Christopher Buccafusco and Christopher Sprigman have a very interesting article, Valuing Intellectual Property: An Experiment, in the latest Cornell Law Review. From the introduction: In this Article, we present an experiment that demonstrates a substantial valuation asymmetry between authors of poems and potential purchasers of them. As we explain, we created a market for poems […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Stopping A Stopped School Bus, Part 2
Reader subpatre chimes in with an interesting update about Wednesday’s post on the Virginia traffic law making it a reckless driving offense to fail to “stop . . . . a stopped school bus.” In the initial post, I had googled the statute and had copied the version from Justia.com. Here was the first sentence […]
To Keep the Latest Ilya-Orin Exchange ….
…from being stuck in an infinite loop of main posts, I’ll respond to Ilya’s latest post in the comment thread to his post immediately below and close comments here.
“Not Unlimited” Is Not the Same As “Significantly Limited”: A Reply To Ilya
Just a quick reply to Ilya’s response on the scope of the Commerce Clause. In my view, the basic problem with Ilya’s argument is that it mixes up two different claims: (1) Congress does not have unlimited power, and (2) Congress has significantly limited power. The Supreme Court has said (1). But it has not […]
“Three Strikes” Challenger Charged With Four Murders
The Los Angeles Times reports: To hear him tell his story, John Wesley Ewell was the victim of an overly harsh criminal justice system. The South Los Angeles hairstylist complained to journalists over the last decade about the unfairness of the state’s tough three-strikes law, saying he lived in fear that even a small offense […]
Cory Maye Gets A New Trial
As a former co-counsel for Cory Maye, back in 2006 when I helped on his case when it was still in the trial court, I am delighted to report that today the Mississippi Supreme Court ruled that Maye is entitled to a new trial because of errors in the jury instructions on the defense-of-others defense. […]
Law Professors With Ph.D.s Versus Those Without Ph.D.s: Which Group Has More Scholarly Impact?
Someone should write a student note comparing the productivity and scholarly impact of entry-level law professors who have Ph.D.s with those who do not. Pick your measure of productivity and scholarly impact — citations, number of articles, etc. — and then run the numbers for the law professors who have been teaching for 10 years […]
Geof Bradfield — A Jazz Musician Deserving of Wider Recognition
I’m always on the look-out for new jazz musicians, and one discovery I’ve made in the last two years has been a relatively obscure Chicago-based tenor player, Geof Bradfield. He reminds me a bit of Chris Potter, but he’s even more fluid and quick than Potter and has lots of ideas. He’s a real joy […]
How Do We Know What is An “Activity” for Commerce Clause Purposes?
I appreciate Ilya’s post below on the meaning of “activity” in Commerce Clause jurisprudence, and I wanted to add two brief observations: 1) If I understand Ilya’s argument, he begins with an assumption as to how much power Congress has, and he then reasons backwards to infer the meaning of “activity” in order to make […]
Civility in Public Discourse
Peter Wehner has a very good essay on civility as a political virtue over at Commentary’s Contentions blog. An excerpt: The argument is sometimes made, directly or obliquely, that civility is merely a guise, the first step toward bipartisan compromises that betray conservative principles. And at times there is something to this critique. Civility has […]
Federalist Society Faculty Conference and Student Conference
The Federalist Society has announced the details of two conferences of interest: First, the annual Faculty Conference, aka the shadow conference that occurs along with the AALS conference every January; and second, the annual Student Conference, which will be held this year at UVA Law School on February 25th and 26 on the subject of […]
Reckless Driving for “Failing to Stop, When Approaching From Any Direction, A School Bus Which Is Stopped”
Virginia Code ยง 46.2-859, Passing A Stopped School Bus, states, with the key section in bold: A person is guilty of reckless driving who fails to stop, when approaching from any direction, any school bus which is stopped on any highway, private road or school driveway for the purpose of taking on or discharging children. […]
Szymuszkiewicz Update
Back on September 10, I had a long post criticizing some dicta in a wiretapping opinion by Judge Easterbrook: The Perils of Interpreting Statutes With Multiple Remedial Schemes: A Comment on the Dicta in United States v. Szymuszkiewicz. Apparently DOJ wasn’t very happy with the language, either, as I understand the government filed a motion […]
Questioning Judge Reinhardt’s Impartiality
Over at Bench Memos, Ed Whelan argues that Judge Reinhardt is obligated to recuse himself from the Prop 8 appeal because his wife, Ramona Ripston, executive director of the ACLU of Southern California, was consulted about whether to bring the case in the first place. Ed suggests that his wife’s role before the case was […]
Ah, Reinhardt
As Dale notes below, the randomly chosen panel of the Ninth Circuit that will be hearing the Prop 8 case includes Stephen Reinhardt, the most-reversed Court of Appeals judge in the land. I’m reminded of this famous line from Casablanca: Michael Hawkins is also on the panel, and in my experience he pretty reliably votes […]