In response to my earlier post on the Obama Administration’s decision not to defend DOMA, Walter Dellinger writes in via e-mail (posted with his permission): Orin, your post comparing what the Justice Department has announced it will do in DOMA cases to some of John Yoo’s theories of presidential power doesn’t give proper weight to […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
The Executive Power Grab in the Decision Not to Defend DOMA
I can understand the intense political pressure on the Obama Administration not to defend DOMA. Presumably Obama and pretty much every significant lawyer in the Obama Administration opposes DOMA, whether or not they can take that position on the record. For what it’s worth, I oppose it, too. At the same time, I worry that […]
DOMA and the Individual Mandate
If the Obama Administration won’t defend the constitutionality of the Defense of Marriage Act, what are the chances that a future Republican administration would defend the constitutionality of the individual mandate? To my mind, this adds a very interesting wrinkle to the individual mandate litigation (and, more broadly, to the role of the Executive Branch […]
Another District Court Decision on the Constitutionality of the Individual Mandate
This one is Mead v. Holder, from Judge Kessler of the United States District Court for the District of Columbia, who concludes the mandate is constitutional. From the opinion: [T]he individual mandate provision is an appropriate means which is rationally related to the achievement of Congress’s larger goal of reforming the national health insurance system. […]
Get Your Law Degree Online!
Not from a diploma mill, but from a Top 10 law school according to the U.S. News ranking, NYU. The only downside: It has to be an LLM in Tax. (Hat tip: Paul Caron)
The Strange Case of Ashcroft v. Al-Kidd
Next week, the Supreme Court will be hearing oral argument in Ashcroft v. Al-Kidd, a case on material witness and national security detention. Al-Kidd is a rather strange Fourth Amendment case, and in this post I wanted to explain why I think it’s strange case and how that strangeness might influence what the Court will […]
Cutting and Pasting into MS Word
Pardon me if everyone knows this, but in case some don’t, here’s a useful tip for cutting-and-pasting formatted text from the Web or .pdf documents into MS Word. As Word users know, cutting-and-pasting normally retains the original formatting of the text, creating a mess when you paste it into Word. Here’s how to avoid that: […]
Interview With Lawrence Connell, the Criminal Law Professor Suspended for His Hypotheticals
You can read it here. Perhaps the most interesting section: Q: Can you give me an example of a hypothetical you might have used in class, to which the students who complained might have been referring? Can you describe the context in which you would have used it? A: Yes, here is one: The Dean […]
Predicting How the Mandate Might Fare at the Supreme Court: Explaining Chief Justice Roberts’ Vote — and Opinion Assignment — in United States v. Comstock
Legal debates over the constitutionality of the individtal mandate generally focus on three different questions: (1) As a matter of constitutional theory, how should a court rule based on a normative theory of interpretation; (2) As a matter of existing doctrine, how does the mandate fit (or not fit) into existing law, and (3) As […]
Police Obtain Warrant to Search “All Persons” Who Enter Apartment Parking Lot Where Drug Selling Commonly Occurs
In Sarasota, Florida, a vacant lot next to an apartment building has become a vibrant open-air drug market. The police are having trouble cleaning it up. So the police tried something they had never tried before: The applied for, and obtained, a warrant to search “all persons” who parked or set foot in the apartment […]
Criminal Law Professor Suspended For Classroom Hypotheticals In Which Law School Dean is Murdered
One of the common ways that law professors keep students mildly entertained in class is by posing hypotheticals involving their professors and the Dean. I ‘m not sure why this is so funny, but students just love it. If you teach first-year criminal law, which typically focuses heavily on homicide crimes, that means you spend […]
I’m Guessing This Legal Argument Won’t Work
From the www.wkyc.com in Cleveland/Akron, via SCOTUSblog: Frank G. Spisak Jr., the convicted killer of three who is scheduled to be executed Thursday, is making a last-minute appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court to delay his execution based on comments against the death penalty by Ohio Supreme Court Justice Paul Pfeifer. Spisak has been on […]
Today’s VC Trivia Question
How many past or current U.S. Supreme Court Justices were full-time law professors for at least one academic year before serving on the Court?
Michael Dreeben on Supreme Court Advocacy, Appellate Practice, and the SG’s Office
Michael Dreeben is the Deputy Solicitor General of the United States who specializes in criminal law. He has argued 77 cases in the Supreme Court, and he’s one of the very best advocates who appears regularly before the Justices. This past fall he was a visiting professor at Duke Law School, and he sat down […]
Federalism and Tort Reform
Cornell lawprof William Jacobson detects a potential contradiction in Republican politicians’ view on constitutional federalism [HT: Steve Bainbridge]. Many of them claim that the Obamacare individual mandate falls outside of Congress’ power, but simultaneously support federally mandated tort reform that would override state tort law: If we are against the federal government forcing us to […]