Author Archive | Orin Kerr

Some Tentative Thoughts on the Constitutionality of the Individual Mandate Under Current Supreme Court Doctrine

I haven’t blogged any detailed thoughts on the constitutionality of the individual mandate, as I’m not an expert in the Commerce Clause or the Necessary and Proper Clause. But I’ve been pondering some of the issues, and I have some tentative thoughts on the constitutionality of the mandate based on current Supreme Court doctrine that […]

Continue Reading 112

Documentary About Adjusting to Life After Prison

About a year ago, I purchased a copy of Goro Toshima’s excellent documentary, A Hard Straight, on the challenges convicts face re-adjusting to life on the outside after their prison terms have ended. Toshima has now posted a 15-minute excerpt of the documentary that you can watch here. Important stuff.

Continue Reading 57

A Generation of Roberts v. Kagan?

Jan Crawford ends her interesting report on Elena Kagan’s first day on the bench, linked to by Jonathan Adler below, with this comment: If you’re a liberal who hopes [Kagan] will be an intellectual force who builds coalitions, you had to like what you saw. And if you’re a conservative, you had reasons to feel […]

Continue Reading 89

O’Donnell Ad: “I’m Not a Witch”

Having grown up in Delaware, and being one who still regularly travels there, I remain fascinated by Christine O’Donnell’s Senate candidacy. Given that O’Donnell is doing very little campaigning — an unusual approach in Delaware, where voters generally expect to meet the candidates one-on-one — I was particularly interested in her new TV advertisement, via […]

Continue Reading 166

Supreme Court Holding Good-Faith-for-New-Law Fourth Amendment Petition

DOJ’s cert petition in United States v. Gonzalez, 10-82, a case on the good-faith exception to the Fourth Amendment, was distributed for last week’s “long conference.” The case did not appear on the Court’s list of granted cases nor its list of denied cases, however. That means either the case will be formally relisted for […]

Continue Reading 11

Moving Right But Not Too Far For The Public: It Must Be “Magic”

First, consider some headlines about the Supreme Court from major news sources: The New York Times, July 2010: “Court Under Roberts Is Most Conservative in Decades” Los Angeles Times, January 2010: “A Bold Conservative Step by Supreme Court” USA Today, June 2009: “High Court Curves In Conservative Direction” Washington Post, June 2007: “Narrow Victories Move […]

Continue Reading 104

Justice Kagan at Oral Argument

At the first oral argument this morning, Justice Elena Kagan was very much in the thick of things. Based on my skim of the transcript, Kagan asked five questions for the Petitioner and five questions for the Respondent. Here was Kagan’s first question: JUSTICE KAGAN: Mr. Burke, if we could stay with this. The $471 […]

Continue Reading 9

County Resident Declines to Pay For Fire Protection and Then His House Catches on Fire

Here’s an interesting question about the proper scope of government arising from Obion County, Tennessee. The county does not have its own fire department, and instead relies on the fire protection services of the nearby City of Fulton. But there’s a catch: The City of Fulton does not automatically serve residents of the county. If […]

Continue Reading 335

VC Photo Caption Contest

With the new Supreme Court Term about to start, Elena Kagan was publicly sworn in on Friday as the newest Supreme Court Justice. Which means it’s time for another VC Photo Caption Contest. Here’s the photo: UPDATE: The winner so far is Ian H. Spedding, who had this caption: “You don’t need to see my […]

Continue Reading 124

Obama Names First D.C. Circuit Nominee

The nominee is Caitlin Halligan, an appellate lawyer from New York who was formerly a law clerk for Patricia Wald on the D.C. Circuit and Justice Breyer on the Supreme Court. The BLT has an interesting report on the nomination here. I don’t know anything about Halligan myself, but given the importance of the nomination […]

Continue Reading 46

Powered by WordPress. Designed by Woo Themes