Perhaps if you spend that stint in the Southern District of New York in Manhattan. Over at the Glom, David Zaring reports on his effort to identify what former federal prosecutors in Manhattan are doing these days. Out of 150 former federal prosecutors, he reports, “the large majority . . . are partners in white […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Call for Papers, AALS Annual Meeting
I just wanted to remind lawprof readers that several sections of the AALS have a Call for Papers out for its January 2011 Meeting in San Francisco. For example, my colleague Greg Maggs informs me that the Section on Commercial and Related Consumer Law has posted a call for papers on the federal Credit Card […]
McKenna v. Edgell and Civil Liability for Police Officers Responding to 911 Calls for Assistance
Yesterday, a divided panel of the Sixth Circuit decided a Fourth Amendment case on civil liability for police officers who respond to 911 calls to provide medical assistance. The case, McKenna v. Edgell, was written by Judge Karen Nelson Moore, with Judge Rogers dissenting. It seems to me that the majority opinion is based on […]
Randall Kennedy on Affirmative Action
Randall Kennedy, one of my favorite writers on race issues, has a provocative essay on affirmative action in the American Prospect. Kennedy’s argument is that in the last 20 years, the diversity rationale for affirmative action has proved surprisingly effective at making affirmative action considerably less controversial than it used to be. From the conclusion: […]
People Who Disagree With Me Are Just Arguing In Bad Faith
I explained before why brilliant people agree with me. I want to talk about the other side of the picture. I’ve come to the realization that people who disagree with me are just arguing in bad faith. How do I know? Well, when I get into an argument, no one who disagrees with me ever […]
Whatever Happened to the Request for Super-En-Banc Rehearing in CDT?
Once in a while folks ask me what happened to the request for super-en-banc rehearing in the Ninth Circuit, filed back in November of last year, in United States v. Comprehensive Drug Testing. The short answer is, nothing has happened. Nine months later, the Ninth Circuit hasn’t ruled yet on whether to go super-en-banc. If […]
Constitutional Theory Debates in a Nutshell (Or a Lot of Them, Anyway)
In Year Zero, a new constitutional provision is enacted that has two provisions, A1 and B1. In Year X, provisions A1 and B1 no longer seem to make as much sense as they did in Year Zero. Soon after, the Supreme Court interprets A1 to mean A2 and B1 to mean B2. A few decades […]
Generic Op-Ed for Judge Walker’s SSM Decision
With lots of media attention focused on Judge Walker’s SSM decision, I decided to write a generic op-ed that any paper or website can use. Just pick the right word you want in parenthesis — conservatives pick the first word, and liberals pick the second. FOLLOW THE CONSTITUTION Judge Walker’s decision on same-sex marriage is […]
“Stay True to the Constitution”
Based on recent comment threads, both sides in the debate on the constitutionality of SSM are extremely confident that they are right and their cause is just and true. All that confidence makes it a little hard to tell the two sides apart. For example, I came across the following comment about what the Supreme […]
Who Will Be on the Ninth Circuit Panel in Perry?
The liberal blog Empty Wheel has an interesting post on which three Ninth Circuit judges might be on the appellate panel (edit: just to be clear, I mean the Ninth Circuit merits panel, not the motions panel that will hear the stay denial in the next few days): There has not yet been a formal […]
Will Perry v. Schwarzenegger Be Moot By the Time it Reaches the Supreme Court?
David S. Cohen has this very interesting post on that question at Faculty Lounge. UPDATE: Upon hearing the news that Judge Walker denied a stay on appeal, but will allow a six-day window to let the defendant-intervenors seek one from higher courts, I plugged in my MagnaZen X53b Crystal Ball and turned it on. It […]
Explaining the Wide Range of Answers on When the Right to Same-Sex Marriage Was Created
In an earlier reader poll, I asked readers who believe that the Constitution requires states to recognize same-sex marriage to indicate when the Constitution began to require it. The results were fascinating: Readers disagreed widely as to the answer, with responses spread pretty evenly among the different centuries and periods of U.S. constitutional history. What, […]
Interesting Similarity Between Two VC Reader Polls
I had a sense of deja vu reading over the results of the VC reader poll on same-sex marriage. Here are the key results. First, as a matter of policy: Favor same-sex marrriage: 61% Oppose same-sex marriage: 33% Don’t know: 6% Second, as a matter of constitutional law: Laws banning same-sex marriage are constitutional: 54% […]
James Robinson, Former Head of DOJ’s Criminal Division, Dead at 66
I am very saddened to hear that James Robinson, the Assistant Attorney General in charge of the Criminal Division in the late 1990s, has died of cancer at the all-too-young age of 66. Robinson was the head of the Criminal Division when I was a brand-new attorney at DOJ. I remember it was a real […]
A Question for Readers Who Think The Constitution Required States to Recognize Same-Sex Marriage Before 1900
This is a follow-up to my post below on the reader polls about attitudes toward same-sex marriage. In the fourth of the four polls, I asked readers who think that the Constitution requires states to recognize same-sex marriage to say when the Constitution began to require it. Slightly more than half the readers who answered […]