This is the open-thread on same-sex marriage promised by the post above.
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
An Interesting VC Reader Poll Result on Same-Sex Marriage
Among the interesting results of the VC readership polls on same-sex marriage, I was particularly intrigued by the answers to when the Constitution began to require gay marriage. This question was only supposed to be answered by those who believe that the Constitution presently requires state recognition of same-sex marriage. 526 readers responded so far. […]
Reader Polls on Same-Sex Marriage
I wanted to do a few reader opinion polls on matters related to gay marriage. Of course, different readers will have different views of how useful these polls are. But I’m curious, so here goes. (Oh yeah, and sorry for the strange formatting: There’s some sort of incompatibility between our software and Pollhost’s, and right […]
Associate Justice Elena Kagan
It’s official: Elena Kagan is now Justice Kagan.
D.C. Circuit Introduces “Mosaic Theory” Of Fourth Amendment, Holds GPS Monitoring a Fourth Amendment Search
Today the D.C. Circuit held that government use of a GPS device to monitor the location of a car on public roads is a Fourth Amendment “search” when conducted over a long-term period (in his case, a month). The case is United States v. Maynard, and it was written by Judge Douglas Ginsburg and joined […]
SALTLAW Blog
I just learned that SALT — the Society of American Law Teachers, as which bills itself as “a community of progressive law teachers working for justice, diversity and academic excellence” — has a blog: The SALTLAW Blog. Worth checking out.
Total Votes “For” And “Against” the Last Four Supreme Court Nominees
Total votes for and against the Republican Nominees (Roberts in 2005, Alito in 2006): 136 for, 64 against. Total votes for and against the Democratic Nominees (Sotomayor in 2009, Kagan in 2010): 131 for, 68 against. Very close. Plus, if you take out the votes of Democratic Senators for Republican nominees where the Senators have […]
In Other Legal News
Today we’re mostly focused on the important district court decision yesterday in Perry v. Schwarzenegger, but I note there was also an important confirmation vote in the last hour or so. Congratulations, Justice-to-be Elena Kagan.
More on Whether the Facts Matter in Perry v. Schwarzenegger
Over at CoOp, Dave Hoffman has more on the relative importance of the facts in Perry: [T]here are facts, and then there are constitutional facts. Almost every “fact” identified by Judge Walker is of the latter type — “Sexual orientation is a fundamental characteristic of a human being.”; “marriage is widely regarded as the definitive […]
How Much Do the Factual Findings Matter in Perry v. Schwarzenegger?
Judge Walker’s opinion in the same-sex marriage case is notable for its factual record. As a commenter to Andrew Sullivan’s blog writes: What strikes me about Judge Walker’s opinion is the amount of evidence he included there – numbered, paraphrased facts with direct citation to and quotation from the trial record. As a lawyer, I […]
How Do You Apply the Rational Basis Test to a Restoration of Prior Law?
I’m sure some people have thought a lot about this issue, and I hope they’ll bear with me as I pose an amateurish question: Should it matter to the constitutionality of Prop 8 that it was passed as part of a ballot initiative that restored preexisting law? Here’s my thinking. Let’s say there’s a really […]
The Pace of Social Change and the Rational Basis Test
A lot of the legal issues in Judge Walker’s opinion have been addressed elsewhere, but I wanted to focus on one narrow part of the opinion raising an issue of particular interest to me: Whether and when the pragmatic concerns abut rapidly changing social institutions provide a rational basis for rejecting such changes. In the […]
Key Language From Judge Walker’s Opinion
Much of Judge Walker’s opinion focus on the facts, and why he concludes that there is no rational basis on which a person can oppose same-sex marriage. But here’s a key passage from the law section of the opinion, on pages 113-14 (with citations to the record omitted): The right to marry has been historically […]
Brilliant People Agree With Me
One of the consequences of confirmation bias is that we are overly impressed by ideas that we happen to share. It’s a natural instinct, if not watched carefully. If you read something that reflects or resonates with your own views, you’ll agree with it. Upon agreeing with it, you’ll think it is highly persuasive. And […]
Vermeule on Living Constitutionalism
Adrian Vermeule, who is one of my favorite legal scholars writing today, has this interesting review in The New Republic of new books on constitutional interpretation by David Strauss and the trio of Goodwin Liu, Pam Karlan, and Chris Schroeder. Thanks to Howard for the link.