Author Archive | Orin Kerr

No, the Fourth Amendment Isn’t Dead

Judge Kozinski and Stephanie Grace have a short essay posted online arguing that the Fourth Amendment is “dead” thanks to the third-party doctrine — the rule that a person loses Fourth Amendment protection in information knowingly disclosed to third parties. Their basic argument has been made many times before in the law reviews, but I […]

Continue Reading 20

Supreme Court Agrees to Review Case on GPS and the Fourth Amendment

According to this morning’s order list, the Supreme Court has agreed to review United States v. Jones, the DC Circuit’s “mosaic theory” case on whether and when use of a GPS device installed on a car is a Fourth Amendment search. The Court added a question, as well: “Whether the government violated respondent’s Fourth Amendment […]

Continue Reading 57

The Historical Role of Warrants, Particularity, and Magistrates

The comment thread to yesterday’s post on ex ante restrictions for computer warrants led to some interesting questions, and it also suggested that it might be helpful to explain the historical role of warrants, the particularity requirement, and magistrates, in order to understand how ex ante restrictions strongly depart from the historical norm. So here’s […]

Continue Reading 60

Vermont Supreme Court Hears Oral Argument in Challenge to Ex Ante Restrictions on Computer Warrants

I’ve blogged before about the fascinating and important issue of whether magistrate judges have the power to impose ex ante restrictions on how computer searches will be executed as a condition of issuing warrants to search computers. As regular readers know, my view is that they don’t: I explained why in my recent article, Ex […]

Continue Reading 24

Nosal Case in the New York Times

Today’s New York Times has a Reuters Breaking Views editorial by Reynolds Holding, Anti-Hacking Overkill (see second item), on the recent Nosal case in the Ninth Circuit on the scope of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act. My coverage of the pending petition for rehearing in Nosal is here.

Continue Reading 0

Supreme Court Justices are Generalists

In his post below, Eugene writes: [T]he supreme courts generally agree to hear only those cases that they see as giving them the most likely law-clarifying bang for their buck. Thus, if you can show the U.S. Supreme Court that there is a disagreement among federal appellate courts or state supreme courts (a so-called “circuit […]

Continue Reading 27

“The Physical Computer and the Fourth Amendment”

The Berkeley Journal of Criminal Law has just published a very interesting article on computer search and seizure law: Josh Goldfoot, The Physical Computer and the Fourth Amendment, 16 Berk. J. Crim L.  112 (2011). I disagree with it for reasons explained here, but it’s a welcome contribution to the scholarship. Thanks to FourthAmendment.com for […]

Continue Reading 3

Today’s Miranda Trivia Question

Today the Supreme Court handed down a 5-4 decision interpreting Miranda v. Arizona in which the dissent criticizes the majority for not being true to Miranda and concludes with the following warning: Under today’s new, “reality”-based approach to the doctrine, perhaps these and other principles of our Miranda jurisprudence will, like the custody standard, now […]

Continue Reading 14

Supreme Court Expands Good-Faith Exception to Exclusionary Rule To Include Reliance on Overturned Law

The Court’s decision in Davis v. United States is here. The vote was 7-2, with Justice Alito writing for the majority and Justice Breyer dissenting (joined by Justice Ginsburg). The key question for the future development of Fourth Amendment law is if and when defendants can challenge adverse Fourth Amendment precedents in criminal cases. The […]

Continue Reading 62

Petition for Rehearing Filed in United States v. Nosal, the Ninth Circuit Case on Criminalizing Violations of Computer Use Policies

A petition for rehearing was recently filed in United States v. Nosal, the Ninth Circuit decision holding that an employee who violates his employer’s computer use policy is guilty of “exceeding authorized access” to the employer’s computer. I have posted a copy here. I hope the Ninth Circuit grants rehearing, as I think the Nosal […]

Continue Reading 28

OT01 Clerks Support Alison Nathan

Alison Nathan has been nominated for a judgeship on the Southern District of New York, and I was very impressed by this letter in support of her nomination signed by almost the entire complement of law clerks who clerked on the Supreme Court when Alison was clerking for Justice Stevens. Of particular interest, I believe […]

Continue Reading 85

Powered by WordPress. Designed by Woo Themes