It is a big night for the Tea Party — and, very likely, the Democratic Party — in my former home state of Delaware: Christine O’Donnell beat out Michael Castle for the Delaware GOP Senate nomination 53% to 47%. It’s an amazing result given the history of Delaware politics. The contrast couldn’t be more stark. […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Crime Rates Continue to Fall
According to the FBI. This is wonderful news, although I doubt it will receive a lot of press attention. UPDATE: Thanks to our commenters for explaining why the crime rate is going down: The answer, according to the comments, is any theory that tends to confirm your pre-conceived views.
This Counts as a Negative Review
Over at The New Ledger, Leon Wolf has a brutal and yet strangely riveting review of Meghan McCain’s new book Dirty, Sexy Politics. Just a taste from the conclusion: On the whole, I am simply not a talented enough writer to express how truly horrible this book was. The last line of the book implores […]
Using Hypotheticals When Debating Law in the Blogosphere
Lawyers often explore legal arguments by offering “hypotheticals,” or “hypos” for short. A hypothetical is a “what if” scenario designed to question a legal principle. The idea is to change the facts to something very different than the one before us to see how the offered legal principle would apply to that set of facts. […]
Ninth Circuit Balks in BALCO Case, Denying Super En Banc in United States v. Comprehensive Drug Testing But Amending Opinion To Remove Challenged Section
The new opinion is here, and it comes almost a year after the DOJ petitioned for super-en-banc rehearing. On a very quick read, it seems that the weird mandatory rules part of Judge Kozinski’s initial en banc majority opinion in CDT is now just part of a Kozinski concurrence to what has been relabeled a […]
The Answer is 1,281
The Question: What is the maximum number of comments permitted by VC’s blogging software? (As determined by the “ultimate legal blog comment” thread.) You might think reaching the maximum of 1,281 comments as we did in that thread shows that the Internet is one grand waste of time. But I ask you this: Have two […]
Open Thread
What’s on your mind? Please keep it civil, as always.
Reflecting on September 11, 2001
It was nine years ago today. Consider this an open thread for readers to post their thoughts and reflections on 9/11 — the events of that day, responses to it, and lessons we should learn from both.
“The Quickly Unraveling Clerkship Market”
Dave Hoffman has a very interesting post by that title over at Concurring Opinions.
Average Billing Rates Charged by Washington DC Lawyers
The BLT reports: A massive study of billing rates shows that law firm partners in Washington charge the second-highest hourly rate in the nation. On average, partners here bill just over $600 an hour, second only to New York City, where partners charge close to $700 an hour, according to the study by CT TyMetrix […]
The Perils of Interpreting Statutes With Multiple Remedial Schemes: A Comment on the Dicta in United States v. Szymuszkiewicz
The Seventh Circuit decided an interesting Wiretap Act case today that was largely a replay of United States v. Councilman, the First Circuit case that I blogged about here a bunch of times back in 2004 to 2005. In the new case, United States v. Szymuszkiewicz (glad I don’t have to pronounce that one), the […]
Rosslyn Jazz Festival on Saturday
We have a lot of readers in the DC area, so I thought I would flag a particularly good line-up at the annual Rosslyn Jazz Festival on Saturday. As always, the Jazz Festival is free, and with lovely weather expected for Saturday the event should be a real treat. The location is Gateway Park, the […]
Podcast on GPS Surveillance, Open Fields, and the Fourth Amendment
I recorded it yesterday for the Legal Talk Network, and it runs about 30 minutes; you can listen here. We start off by discussing Judge Kozinski’s stirring dissent from denial of rehearing en banc in United States v. Pineda-Moreno, which has received a lot of press attention. Among the questions discussed: Who lives in gated […]
Third Circuit Rules That Magistrate Judges Have Discretion to Reject non-Warrant Court Order Applications and Require Search Warrants to Obtain Historical Cell-Site Records
A while back, I blogged at length about the Third Circuit’s pending case involving government access to historical cell-site records. The issue in the case is what legal standard the government must satisfy to obtain orders requiring phone companies to disclose such information. The district court had ruled that a warrant was required, and the […]
Law Clerk Ideology and the Principal-Agent Problem
Jonathan links below to Adam Liptak’s front-page New York Times article on the ideology of law clerks, and Jason Mazzone’s critique of it. Echoing the point at the end of Mazzone’s critique, I think the ideology of law clerks roughly matches that of the Justices because the Justices are trying to solve the principal-agent problem. […]