As most readers are aware, the English newspaper “News of the World” has recently been shut down over reports that the paper’s reporters regularly hacked into the voicemail boxes of celebrities and political figures to gather news for stories. The hacking has had huge ripple effects, ranging from its impact on UK politics to Rupert […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Legal Brief Discusses Blog Post on Earlier Round of Legal Briefing
Maybe it’s just me, but that seemed kind of interesting: See pages 10-11 in this brief recently filed in the Vermont Supreme Court’s pending case on ex ante search warrant restrictions, which quotes from this post. I hope to have some substantive comments posted about the second round of briefing soon, but for now was […]
Review of the OT10’s Fourth Amendment Cases
I have posted a quick review of the recently-completed Term’s Fourth Amendment cases over at SCOTUSblog.
What If Lower Court Judges Weren’t Bound by Supreme Court Precedent?
Last week’s post, What Should Conservative Lower Court Judges Do With Liberal Supreme Court Precedents?, drew some interesting comments. I wanted to respond to one common argument: Lower court judges take an oath to defend and are bound by the Constitution, not the Supreme Court’s erroneous version of the Constitution. As a result, the argument […]
The Cases Against Barack Hussein Obama
In the Westlaw database of federal cases, as of today, there are 202 opinions involving lawsuits against the President in his official capacity that name the President as “Barack Obama.” There are another 191 opinions involving lawsuits against the President in his official capacity that name the President as “Barack H. Obama.” But of particular […]
The Law Film School Scam
First the schools promised that everyone who enrolled would get rich, but then there were no jobs: The film school version.
Federalist Society Symposium on Cybersecurity
Last week, the Federalist Society hosted a symposium on cybersecurity that you can watch here (morning panel, focused on national security issues), here (lunch address), and here (afternoon panel, focused on business and criminal law issues). Two VC bloggers participated in the symposium. Stewart Baker gave the lunchtime keynote address, which you can watch here: […]
What Should Conservative Lower Court Judges Do With Liberal Supreme Court Precedents?
In his initial reaction to the Sixth Circuit decision upholding the mandate, Cato’s Ilya Shapiro made the following comment: While a progressive like Judge Martin could be expected to accept any exercise of federal power, it is shocking that an avowed constitutionalist like Judge Sutton requires Congress to show only a rational basis behind what […]
Cory Maye to Be Set Free
Radley Balko has the excellent news in the Cory Maye case, which some readers will remember from a few years ago (and which I helped out on myself at the death penalty stage back in 2006). For more, Maye’s wikipedia page has useful background.
The Puzzling Case of Moore v. State
Held, by the Indiana Supreme Court: A drunken passenger in a car that is pulled over for a traffic violation is guilty of public intoxication, on the ground that “established precedent has long recognized that a person in a vehicle stopped along a highway is in a public place for purposes of the public intoxication […]
More on the Presumption of Constitutionality
In his post below, my co-blogger Ilya Somin concludes that courts should not apply the presumption of constitutionality to the individual mandate: In my view, courts should not grant either congressional or state legislation a presumption of constitutionality. Such deference is especially inappropriate in situations where the the legislature is passing judgment on the scope […]
The Individual Mandate and the Presumption of Constitutionality
One of the emerging criticisms of the Sixth Circuit opinion upholding the individual mandate — and especially Judge Sutton’s separate opinion — is that the Sixth Circuit erred because the individual mandate should be presumed unconstitutional. Unless Supreme Court precedent is so clear that it compels a holding that the statute is constitutional, the argument […]
Judge Sutton on the Individual Mandate
Of all the judges tasked with assessing the constitutionality of the individual mandate, the one to watch so far has been Judge Jeffrey Sutton of the Sixth Circuit. As some readers know, Judge Sutton is a Federalist Society favorite, one of Justice Scalia’s favorite former clerks, and a regular “feeder” judge to the Supreme Court. […]
LearnLiberty.Org
Learn Liberty is a collection of videos on various aspects of classical liberalism put together by the Institute for Humane Studies. If you’re interested in libertarian ideas, there’s a lot of good stuff to check out.
Utah Court Misses Chance to Be a Leader in Third Amendment Jurisprudence
The rare opportunity arose in American Fork City v. Smith, decided by the Utah Court of Appeals on June 23. From the opinion, with emphasis added: David M. Smith appeals from his conviction of electronic communication harassment, a class B misdemeanor. Smith asserts various constitutional issues to challenge his conviction. We affirm. Smith first asserts […]