As I read Justice Stevens’ essay on the death penalty, linked to below by Jonathan Adler and now posted online, the Supreme Court’s striking down the death penalty in 1972 was an example of the Justices “appropriately . . . just trying to interpret the Constitution.” On the other hand, the 1991 decision permitting victim-impact […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
“Students Campaign For Alternative Hummus”
No, it’s not The Onion: It’s a real political protest at Princeton.
Petition for Certiorari Filed in Pineda-Moreno, The Ninth Circuit GPS Case
A petition for certiorari was recently filed asking the Supreme Court to review United States v. Pineda-Moreno, the Ninth Circuit case allowing warrantless GPS surveillance. I have posted a copy of the cert petition here. There’s been a lot of interest in this case thanks to Judge Kozinski’s over-the-top dissent from denial of rehearing, so […]
Guest-Blogging General This Week at the LawFare Blog
This should be interesting: We are thrilled to be joined this week by a guest blogger: Brigadier General Mark Martins. General Martins commands the Rule of Law Field Force–Afghanistan . . . [T]he U.S. military and diplomatic mission are assembling a substantial and diverse task force of lawyers, engineers, trainers, advisors, procurement experts, military police, […]
DC Circuit Denies Rehearing in United States v. Maynard, the “Mosaic Theory” Case, by 5-4 Vote
The DC Circuit has just noted on its docket that it has denied rehearing in United States v. Maynard, the GPS case introducing a new “mosaic” theory of the Fourth Amendment, by a 5-4 vote. According to the docket entry, there were two dissents from denial of rehearing. Judge Sentelle wrote one dissent that was […]
NYT “Room for Debate” Blog on Prosecuting Terrorists in Federal Court
You can find links to five essays on that topic here. My own response as part of the NYT blog debate is here.
Ted Koppel on Changes in the TV News Business
Read it here. A depressing account, especially as it suggests that the Golden Age — Golden at its best, at least — was inevitably just a temporary window.
Clarity in Supreme Court Opinions, and the Role of Concurrences
Adam Liptak has a somewhat puzzling critique of Supreme Court opinions in the New York Times. Two quick responses: 1. No matter what Supreme Court opinions look like, there will always be someone who criticizes them for not being clear enough. If an opinion is long, the criticism will be that the opinion has too […]
Question for Law Students and Recent Law Grads
Have you ever cheated on a law school exam? For purposes of the question, construe “cheating” broadly to include getting outside help when not permitted, violating the rules of the exam to get an advantage, and the like. No. Yes, on a take-home exam. Yes, on an in-class exam. Yes, on both take-home and in-class […]
Do New High-Tech Scans at the Airport Violate the Fourth Amendment?
Some airports have begun using backscatter x-ray and millimeter-wave technology scanners to look for weapons and explosive devices on passengers to stop terrorist attacks. The new devices have raised privacy concerns, fueled in no small part by this YouTube video and by the prominence given to the issue at the Drudge Report. Some readers have […]
Draft Proposal of the National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform
After a quick read of the Draft Proposal, I can’t say I understand all of it. But I pretty much agree with the parts that I do understand. What do you think?
Law Prof Blog Traffic Ranking
Paul Caron has the scoop, at least for blogs that have public SiteMeters. The VC’s traffic has been steady for the last 2-3 years, it seems, neither going up nor down much beyond occasional blips due to big stories.
“Kristallnacht and Memory”
Eric Muller has a post by that title at Faculty Lounge.
George W. Bush on the Miers and Alito Nominations
Over at her Crossroads blog, Jan Crawford reports on what George W. Bush’s memoir of his presidency says about his Supreme Court selection process. “After he tapped Roberts for chief justice when William Rehnquist died,” Crawford explains, “he only considered women candidates to replace O’Connor” because Bush “didn’t like the idea of the Supreme Court […]
People v. La Voie and Killing in Self-Defense
I recently taught one of my favorite criminal law cases, People v. LaVoie, 395 P.2d 1001 (Colo. 1964), and I thought readers might enjoy weighing in on the case. LaVoie is a self-defense case that is only a page long, so the facts are very simple. The ultimate question is, did the defendant have a […]