The New York Times has a story on the police “stop and frisk” policies in New York City that states: Critics say that as part of the Police Department’s stop-and-frisk policy, officers routinely tell suspects to empty their pockets and then, if marijuana is displayed, arrest them for having the drugs in public view, thereby […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Taking A Computer Out of Screensaver Mode to See Suspect’s Facebook Wall Is a Fourth Amendment Search
The legal question: When a computer is in screensaver mode, does a police officer’s touching a key or moving the mousepad in order to reveal the contents of the screen constitute a Fourth Amendment “search”? The facts: The local police received a few citizen calls about a threat posted on Craigslist regarding possible planned violence […]
How Much Does the Mandate Case Matter for Constitutional Law?
Michael Dorf has an interesting Verdict column arguing that the mandate case is very important politically, but much less important than you might think as a matter of constitutional law.
Obama Administration Decides Not to Petition for Rehearing in Eleventh Circuit Mandate Case
So reports the ACA Litigation blog. I’m quite surprised, as normally DOJ would delay a case like this as long as possible– and try to eliminate the split — with a petition for rehearing. So it looks like it’s on to the Supreme Court, with a DOJ-filed petition for certiorari coming soon. That would make […]
The New and Improved SCOTUSblog
Over at SCOTUSblog, Tom Goldstein has a post introducing the new and improved SCOTUSblog site. The new site is sponsored by Bloomberg Law, and it will feature more commentary and a new approach to comments. From Tom’s post: Substantively, we are continuing our transition to more expert coverage. Last Term, we published symposia with leading […]
“Judges Compete for Law Clerks on a Lawless Terrain”
Today’s New York Times has this story on the federal law clerk hiring process. It’s old news for some of us, but probably of interest to others.
Richard Epstein Reflects on His Academic Success
From Epstein’s remarks on accepting the Bradley Prize in May: The great advantage that I had was no strong mentor, so I went off at my own pace in my own direction. The combination of philosophy, ancient law, and some economics that I picked up along the way set the stage for my work. If […]
Second Circuit Divides 6-6 on Rehearing Standing Case to Challenge FISA Amendments Act
I blogged about the panel decision in Amnesty International v. Clapper in March, opening and closing my post with the following two paragraphs: On Monday, the Second Circuit handed down a very important decision on standing to challenge secret surveillance programs in Amnesty International USA v. Clapper. The decision, by Judge Gerard Lynch and joined […]
Should Libertarians Prefer the Single-Payer Model to the Individual Mandate? A Response to Adler and Burrus
I appreciate the responses of Jonathan Adler and Trevor Burrus to my post questioning whether the mandate challenge would further libertarian ends. To recap, in my post I agreed that in the short run, given prevailing political winds, the mandate challenge would further libertarian preferences. But I questioned whether that would be true in the […]
Is the Individual Mandate “Unprecedented” Because It Is More Statist Than Previous Laws, or Because It Is More Market-Oriented?
One of the common claims made by opponents of the individual mandate is that it is “unprecedented” — and therefore constitutionally suspect — for Congress to use the Commerce Clause power to mandate the purchase of a product. Never in United States history has Congress interfered so much with personal freedom so as to mandate […]
Senate Judiciary Committee Passes Amendment to Prohibit Prosecutions for Terms-of-Service Violations
Kashmir Hill writes at her Forbes blog on the good news from yesterday’s Senate Judiciary Committee hearing markup of amendments to the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act: No, Faking Your Name On Facebook Will Not Be A Felony. Legal scholar Orin Kerr wrote an alarming op-ed in the Wall Street Journal yesterday, warning people that […]
Is Benzinga.com Just A Front for Plagiarists? [BUT SEE UPDATE]
For those interested in the case of my plagiarized op-ed, it seems to have jumped from the San Francisco Chronicle (where it was alleged to have been written by “Patrick Harvard,” a writer at Benzinga.com, but it has just been taken down) to Yahoo News and Forbes.com, where it is now allegedly written by Jason […]
Imitation is the Sincerest Form of Flattery, But…
I was fascinated to see this very persuasive op-ed on the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act by a Mr. Patrick Harvard that was just posted an hour ago over at SFGate.com, which as far as I can tell means it is going to be in the San Francisco Chronicle. But I fear I have read […]
My Wall Street Journal Op-Ed on the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act
Tomorrow’s Wall Street Journal is running an op-ed I authored on the proposed amendments to the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act. It begins: Imagine that President Obama could order the arrest of anyone who broke a promise on the Internet. So you could be jailed for lying about your age or weight on an Internet […]
AEI Panel on the Individual Mandate
This Thursday morning, I’ll be participating at an event at the American Enterprise Institute on how the individual mandate litigation might fare at the Supreme Court. The panelists include Eric Claeys, Gregory Katsas, James F. Blumstein, and Thomas Miller. And if you’re looking to make the rounds of conservative/libertarian think tanks that day, don’t forget […]