not effectively be our own. Government exists also to promote […]
Does Presence of a Concealed Weapon Create Reasonable Suspicion of a Crime?
A recent decision of the District of New Mexico, United States v. Rodriguez, 2011 WL 6739498 (D.N.M. Dec. 8, 2011) (Browning, J.) , addresses an issue of Fourth Amendment law that touches on Second Amendment concerns: In a concealed carry state, does police observation that a person is in possession of a concealed weapon create […]
If a Dog Sniff Around a Car is Not A Search, What About a Dog Sniff Around a Home?
SCOTUSblog flags a pending cert petition on an interesting Fourth Amendment question: What limits, if any, does the Fourth Amendment place on the use of a trained drug-sniffing dog to approach the front door of a home? The police might do this to see if the dog will alert for the presence of narcotics in […]
Limit Your Issues on Appeal
From the introduction to United States v. Bansal, a recent Third Circuit decision authored by Judge Aldisert: We note at the outset that Bansal’s and Mullinix’s briefs raise approximately 75 issues for our consideration. Although the government responds by calling to our attention no fewer than 339 cases drawn from the span of more than […]
“Is Hanukkah Responsive to Christmas?”
A study from the Economic Journal (2010), with the following Abstract: We use individual-level survey and county-level expenditure data to examine the extent to which Hanukkah celebrations among US Jews are driven by the presence of Christmas. We document that Jews with young children are more likely to celebrate Hanukkah, that this effect is greater […]
Larry Lessig Interviews Jack Abramoff
The topic: Lobbying and corruption in politics.
Standards of Review in Patent Law: A Comment on Kappos v. Hyatt
In Kappos v. Hyatt, to be argued on January 9th, the Supreme Court will consider the standards of review in Section 145 patent proceedings brought in federal district court. You can read Ronald Mann’s preview of the case here at SCOTUSBlog. As it happens, I wrote a law review article on patent law standards of […]
Final Version of “An Equilibrium-Adjustment Theory of the Fourth Amendment”
I’m pleased to say that the final version of my latest article has been posted at the journal’s website: An Equilibrium-Adjustment Theory of the Fourth Amendment, 125 Harv. L. Rev. 476 (2011).
The ABA and Law School Cost
Yesterday’s New York Times published David Segal’s lastest criticism of law schools, this time focusing on the role of the ABA. An excerpt: Anyone willing to invest $175,000 on a legal education, and hoping to earn a pile of money at a corporate firm, has plenty of options. But let’s say that your ambition is […]
Thoughts on the Oral Arguments in United States v. Nosal
I’ve blogged a lot about the Ninth Circuit’s en banc case in United States v. Nosal, on the scope of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act — and more specifically, on whether it’s a federal crime to violate an express written restriction on using a computer. You can watch last Thursday’s oral argument in the […]