It is always a pleasure when Randy responds to one of my posts that touches on his areas of expertise. Here are a few thoughts in reply to Randy: 1) I fear there is a misunderstanding as to what comparison I made in my post to which Randy responds. In my post, I compared the […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
One Perspective on the Scope of Federal Power “In the Commercial Sphere”
I recently was reminded of this quote about Commerce Clause doctrine and I thought I would put it out there for comment in light of the recent debates on the constitutionality of the individual mandate: [T]he Court as an institution and the legal system as a whole have an immense stake in the stability of […]
The Individual Mandate Debate as a Replay of McDonald v. City of Chicago
The more I participate in discussions on the constitutionality of the indivdiual mandate, the more it feels to me like a replay of last year’s discussions on the Privileges or Immunities Clause on the road to McDonald v. City of Chicago. In both cases, the issue is whether the Supreme Court will adopt limitations on […]
Law & Order: SVU — What They Get Right and What They Get Wrong
My law school friend Allison Leotta, a federal prosecutor who specializes in sex crimes, is blogging about each episode of Law & Order: SVU to explain what in each episode was realistic and what was not. Allison also has a new novel out with Simon & Schuster, The Law of Attraction, about, well, a Harvard […]
Congrats to Randy, But Then A Missing Argument
Congratulations to Randy Barnett in particular for the new Florida decision refusing to dismiss the challenge to the individual mandate. The language the judge uses at various points in the opinion very closely resembles the language Randy has used in framing the challenge. That is a major accomplishment. Indeed, reading the opinion, I had to […]
More on Harlan Before Hand
Following my earlier post on Justice Harlan appearing before Learned Hand, Roy Englert writes in to point out an interesting story about another appeal with Harlan in front of Judge Hand. It is recounted in Martin Mayer’s biography of Emory Buckner, at page 239: On appeal in [a particularly complicated case], Harlan wrote a brief […]
Harlan Before Hand
I was just reading a fascinating old Fourth Amendment decision, United States v. Kirschenblatt, 16 F.2d 202 (2d Cir. 1926), and I realized the appeal featured one of my favorite Justices appearing before one of my favorite Judges. John Marshall Harlan II represented the United States as an Assistant U.S. Attorney (back when Emory Buckner […]
Is Procrastination Rational?
The current issue of The New Yorker has this interesting article on procrastination, which, appropriately, I just read instead of doing actual work I need to finish. It seems to me that procrastination is rational to the extent we can’t be sure of future events. As uncertainty about future events increases, putting off preparations now […]
The Competition for Supreme Court Cases
Adam Liptak has an important front-page story in The New York Times about how Supreme Court specialists look for cases to take to the Supreme Court. The story presents a pretty accurate picture of how tough the competition is for cases likely to get to the Supreme Court. These days, if you’re a lawyer who […]
Audio of the Week’s Supreme Court Arguments
The Supreme Court has posted the audio files from the oral arguments this week. You can find them here. I’m in Central Park right now listening to the Phelps argument on my iPad. Pretty cool.
The Individual Mandate and Applying Versus Inventing Doctrine
In his post on the new district court decision upholding the individual mandate, my co-blogger Randy writes: I do not believe Judge Steeh relied upon existing Supreme Court doctrine because of his claim that this was a case “of first impression” and therefore not covered by that doctrine. This presents a new debate: Has the […]
New Law Professor Group Blog: The CockleBur
Please give a warm blogospheric welcome to a promising new law blog, The CockleBur. The proof of the pudding is in the blogging, but The CockleBur has some terrific academics in the line-up: Erwin Chemerinsky of the University of California at Irvine; Ron Sullivan, Susan Farbstein and Tyler Giannini of Harvard; Richard Friedman of the […]
If It’s Necessary and Proper, Then It’s Proper: A Reply to Ilya
I’ve enjoyed my exchange with Ilya on the health care mandate, although I find myself in the exchange becoming increasingly of the view that this isn’t a difficult issue under current Supreme Court caselaw. Here’s one more round to try to sharpen the debate between us. The crux of the disagreement between Ilya and I […]
NPR’s “On Point” on the Rutgers Suicide, Cyberbullying, and Internet Crime Law
I was on the NPR program “On Point” today discussing the Rutgers suicide and criminal liability for invasions of privacy online. You can listen to the program here; I come in at the 13-minute mark. Here’s the blurb about the program from the “On Point” homepage: Tyler Clementi was eighteen years old. He closed the […]
More on the Constitutionality of the Individual Mandate
I appreciate Ilya’s reply to my post on the constitutionality of the individual mandate. Three points in response: 1) Ilya suggests that the Supreme Court has never answered what makes legislation “proper,” and he suggests a first-principles argument for why there may be limits on what is “proper” that would permit the Supreme Court to […]