Commenter Brandon, a frequent critic of my posts on the individual mandate, offers the following question tonight in a comment thread: Orin, The frustrating thing about your posts (especially on obamacare) is that you rarely, IF EVER, come out and just state your f**cking opinion. All we have from you are tidbits of hints and […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
The Grover Norquist Tax Scandal
Forget Newt’s problems; the real GOP scandal is Grover’s.
Congrats to Two GW Law Grads Clerking at the Supreme Court in OT2012
Pardon the parochial posting, but I wanted to congratulate two recent graduates of GW Law (where I teach) for accepting offers to clerk for Justices at the United States Supreme Court starting this coming summer. Mark Taticchi ’10 will be clerking for Justice Kennedy, and Ryan Watson ’07 will be clerking for Justice Alito. In […]
Supreme Court Considers Case on “Unprecedented” Assertion of Congressional Power
You’re no doubt familiar with this Term’s Supreme Court case involving a constitutional challenge to an “unprecedented” recent federal law. According to the challengers, the new statute exceeds Congress’s Article I power. Although Congress had long regulated the relevant kind of activity for economic reasons, for the first time it tried something new. Specifically, It […]
Fostering Strong Comment Threads, and the Effort Rule of Comment Moderation
I sometimes blog on the process of moderating blog comments. I realize it’s a bit “inside baseball,” as most readers don’t comment or run blogs that allow them. But I see Internet comment threads as a new and relatively important kind of online discussion, and I’m very interested in the conditions in which comment threads […]
Golan v. Holder
The Supreme Court has handed down its opinion in Golan v. Holder, holding Congress has the authority to restore copyrights in this country that had had lapsed. The vote was 6-2, with a majority opinion by Justice Ginsburg. A very quick skim suggests it is largely a replay of Eldred v. Ashcroft from 2003.
The Joys of “Anonimus”
A week or two ago, I banned commenter “Anonimus,” who had become kind of famous in VC threads for his steady stream of insults to other commenters. It won’t surprise regular readers of comment threads that Anonimus hasn’t been deterred by his banning: After making the usual complaints that he was the victim of censorship, […]
Legal Education Reform, But How?
The National Law Journal reports on a recent panel at the AALS conference on the need for changes in legal education. Readers will recall that Judge Cabranes also spoke at the same conference on the same topic, and he urged a return to traditional doctrinal classes and a reduction in “law and” classes. The National […]
David Addington Favors Transparency When Presidents “Test the Outer Limit of their Powers Under the Constitution”
During the Obama Administration, at least.
Citations to 18 U.S.C. 1030, the Computer Fraud And Abuse Act
I’ve often blogged about the scope of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, 18 U.S.C. 1030, the federal “unauthorized access” statute. This graph of the number of annual judicial citations to the statute from 2002 to 2011, from Westlaw’s ALLFEDS database, helps explain why I think it’s an important issue: Click on the graph to […]
The Ninth Circuit-vs.-Supreme-Court AEDPA Wars Continue
The Ninth Circuit panel: Pregerson, Paez, and a district judge sitting by designation. The decision: granting habeas relief despite AEDPA. Disposition at the Supreme Court: Cert denied. Publicly-known votes to grant cert: Scalia and Alito. From Scalia’s dissent from denial of certiorari, in Cash v. Maxwell: It is a regrettable reality that some federal judges […]
Volokh Conspiracy Stuff
Just a reminder for serious VC readers: If you want, you can buy Volokh Conspiracy t-shirts and other stuff. Because nothing says “I’m a libertarian law nerd who loves guns, free speech, and debating the scope of the Commerce Clause” quite like carrying a Volokh Conspiracy tote bag. We probably should have a way for […]
Curriculum and Legal Education Reform
In a recent speech, Second Circuit Judge Jose Cabranes argued that law schools should get “back to basics” with more bread-and-butter courses and fewer “law and” courses, in addition to other changes: To get back on track, law schools should shift their curricula back to core courses and away from the interdisciplinary classes that have […]
DOJ Files Supreme Court Brief Defending the Mandate
The brief is here, and it strikes me as significantly better than the briefs that DOJ was filing in the early mandate cases. In terms of atmospherics, it leads with a background of the health care industry to make clear that the industry as a whole is such a significant part of commerce, and it […]
Supreme Court Grants Cert in Dog-Sniff-At-The-Home Case
I blogged about the case a few days ago, and news of the cert grant is here. The QP: Whether a dog sniff at the front door of a suspected grow house by a trained narcotics detection dog is a Fourth Amendment search requiring probable cause? And so the most interesting Supreme Court Term in […]