We haven’t had one of these in a while. What’s on your mind?
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Reply Brief in Davis v. United States
Today I filed the Reply Brief in Davis v. United States, the Fourth Amendment case I am arguing at the Supreme Court on March 21. Here is the full set of merits-stage briefs by the parties: 1. Davis Main Brief 2. United States Brief 3. Davis Reply Brief Also, here are the amicus briefs: 1. […]
The Strange Glitch in the Rhode Island Rules of Evidence
Professor James Duane has the rather entertaining scoop in the Green Bag.
Classic Dynamics in Internet Commenting, #4291
My original post: When Judge Vinson entered his ruling holding that the mandate was unconstitutional, it left the federal government in a somewhat uncertain position. Given that the mandate was subject to inconsistent decisions by district courts, and Judge Vinson declined to enter an injunction, it wasn’t clear what DOJ was supposed to do while […]
Richard Friedman on Bullcoming v. New Mexico
I had the pleasure of chatting with Professor Richard Friedman on Wednesday when I attended arguments at the Supreme Court. Professor Friedman has written up his expert impressions of the oral arguments in one of Wednesday’s cases, Bullcoming v. New Mexico, over at The Confrontation Blog: Impressions of the Bullcoming Argument. Thanks to Howard Bashman […]
Judge Vinson’s New Order in the Mandate Litigation
When Judge Vinson entered his ruling holding that the mandate was unconstitutional, it left the federal government in a somewhat uncertain position. Given that the mandate was subject to inconsistent decisions by district courts, and Judge Vinson declined to enter an injunction, it wasn’t clear what DOJ was supposed to do while the inevitable appeals […]
An Equilibrium-Adjustment Theory of the Fourth Amendment: The Basic Idea
I recently posted a new draft of my latest article, An Equilibrium-Adjustment Theory of the Fourth Amendment, which recently was accepted for publication in the Harvard Law Review. In this post, I wanted to summarize the argument for readers who don’t feel like wading through 60 pages of law review writing. Here’s the basic idea. […]
Oral Argument in Ashcroft v. Al-Kidd
I attended oral argument this morning in Ashcroft v. Al-Kidd, the material witness detention case. As expected, it seemed pretty certain the Court would reverse on immunity grounds. Beyond that, the Justices didn’t seem terribly interested in the substantive Fourth Amendment standard for using the material witness statute pretextually. As best I can remember, it […]
Michigan v. Bryant and the Future of the Confrontation Clause
The Supreme Court handed down Michigan v. Bryant today, and it voted 6-2 (with Kagan recused) to allow police officers to testify about what a mortally wounded crime victim told the police about the identity and description of his shooter. The case involves the Confrontation Clause, and the issue is whether the statement of the […]
Lecture on the Dissenting Opinions of Judge Henry Friendly
Regular readers know of my love of all things Henry Friendly, so I wanted to flag this interesting lecture (mp3) about Judge Friendly’s dissenting opinions by Judge Michael Boudin, a former Friendly clerk. The lecture was delivered recently at the University of Virginia Law School, and it lasts 46 minutes. UPDATE: Adam White points out […]
The Fourth Amendment and National Security Detention
Over at Prawfs, Steve Vladeck has an extended response to my recent post, The Strange Case of Ashcroft v. Al-Kidd. In my post, I argued that it was strange that DOJ is not making arguments based on national security interests to justify Al-Kidd’s detention. In Steve’s response, An Al-Kidd Reality Check: The Myth of Non-Statutory […]
Errors and Oddities on the U.S. Citizenship Test
Dafna Linzer has the scoop over at ProPublica. An excerpt: Then there is Question 12: What is the “rule of law”? I showed it to lawyers and law professors. They were stumped. There are four acceptable answers: “Everyone must follow the law”; “Leaders must obey the law”; “Government must obey the law”; “No one is […]
Happy Sestercentennial of James Otis’s Argument in Paxton’s Case!
Don’t forget to celebrate. Details, for Fourth Amendment geeks and legal history buffs, are here.
Helpful Links to Supreme Court Fourth Amendment Decisions
John Wesley Hall has assembled the links here at FourthAmendment.com. Sweet.
Federalist Society Podcast on the Government’s Duty to Defend the Law — And A Few More Thoughts on the Decision Not to Defend DOMA
The Federalist Society had an interesting podcast on the issue back in October that you can listen to here. It lasts 40 minutes, and it features Walter Dellinger, John Eastman, John Baker, and Dean Reuter. In thinking over my reaction from yesterday, some of the feedback I’ve received has me somewhat less concerned than I […]