The CBS affiliate in Boston reports, with video available through the link: A thermal imaging project in the city of Boston has been put on hold because of privacy concerns. Boston officials had hoped to have aerial and street-level photos taken across about four square miles of the city this winter using infrared cameras that […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Happy Birthday to the Volokh Conspiracy
The VC turns 9 years old today. You can see the first day of posts here.
Widener Law Professor Sues Dean For Defamation
The NAS blog has the scoop, about a lawsuit apparently filed today by Professor Lawrence Connell against Widener Law Dean Linda Ammons. The complaint is here. The NAS blog also points out that I submitted an affidavit on March 24th in the university disciplinary proceedings against Professor Connell. The affidavit I submitted addresses the norms […]
Applying the Mosaic Theory of the Fourth Amendment to Disclosure of Stored Records
I’ve blogged a few times about United States v. Maynard, the controversial D.C. Circuit case holding that over time, GPS surveillance begins to be a search that requires a warrant. Maynard introduced a novel mosaic theory of the Fourth Amendment: Although individual moments of surveillance were not searches, when you added up the surveillance over […]
Harvard Law School Exams, 1871 to 1998
This is the time during the semester in which law professors often post old exams to help students prepare for upcoming finals. Harvard Law School has done one better: It has posted all of the law school exams at Harvard from 1871 to 1998. Pretty interesting to see how exams evolved over time. (Here’s the […]
Constitutional Deja Vu in Winn and Berghuis
Reading over today’s decision in Arizona Christian School Tuition v. Winn, I feel like I’ve been here before: The decision reminds me of last year’s decision in Berghuis v. Thompkins. The two cases raise different issues, to be sure: Winn is about standing to bring Establishment Clause challenges, while Berghuis is about the standard for […]
Boston Globe Profiles Randy Barnett
Congrats to Randy for his profile in today’s Boston Globe. It begins: Libertarian legal scholar Randy Barnett, a former Boston University professor who now teaches at Georgetown, fulfilled a lifelong wish three years ago when he appeared in a low-budget sci-fi movie — a genre-blending legal drama about an adolescent parasite from outer space. Most […]
Ninth Circuit Decides Cotterman Case, Reversing District Court on Laptop Seizure at the Border
Back in 2009, I blogged about United States v. Cotterman, a fascinating Fourth Amendment case from the District of Arizona involving a forensic search of a computer seized at the U.S./Mexico border. Ninth Circuit precedent holds that the government can search a computer at the border with no suspicion under the border search exception, just […]
Movie References in Judicial Opinions
I’m generally skeptical of movie and pop culture references in judicial opinions, as they usually get more points for being cute than for being illuminating. But today’s opinion by Judge Kavanaugh in Uthman v. Obama had a movie reference that I thought worked pretty well. The issue in the case was whether there was enough […]
Supreme Court DIGs Tolentino
This morning, the Supreme Court dismissed as improvidently granted a Fourth Amendment exclusionary rule case, Tolentino v. New York, argued last week. Over at Crime & Consequences, Kent Scheidegger speculates about why; his speculation strikes me as a pretty good guess.
New Draft Paper: “Why Courts Should Not Quantify Probable Cause”
I have just posted a first draft of a very short essay, Why Courts Should Not Quantify Probable Cause, which is forthcoming as a book chapter in a volume dedicated to the late Professor William Stuntz. (I first presented the idea at the Harvard conference in his honor.) Here’s the abstract: Probable cause is one […]
Significant Test Case in Seattle on Lawfulness of Ex Ante Search Limitations in Computer Warrants
In a recent article, Ex Ante Regulation of Computer Search and Seizure, 96 Va. L. Rev. 1241 (2010), I pointed out a newly emerging practice of some federal magistrate judges in computer search cases. When the government applies for warrants to search for and seize computers, some judges are rejecting the applications — even when […]
Justice Scalia on the Activity/Inactivity Distinction
Commenter Richard Riley brings up an interesting point I haven’t seen mentioned before: Justice Scalia’s concurrence in Cruzan v. Missouri Dep’t of Health, 497 U.S. 261 (1990), has some pretty forceful language rejecting a proposed constitutional difference between regulating activity and inactivity. The issue in Cruzan was not the scope of Federal power, to be […]
Open Thread
What’s on your mind?
Oral Argument Audio in Davis v. United States
For those interested, the oral argument audio in Davis, which I argued at the Supreme Court on Monday, is now available here.