I attended the oral argument this morning in Florence v. Board of Chosen Freeholders of the County of Burlington, a case on whether the Fourth Amendment permits a jail to conduct a suspicionless strip search whenever an individual is arrested, including for minor offenses. To my mind, the case is really a follow-up to Atwater […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Nina Totenberg on the Influence of Justice Thomas
An interesting segment, and one that features commentary from the likes of blogfather Eugene, Ed Whelan, Tom Goldstein, and Charles Fried.
District Court Awards One-Time Criminal Defendant $1.7 Million for Malicious Prosecution After EPA Agent Manufactured Evidence — With the Apparent Motive of Out-of-Town Travel to Spend More Time With His Mistress
On September 30, Judge Doherty of the United States District Court for the Western District of Louisiana handed down a decision in Vidrine v. United States awarding $1.7 million in damages for a malicious prosecution. The facts of what happened are simply appalling, and they deserve wider attention. First, the background. Hubert Vidrine had been […]
Governor Brown Vetoes Bill on Searching Cell Phones Incident to Arrest
The U.S. Supreme Court denied cert last week in Diaz v. California, a Fourth Amendment case from California’s Supreme Court which held that a cell phone can be searched incident to arrest. Meanwhile, over the summer, California state legislators passed SB 914, a bill limiting searches incident to arrest in California. Just today, however, California […]
Steve Jobs Commencement Speech, 2005
With the recent passing of the remarkable Steve Jobs, it’s a good time to post his inspiring 2005 commencement speech at Stanford University. It’s only 15 minutes long. For my money, it’s hard to beat.
UCLA Law School to Host Inaugural Cyber Crimes Moot Court Competition
Cool.
Collection and Analysis of DNA Left on a Chair at the Police Station Not a Fourth Amendment Search, Court Holds
In recent years, lower courts have struggled to figure out how the Fourth Amendment applies to the collection of DNA from a suspect to try to prove identity in a criminal case (typically in rape cases). In general, courts have held that if a suspect uses a cup and throws it away, or spits on […]
The Defense Brief in United States v. Jones and the Four Models of Fourth Amendment Protection
In an earlier post, I looked at the Petitioner’s arguments made in the merits brief filed in United States v. Jones, the Fourth Amendment GPS surveillance case. In this post, I wanted to break down the Respondent’s merits brief in the same way. I. The Four Models of Fourth Amendment Protection First, a recap. In […]
Ken Burns’s “Prohibition”
The Prohibition Era combines two of my favorite topics: the Fourth Amendment and beer. The latter was banned, and the former was routinely litigated for the first time in American history. As a result, I was a natural audience member for the new Ken Burns’s series Prohibition, which began last night. The series is loosely […]
E-Mail Confidentiality Statements and the Electronic Communications Privacy Act
It is common for e-mail from lawyers to have a statement at the end indicating that the e-mail is confidential and may be privileged, and that if you have received the e-mail in error you should delete it. Sometimes the statement also includes this line: This email (including the attachments) is covered by the Electronic […]
October Term 2011
28 U.S.C. ยง 2 states: The Supreme Court shall hold at the seat of government a term of court commencing on the first Monday in October of each year and may hold such adjourned or special terms as may be necessary. Happy First Monday, everyone.
Justice Breyer on Tenure Standards at Harvard Law School in the Late 1960s
In the latest George Washington Law Review, Justice Stephen Breyer has an interesting reflection on writing his first law review article when he was a professor at Harvard in the late 1960s. It’s an interesting essay on what he was trying to say and why he wrote that article, but I was struck most by […]
Prof. Duane: “Don’t Talk to the Cops!”
Here’s an entertaining lecture by law professor (and former defense attorney) James Duane on why he will never talk to the police — or perhaps more accurately, why defense attorneys hope that their clients have not done so. Thanks to commenter Anton Iskabibble for the link.
Videotape and the Scope of Traffic Stops Under the Fourth Amendment
The Fourth Amendment allows the police to pull over a driver who has committed a traffic violation, and to detain that person for a reasonable period of time to investigate the traffic violation. The officer generally can ask questions unrelated to the traffic violation so long as the questioning doesn’t extend the traffic stop for […]
Five Chiefs: A Supreme Court Memoir
I’ve just received a copy of the new book by Justice Stevens, Five Chiefs: A Supreme Court Memoir. Based on a quick skim, it’s surprisingly interesting. Stevens offers his opinions on lots of cases as well as his fellow Justices, both past and present, and he includes many “behind the scenes” stories from his time […]